House prosecutors flag ‘newly discovered’ Sara dollar accounts

THE House of Representatives prosecution panel on Thursday flagged ‘newly discovered’ dollar accounts belonging to Vice President Sara Z. Duterte after her defense dropped a Bank of the Philippine Islands (BPI) witness who could have been questioned about the accounts while also challenging the couple’s modest-living claim over a P205,007.29 dinner in Tokyo, Japan.

Private prosecutor James Bryan Ibrahim Alih told the Senate Impeachment Court that documents submitted by BPI included a letter confirming the existence of Duterte’s dollar accounts, which were not covered by the prosecution’s earlier subpoena.

‘We just wanted to highlight certain portions, Your Honor, particularly, say, for example, one letter coming from the BPI where it confirmed that the Vice President had dollar accounts,’ Alih said.

‘This was not within our visibility because the subpoena issued previously did not include dollar accounts,’ he added.

The disclosure came after defense counsel Michael Poa informed the court that the defense would no longer present BPI Senior Vice President Paul Roderick Ysmael, who was supposed to authenticate a letter he had sent to the bank. Poa said Ysmael had already admitted writing the letter during an earlier hearing, making his further testimony unnecessary.

Alih, however, said the prosecution intended to question Ysmael about the additional documents submitted by BPI, particularly the letter concerning Duterte’s dollar accounts. Presiding Officer Sen. Francis Escudero declined to allow the discussion, saying the documents had not yet been formally identified by a witness and that the prosecution could raise the matter through written submissions, closing arguments or rebuttal evidence.

Modest living

PRIVATE prosecutor Virgil Ligutan, meanwhile, asked if a P205,007.29 dinner at Ginza Inakaya in Tokyo on May 19, 2023, was consistent with the constitutional requirement for public officials and their families to lead modest lives.

Ligutan raised the issue while cross-examining defense witness lawyer Anel Martin S. Antero, one of the 11 people who reportedly attended the dinner. Antero testified that Carpio’s credit card was used to settle the bill after some members of the group ran short of cash, but maintained that the expenses were shared among the diners.

Antero said he personally contributed around JPY40,000 and that the group had agreed to reimburse Carpio for advancing the payment. He also admitted being surprised by the amount of the bill.

‘Is that leading a modest life?’ Ligutan asked, challenging the witness to explain how spending more than P200,000 on a single meal could be reconciled with the constitutional standard.

The prosecutor also pressed Antero for proof that the other diners had reimbursed Duterte’s husband, Manases Carpio. The witness admitted he had no bank transfer records, receipts or written acknowledgement from Carpio confirming that the payments had been made. He likewise had no photograph to establish that all 11 people attended the dinner.

‘Do you have that document, sir?’ Ligutan asked.

‘None, sir,’ Antero replied.

Ligutan also examined Antero’s personal and professional ties to the couple, establishing that he had known Carpio since 1998 and Duterte since 2004. Antero described Carpio as a close friend whom he treated like a brother and acknowledged having been part of Duterte’s legal team. He also confirmed receiving compensation from Carpio’s law firm for professional services.

The prosecutor confronted Antero with an Anti-Money Laundering Council report indicating an alleged P580,000 transfer from Carpio to him in July 2020. The witness, however, said he could not recall receiving the amount. The prosecution said its questions were intended to establish possible bias and assess his credibility in light of his longstanding relationships with the couple.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *