There is a small administrative problem with the recent campaign to legalize polygamy. Before Batswana men can persuade Parliament to recognise multiple wives under common law, they might want to demonstrate that they can successfully negotiate the matter at home.
Kgosi Totang Dingalo of the Maun Region has already taken the matter to Ntlo ya Dikgosi, asking Government to consider amending marriage laws to allow men to marry more than one wife under common law. Reports also suggest that an MP is expected to bring a similar motion before Parliament.
It is a noble legislative ambition, depending on which side of the matrimonial bed one happens to occupy. But perhaps the campaign is starting at the wrong end. Men should first establish that polygamy can work in the most important institution in the country, their own households.
After all, polygamy is not illegal in Botswana. Under customary law, a man can marry more than one wife. What is currently prohibited is having multiple simultaneous marriages under common law. In other words, the law has already left the door open. It is the men who appear reluctant to walk through it.
So, before demanding that Government changes the law, perhaps Batswana men should demonstrate their commitment to polygamy. Let every man who believes in having multiple wives go home tonight and announce to his current wife that he intends to bring another woman into the family.
This should be the first test of the proposed legislation. The brave ones can start with a casual conversation over dinner. Others might prefer to raise the matter during a family meeting, preferably with the in-laws present, a pastor on standby and a lawyer within telephone range.
There will, of course, be challenges. Some men may discover that their wives are not particularly enthusiastic about sharing their husbands. Others might learn that the phrase ‘what is good for the goose is good for the gander’ has a surprisingly short shelf life when introduced into matrimonial negotiations. And some may discover that their wives are perfectly happy with customary law, provided the custom in question does not involve introducing another woman into the marriage. But this is precisely why the demonstration is necessary. If a man cannot convince one woman, who knows him intimately, to accept a second wife, what makes him think he can convince an entire Parliament?
Government cannot be expected to legislate courage into men. Neither can Ntlo ya Dikgosi be turned into a matrimonial dispute-resolution centre for husbands whose proposals have been rejected at home.
Perhaps the proposed MP’s motion should therefore include a practical pilot programme. Before the law is amended, aspiring polygamists should be required to demonstrate successful negotiations with their existing partners. Certificates of consent could be issued.
There is also the small matter of finances. A man who struggles to maintain one household should think very carefully before applying for a second. Love may be unlimited, but school fees, groceries, rent and power bills are not. Polygamy requires more than enthusiasm and a persuasive speech about African culture. Ultimately, there is nothing wrong with debating whether our marriage laws should recognise polygamous civil unions. There are legitimate questions about equality, legal protection, inheritance, property rights and the rights of women in such arrangements.
But if Batswana men want the law to recognise their right to multiple wives, they should first demonstrate that they understand the responsibilities that come with it. The first motion therefore, should not be tabled in Parliament. It should be tabled in your living room.