Epra loses fight over 407cooking gas cylinders seized in Narok

The Energy and Petroleum Regulatory Authority (Epra) has lost an appeal seeking to overturn a tribunal decision that ordered it to release gas cylinders seized from an operator in Narok two years ago.

The High Court upheld the Energy and Petroleum Tribunal’s decision, finding that Epra had failed to prove the alleged regulatory offences against Rihal Energy Company Ltd, whose 407 gas cylinders were seized in October 2024.

“The mere presence of cylinders bearing different brands at the Respondent’s facility did not, without more, establish that the Respondent had committed the specific contraventions alleged,” the court said.

“I accordingly uphold the Tribunal’s finding that the alleged contraventions were not proved,” the judge added.

The dispute arose from an enforcement exercise at Rihal Energy’s liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) facility on October 19, 2024, when EPRA officers allegedly found assorted cylinders bearing different brand markings being loaded onto two motor vehicles.

The regulator seized the cylinders, sealed the premises and subsequently suspended the company’s filling licence for three months, imposing two fines of Sh100,000 for separate alleged contraventions.

Rihal challenged the decision before the Tribunal, arguing that some of the cylinders were held under a reciprocal arrangement among members of the Energy Dealers Association (EDA).

The tribunal set aside EPRA’s determination on August 21, 2025, and ordered the release of 254 proclaimed cylinders and 153 EDA cylinders, prompting the regulator’s appeal.

EPRA argued that the tribunal had misinterpreted the law, ignored documentary evidence, and wrongly interfered with its statutory enforcement mandate.

The regulator maintained that Rihal was licensed to store and fill Raha-branded cylinders only and that its officers had found cylinders belonging to different brands at the facility.

It argued that Regulation 26 of the LPG Regulations preserves ownership of cylinders with the respective brand owners and that a court proclamation could not justify the attachment of third-party property without their consent.

EPRA also defended its enforcement measures, saying sections 11 and 22(4) of the Energy Act empowered it to inspect premises and seal facilities where regulatory contraventions were suspected.

It further maintained that it observed due process by issuing a notice to show cause, receiving Rihal’s response, conducting a hearing and eventually issuing a reasoned determination.

The regulator also questioned the tribunal’s impartiality, taking issue with its description of enforcement officers as having acted “like cowboys” and “like criminal gangsters”.

It argued that the language suggested the tribunal had formed an adverse opinion before objectively considering the evidence.

Rihal opposed the appeal, accusing Epra of regulatory overreach through the unlawful closure of its business, arbitrary seizure of property and a procedurally defective disciplinary process.

The company argued that EPRA had failed to establish that illegal cross-filling had taken place, pointing out that the regulator’s own witness admitted he had not seen anyone filling cylinders when officers entered the premises.

It further maintained that its membership in EDA allowed it to handle cylinders belonging to other association members under a reciprocal arrangement that Epra had been notified about.

On the closure of its premises, Rihal argued that sealing the facility for approximately five months, despite its licence remaining valid, effectively amounted to an unlawful suspension without prior notice or a hearing.

It also accused Epra of withholding photographs allegedly taken during the enforcement exercise, denying it an opportunity to challenge the evidence.

In dismissing the appeal, the High Court found that Epra’s inventories did not adequately distinguish between the proclaimed cylinders and those held under the EDA arrangement.

The photographs allegedly taken during the enforcement exercise had also not been produced before the tribunal.

The judge said Epra was required to demonstrate a sufficient evidentiary connection between the company’s conduct and the prohibited acts forming the basis of its determination.

The court acknowledged discrepancies in Epra’s inventories, which recorded 253 cylinders along a perimeter wall, one on motor vehicle registration number KCY 265S and 131 on motor vehicle registration number KCY 709Y.

These figures did not correspond with the tribunal’s order for the release of 254 proclaimed cylinders and 153 EDA cylinders.

However, the judge said the discrepancy did not, by itself, establish that Rihal had committed regulatory offences or provide sufficient grounds to overturn the release order.

“I therefore find no sufficient basis to interfere with the Tribunal’s conclusion that, in the circumstances established, the enforcement process fell short of the requirements of procedural fairness and proportionality,” the court said.

The judge clarified that the release order did not conclusively determine ownership disputes between Rihal and third-party brand owners.

The court upheld the tribunal’s judgment of August 21, 2025, including the order directing Epra to release the 254 proclaimed cylinders and 153 EDA cylinders to the company.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *