Kenya’s first Data Commissioner on the tough task of policing the country’s data economy

Kenya passed the Data Protection Act, 2019 shortly after the groundbreaking European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), to help protect people’s personal information in a digital age. But even after its implementation and establishment of the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner (ODPC) in 2020, many Kenyans, including big corporations, did not understand the law.

As Immaculate Kassait, Kenya’s first Data Commissioner, leaves office after six years of overseeing the implementation of the Data Protection Act, 2019, she speaks to the Business Daily on the difficult task she had of making the country understand this new law.

She opens up on the challenges of enforcing the law, regulating global technology companies, emerging threats from artificial intelligence and the reforms needed to strengthen data protection in Kenya.

You are leaving office after six years as Kenya’s first Data Commissioner. What have been your biggest achievements?

What I am most proud of is bringing the conversation about data protection from the back office to the living room and, now, into international conversations. It is no longer something people discuss as a foreign concept. Initially, everyone kept asking about GDPR. We have also put Kenya on the map and brought accountability into conversations around data protection.

That, for me, demonstrates impact.

What has the ODPC achieved in terms of enforcement and holding organisations accountable?

We have handled more than 13,000 complaints, issued 459 determinations and taken 206 enforcement and penalty notice actions. We have also registered about 28,000 data controllers and processors.

Our approach is that we identify gaps, whether through compliance assessments, data protection impact assessments or investigations arising from complaints. Where we find shortcomings, we issue enforcement notices requiring institutions to rectify them.

If they fail to comply, we can proceed to penalty notices. Where a data subject requests compensation, we assess the circumstances and determine what is appropriate.

Most of the publicly discussed enforcement actions appear to involve private companies. Has the ODPC been equally tough on government institutions?

We have come hard on government just as we have on the private sector. We have taken enforcement action against the Ministry of Agriculture and issued action against the Migori County Assembly. The difference is that these cases may not receive as much attention as those involving private companies.

Can we do better? Yes. We are not yet where we want to be. There is still room for improvement in government compliance. However, it is a misconception that we have not taken action against public institutions.

Worldcoin’s biometric data collection exercise generated considerable controversy. Do you think the ODPC acted too late in dealing with the company?

I don’t think so. The issue was brought to our attention much earlier, and we had engaged Worldcoin, asking questions about its purpose for processing personal data and the basis for doing so. They kept moving the goalposts.

One of our concerns was their reliance on legitimate interest as a basis for processing. Legitimate interest is applicable in circumstances where there is an existing relationship with the data subject.

Worldcoin was onboarding people for a service that was supposedly going to be available in the future.

Our first intervention was to direct them to stop processing data, which they did. When they subsequently went public, we issued a cautionary advisory to members of the public. We later cancelled their registration.

Following the court order, we also undertook further interventions. Our processes were not found wanting. Some of the work we do is not always visible to the public, but there was a lot happening behind the scenes.

Six years into implementing the Data Protection Act, what loopholes have you identified that need to be addressed?

We have undertaken an audit and identified areas that require reform. One is the expansion of the definition of sensitive personal data. There are emerging issues, including political party membership, that require greater attention.

We also believe penalties should be increased. Another area is expanding the definition and scope of data governance, which is currently quite restrictive.

Artificial intelligence is another major gap. The Act only addresses AI in relation to automated decision-making, yet technology has evolved significantly. These are some of the issues I hope my successor will take forward.

How difficult has it been to enforce the law against multinational technology companies such as Meta and Google?

The beauty about the Data Protection Act is that it has extraterritorial application. We can investigate a data controller processing the personal data of a Kenyan data subject, even when that controller is outside the country.

However, we lack mutual legal assistance powers. Data is not necessarily stored in Kenya, and accessing information held in other jurisdictions can be difficult.

In the BRS (Business Registration Services) breach investigation, for example, we had to seek assistance from other data protection authorities, including in Europe, to identify the controller involved. This is a significant gap that needs to be addressed through legislative reforms.

What about the capacity of the ODPC itself? Have staffing and institutional limitations affected enforcement?

One challenge is the strict timelines for determining complaints. We have 90 days to make determinations, and that can be challenging given the volume and complexity of cases. We would like to see the timelines extended.

I have been fortunate to work with a committed team that has been willing to go the extra mile. However, as the institution grows and its responsibilities expand, there is still room for additional capacity.

How compliant are Kenyan companies with the Data Protection Act as you leave office?

Compliance happens in stages, from awareness to maturity. Some organisations are at level one or two, depending on their sectors. In the financial sector, for instance, because of the importance of trust, some institutions are approaching maturity.

Awareness has improved significantly. When we started, almost 70 per cent of people did not know about data protection. Today, there is much greater awareness.

However, organisations must move beyond awareness. They need to audit their systems, establish where their data is stored, develop governance policies and have mechanisms for responding to data breaches. Different organisations are at different stages.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *