When the influential are above firm’s rules

‘You know how he is. But he brings in the business.’

This is the chief executive’s answer when the finance director raises another complaint about the commercial director humiliating colleagues. There will be another quiet conversation. Anyone else might already have a formal warning on record.

This behaviour ignores the company’s stated respect for every individual. The CEO’s response shows whether commercial or personal influence can override the company’s authority.

The individual’s contribution may be significant. They may have built the business, handled a crisis or brought in important customers. Strong leaders can be demanding. But expecting good work does not justify humiliating people, and commercial success or strong connections do not give permission to ignore standards others must follow.

Influential people become untouchable when others shield them from accountability, by choice or because they have given up trying to act. Complaints are dismissed, disciplinary decisions reversed, and challenges left unsupported. Repeated failure breeds learnt helplessness. People stop exercising authority they still formally hold.

Subtle cues can appear earlier. Managers seek informal approval for decisions already delegated to them. ‘The shareholder would never accept it’ ends a discussion, although nobody asked. Colleagues question proposals privately but fall silent when the influential person presents them.

None of these signs proves misconduct. But together, they can portray an organisation learning to avoid challenge. An expectation about someone’s reaction can become a rule nobody remembers agreeing to.

The problem deepens when the person is the CEO or a major shareholder’s relative. Directors may hesitate to confront a CEO they appointed and supported. A CEO dealing with the relative may fear for their own position. Both can receive protection without asking.

The consequences go beyond those directly affected. Colleagues stop questioning forecasts or explaining why a project is failing. Directors can approve proposals without hearing objections that disappeared before reaching the board.

Every exception the board accepts teaches the organisation something about its values. Management notices whether directors examine how results were achieved. Repeated departures of capable colleagues deserve attention even when performance remains strong and complaints are falling.

Individual conduct cases usually belong with management, and confidentiality limits what others can know. Through anonymised speak-up reports, a board committee can check whether concerns recur, responses change behaviour and whether those who speak up later leave. A case recorded as closed may leave the underlying issue unresolved.

The chair has particular influence. A chair who gives a director an opportunity to explain privately expressed reservations makes disagreement less costly. Responding with ‘I know the person; leave it with me’ can close discussion before the board understands the concern.

Similarly, supporting management’s properly handled decision about someone well connected gives the CEO confidence that their authority holds. A private intervention to secure an exception teaches the opposite. The chair’s personal loyalties can shape culture as much as any board-approved statement.

Earlier decisions preserve room to act. Sharing customer relationships and knowledge, and developing credible successors can reduce dependence and make disagreement less threatening to the business.

Holding someone to account still needs evidence and a chance to respond. Strong personalities attract criticism, sometimes unfairly.

What matters is whether concerns get proper examination regardless of who is involved, and whether those raising them stay safe afterwards.

The claim that ‘we cannot afford to lose them’ is based on an incomplete calculation.

Revenue is visible, but the costs of lost talent, withheld advice and avoidable mistakes are harder to count. Each exception can deepen the dependence used to justify the next one.

The key moment is when someone questions a person whose contribution everyone values.

Whether that concern gets a hearing, and whether the person raising it keeps the support of colleagues and leaders, shows who really holds authority. The board and its chair help shape that response long before a confrontation. Strong institutions make room for exceptional people without making exceptions of them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *