A banker who spent more than three decades building his career found himself fighting to protect his livelihood and retirement after an ATM fraud investigation unfolded against the backdrop of his battle with cancer.
At 57, Robert Ochola was undergoing chemotherapy when a Sh2.5 million cash discrepancy at National Bank of Kenya’s Kapsabet branch led to his arrest, suspension and eventual dismissal.
But in a judgment delivered last week that has offered him a second chance of financial security, the Employment and Labour Relations Court found that the bank had failed to prove he was responsible for the fraud and ordered it to convert his dismissal into early retirement with full benefits.
The fraud investigation occurred as Mr Ochola was undergoing chemotherapy for colorectal cancer, taking time off to recover after treatment and coping with the death of his brother, circumstances the court said the bank ought to have considered when handling the disciplinary process.
‘These were factors that would seriously compromise the ability of any employee to be alert and which the Respondent ought to have taken into account when handling the disciplinary case against the Claimant,” said Justice Maureen Onyango.
Mr Ochola joined the bank on December 14, 1992, as a bank clerk. He rose through the ranks to become Branch Operations Manager at Kapsabet, earning a consolidated monthly salary of Sh247,642.
The dispute began after the bank detected a cash discrepancy of about Sh2.5 million on July 9, 2025. It accused Mr Ochola of compromising ATM keys and the combination passkey, allowing the Branch Manager to access the machine alone, and failing to report breaches of security procedures.
It also linked him to transactions involving a bank customer and a Sh2.5 million transfer from an account belonging to Mosoriot Sub-County Hospital, made without debit vouchers or customer instructions. Mr Ochola denied wrongdoing.
He told the disciplinary panel that the drawer holding the keys was faulty and could not be locked. He said he had reported the problem verbally to the Branch Manager, his immediate supervisor.
He denied sharing his password or combination, although he acknowledged that the manager sometimes accessed the ATM alone. In re-examination, Mr Ochola said he ‘had not shared his ATM password’ and ‘had reported the faulty drawer to the Branch Manager’.
The bank’s evidence showed that the Branch Manager was an authorised alternative for the keys and combination. Investigators found that the manager had accessed the ATM alone, including before Mr Ochola’s shift and on Saturdays.
Employee Relations Manager Ezra Nyagah said Mr Ochola had left a note containing login credentials and failed to report the manager’s conduct. But Ms Nyagah acknowledged it would be unfair to blame Mr Ochola for the faulty drawer itself, and confirmed that he had reported the defect to the manager.
The court considered whether the bank had proved Mr Ochola’s own responsibility, rather than merely showing that security procedures had been breached.
Justice Onyango found that the bank had not proved he negligently compromised the keys or password. Nor had it established what further protective action he should have taken after reporting the faulty drawer to his supervisor. The judge questioned why CCTVs had not detected the branch manager’s solo access.
The judge found that the branch manager’s access to the ATM ‘was a fraudulent scheme of the Branch Manager who exploited the weaknesses in the guidelines and operations of the Bank to steal from the ATM”.
She also found that the branch manager’s senior position did not permit him to bypass dual-control rules. The bank said the branch manager admitted responsibility and refunded Sh2.4 million, but that did not automatically clear Mr Ochola. The bank still had to establish each employee’s individual role.
The investigation was unfolding as Mr Ochola underwent cancer treatment, which necessitated his being absent after every chemotherapy session for three days to recover.
He was diagnosed with colorectal cancer in May 2025 and received chemotherapy. His oncologist, Dr Naftali Busikhala, told the court that the illness affected his ability to work.
The bank suspended Mr Ochola on July 10, 2025. He was arrested the next day and charged with conspiracy to defraud.
He told the employment court that the detention and transport interfered with his chemotherapy sessions. The criminal case was withdrawn on February 13, 2026, but the judge said this was not an acquittal.
The bank issued a show-cause notice on August 5, 2025, and dismissed him on September 1. Mr Ochola appealed, but the bank declined his request for reinstatement on March 6, 2026.
He challenged his dismissal, arguing that the bank unfairly blamed him for the ATM fraud despite his denial of wrongdoing, his report about the faulty drawer holding the ATM keys and the Branch Manager’s role in accessing the machine alone.
Mr Ochola asked the court to declare his dismissal unlawful and unfair, reinstate him or grant compensation and his employment benefits, including salary arrears, medical expenses and retirement benefits.
He contended that the bank’s actions caused him immense psychological distress, public humiliation and reputational harm, particularly during the criminal proceedings.
However, the court found the termination procedure fair because Mr Ochola received notice, responded to the allegations, attended a hearing, was offered a companion and pursued an appeal. It also ruled the dismissal substantively unfair because the bank had not proved his culpability.
‘On the totality of the evidence, the respondent established that the branch manager improperly accessed the ATM and was responsible for the loss. It did not sufficiently establish the claimant’s separate culpability, particularly in light of the evidence that he reported the defective drawer to the very supervisor who subsequently exploited the access arrangements,” said Justice Onyango.
The bank said it did not know of his diagnosis before the disciplinary hearing and referred to its wellness policy.
Rather than order reinstatement, the judge directed the bank to convert the dismissal into early retirement with full benefits. It directed the bank to restore his salary and contractual benefits from suspension until retirement. Salary arrears will attract court-rate interest from the date of judgment.
The bank was also directed to meet his medical expenses under its medical scheme up to retirement.
The court declined his other claims, including 12 months’ salary as compensation, future earnings, legal fees, cash bail and damages for malicious prosecution.
It also declined a direct award of Sh382,500 in medical expenses, while ordering continued medical cover under the bank’s scheme until retirement. Pensionable service and contributions are to be restored under the applicable scheme rules.