The House of Representatives has called for stronger measures to protect judicial officers from threats harassment intimidation and attempts to improperly undermine them.
In a resolution following a motion by Ademorin Aliu Kuye (APC Lagos) the House asked the Federal Ministry of Justice and relevant institutions to promote public awareness of the constitutional and legal channels available to litigants seeking redress against judicial decisions or alleged misconduct by judicial officers.
The House resolutions seek to address growing concerns over the treatment of judicial officers in public discussions while preserving citizens’ constitutional right to scrutinise and criticise court decisions.
The House urged the National Judicial Council (NJC) to strengthen its mechanisms for receiving assessing and addressing credible complaints involving threats harassment intimidation and attempts to influence judicial decisions improperly.
In addition the House wants the Body of Benchers and the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) to reinforce professional standards and ethical responsibilities among legal practitioners particularly in their public statements and commentaries on pending cases judicial proceedings and judgments.
The lawmakers asked the two professional bodies to issue guidance encouraging lawyers to express disagreement with judicial decisions through lawful constructive and professionally responsible channels while discouraging personal attacks intimidation and abusive conduct against judicial officers.
They want the National Broadcasting Commission (NBC) to strengthen compliance with applicable broadcasting standards by media organisations and presenters discussing judicial proceedings and judgments adding that such coverage should reflect fairness accuracy and responsible reporting while demonstrating respect for the administration of justice.
The House asked Media organisations journalists political actors and social media users to distinguish between legitimate criticism of judicial decisions and personal attacks that could intimidate judicial officers or undermine public confidence in the Judiciary.
They want relevant law enforcement agencies to investigate credible reports of threats harassment incitement to violence and other unlawful attempts to intimidate judicial officers and ensure that appropriate legal action is taken where offences are established.
In the motion Kuye argued that judicial independence is a fundamental pillar of Nigeria’s constitutional democracy the rule of law and the administration of justice as guaranteed under the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended).
According to him judicial officers are constitutionally entrusted with the responsibility of interpreting the law determining disputes and dispensing justice without fear favour affection or ill will. He also noted that some public commentators and legal practitioners engage in personal attacks against judges rather than addressing the legal principles reasoning and findings contained in their judgments.
He maintained that Section 39 of the Constitution guarantees the right to freedom of Expression and that the Press must be protected including the right of citizens journalists and legal practitioners to scrutinise and criticise judicial decisions responsibly.
Kuye argued that a fundamental distinction exists between legitimate criticism of a judgment and personal attacks threats harassment or intimidation intended to undermine the integrity and independence of the judicial officer who delivered it.
He said social media platforms online publications and broadcasting networks are increasingly used to circulate unverified allegations misleading interpretations and inflammatory commentaries about judicial proceedings and judgments sometimes without adequate examination of the court records evidence legal arguments or reasoning underpinning such decisions.
He stressed that sustained campaigns of intimidation harassment and personal vilification against judicial officers may weaken public confidence in the Judiciary expose judges to undue pressure and undermine the Constitutional Principle of Separation of Powers.
He maintained that the National Judicial Council the Body of Benchers and the Nigerian Bar Association have important constitutional and professional responsibilities in promoting judicial integrity professional ethics and public confidence in the administration of justice.
He said the protection of judicial independence is not meant to place Judges above accountability or legitimate scrutiny but to ensure judicial officers can discharge their constitutional responsibilities without unlawful intimidation threats or external pressure.