Defense presents parent-witness to explain Carpio’s Kuala Lumpur shoe purchase

Adefense witness at Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial on Thursday testified that lawyer Manases ‘Mans’ Carpio purchased shoes in Malaysia not only for members of the Elite Philippines basketball team, but also for their parents, and their guardians because not every player came from a financially well-off background.

He reportedly did this in his capacity as both manager and mentor to the youth basketball team, in which he took on a ‘co-parent’ role for the players.

During Day 43 of the trial, defense lawyer Justin Gular presented Chadrin Parian, who is also a parent of one of the players in the team, to clarify details about the P256,882 shoe purchase at a Nike store in Kuala Lumpur, a transaction previously flagged by prosecution witness and financial forensic expert Alexander Cabrera.

Parian explained that Carpio bought the shoes for the players, their parents, and their guardians because not every player came from a financially well-off background.

‘I think the children and the parents deserve it,’ Parian told private prosecutor Reynaldo Robles. Robles asked if the purchase by the Vice President’s husband ‘is an example of simple living.’

Speaking in mixed Filipino and English, Parian noted that not everyone can afford to buy shoes. Parian later told Gular that Carpio also bought shoes for the parents and guardians of the team members.

He shared that following the team’s victory in the Malaysian competition, Carpio treated the players and their families to new shoes.

‘We went to Malaysia to compete because the kids had a basketball tournament and by the grace of God, the kids won the championship there,’ he said. He showed the impeachment court pictures of the boxes of Nike shoes and Carpio paying for it.

He further explained that the parents take turns buying sports equipment for the team because not everyone comes from the same financial background.

Defense spokesperson Michael Poa, in a press briefing, asserted that senator-judges should focus on the overall substance and weight of the defense witnesses’ testimonies rather than dwelling solely on specific points of contention.

Lawyer Anel Antero, speaking under questioning by defense lawyer Lindon Bacquel during the 43rd day of the impeachment trial, emphasized that he would not lie for Vice Sara Duterte and her husband, Manases ‘Mans’ Carpio, disputing allegations of unusual credit card spending.

‘Magsisinungaling po ba kayo para kay Manases Carpio? Magsisinungaling din ba kayo para kay Sara Duterte,?’ Bacquel asked, to which Antero said no.

‘I took an oath as a witness and a lawyer. Hindi po ako magsisinungaling [I will not lie],’ Antero added.

Antero told prosecution lawyer Amando Virgil D. Ligutan that he was a long-time friend of the couple, and that he also supported the advocacies of the vice president.

‘I met her way back in 2004. I met him in 1998 in law school. We are friends, and I support her and what she represents,’ he said, adding that he and the vice president’s husband both attended San Beda College of Law School, though they were not classmates.

Antero, also admitted he regularly received compensation from the Duterte couple for his legal services.

A sharp exchange took place between Bacquel and Ligutan after the latter remarked, ‘And that does not deserve a recross-examination, Sir.’

Bacquel then asked the impeachment court to strike from the records Ligutan’s remarks.

billboards do the job socmed

Meanwhile, Antero clarified that the controversial P200,000 meal at Ginza Inakaya in Tokyo on March 19, 2025, was split among 11 people, though it was paid using Carpio’s credit card. The prosecution has questioned the said meal, saying it belied the simple lifestyle that the Duterte couple presented in public.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *