Stanford University scientists killed off roughly half of a mouse’s brain on purpose, then filled the empty space with human tissue, and the resulting mouse did better on tests than mice carrying the same damage with nothing put back in the brain hole. That is the actual result of a study published this month in Nature by neuroscientist Sergiu Pa?ca. It deserves attention well beyond the medical journals because it describes something the Philippines has been doing to its own institutions for 50 years without the benefit of a laboratory.
The mechanics are almost too similar to ignore. Researchers engineered mice so that the cells destined to become the cortex and hippocampus, the parts of the brain responsible for higher reasoning and memory, died off early. Those two regions normally make up about half a mouse’s brain. The animals survived anyway, a little forgetful, a little clumsy, running on whatever was left. Then the scientists injected several hundred thousand human cells, grown from reprogrammed human skin cells, into the vacant real estate.
Within two to three months, the graft had grown to nearly five times its original size, occupying more than 90 percent of the missing cortex, with a human neuron count nearing four million. It plugged into the mouse’s circulatory system, began generating electrical activity on its own, and extended nerve fibers as far as the spinal cord. Researchers even found neurons resembling Von Economo cells, specialized cells linked to social behavior in mammals, growing inside a rodent that will never attend an office Christmas party. The maze results told the same story with the mice carrying the graft consistently outpacing mice whose damaged cortex had been left empty.
Pa?ca’s own framing was that psychiatry and neurology have fewer treatments than almost any other branch of medicine, largely because the human brain is too inaccessible to study directly. So, they built a mouse that could carry a piece of human brain around for them to observe. The scientists insist that the animals are not thinking like humans and remain, in every functional sense, mice. It is the movie Ratatouille in reverse. Instead of a rat’s brain under the chef’s hat doing the human’s cooking, it is human tissue under a mouse’s skull helping the mouse survive.
Filipinos have watched a version of this experiment run at national scale for two generations. Domestic manufacturing capacity, the cortex of any developing economy, was allowed to waste away while remittances from a large and growing population of overseas Filipino workers and a business process outsourcing sector built on other countries’ back-office needs filled the vacant space.
The transplanted tissue took over nicely. It grew, and it now accounts for a share of gross domestic product that keeps consumption humming along well enough that nobody in Malacañang loses much sleep over the industrial base nobody built. That is the same result the mouse study produced, better than the version with nothing put in the hole at all, which is not the same as healthy.
The question the mice cannot ask, because they lack the cortex for it, is the one that matters. What happens when the environment changes and the substitute was never built for the problem it now has to solve? The grafted human cortex is still wired to a mouse body. OFW earnings are wired to host-country hiring, visa rules, and oil-state payrolls. BPO earnings are wired to corporate cost-cutting and to software that is getting better every year at doing without a night shift in Manila. Those grafts still work, but they are not a factory floor, a supplier network, or an export mix that survives the day someone else’s back office gets automated.
A transplant that beats an empty socket is not a transplant that beats the original, and confusing the two is how a country talks itself into believing a workaround is a cure. The Philippines has spent two generations passing the tests built around the hole it already has, with foreign exchange coming in, consumption ticking along, the lights staying on, and by those measures it has reasonably often passed. What none of those tests ask is the harder question of whether an economy that outsourced its industrial base to other people’s factories and other people’s paychecks can still grow the thing it gave up, if it ever needs to.
Stanford’s mice will spend their lives being useful to researchers who are not particularly curious what a mouse would have done with its own brain, given time. A country gets to ask that question of itself. The Philippines has not done so yet, and the tests it keeps passing were never designed to force the issue.
E-mail me at mangun@gmail.com. Follow me on Twitter @mangunonmarkets. PSE stock-market information and technical analysis provided by AAA Southeast Equities Inc.