Should businesses pay 30% to argue with URA?

In Uganda, the right to argue with the taxman has a price, and the price is 30 percent.

Say a company gets a Shs10b tax bill from Uganda Revenue Authority (URA) and believes it is wrong. Its first step is to object, a formal written complaint asking URA to review its own bill.

If URA stands by the bill, the company can take the fight to the Tax Appeals Tribunal, an independent body that settles disputes between taxpayers and URA.

But before the tribunal hears a single argument, the company must hand URA Shs3b in cash, an equivalent of 30 percent of the assumed Shs10b in dispute.

That rule has been thorny for almost three decades. Tonny Kalungi, Acting Manager, Appeals Litigation at URA, thinks it may be losing its shape.

‘Every taxpayer has argued that there is a legal point. People are becoming ingenious. Every day they are coming up with something new. Now people are saying you can’t pay it if I am in financial distress. People are getting letters from the Finance Ministry saying waive it; look at the economy. So now 30 percent, if it is a rule, I believe it is at its weakest point. Someone needs to sit down and reconcile all these positions,’ he says.

The deposit is the gate to fair adjudication in a country that needs both more tax revenue and more private capital.

By September 2025, 529 cases worth about Shs1.4 trillion were waiting at the Tribunal. That is money government cannot spend, and companies cannot invest. And URA’s own figures suggest the bills behind those cases are often far too high.

A gate built in 1997

Section 15 of the Tax Appeals Tribunal Act says a taxpayer pays 30 percent of the tax in dispute, or all the undisputed tax if larger, before the tribunal hears the case.

If you win the case, the money comes back. If you lose, it counts toward the bill. So why make a taxpayer pay before being heard? URA says that without the deposit, people would appeal just to delay paying.

The idea is that money upfront discourages weak cases and keeps revenue flowing while the dispute runs.

Mwajumah Nakku Mubiru, the assistant commissioner who runs URA’s dispute-resolution unit, says the law leaves no room to bend.

‘On the side of URA, we are guided by the law. The law states that the person shall pay 30 percent of the amount of tax in dispute, which means the payment is actual money through the bank. But we are always guided by what the Tribunal shall decide and guide us in such a scenario,’ she notes.

The rule was written in a different Uganda, in 1997, at the height of International Monetary Fund and World Bank-backed tax reforms.

Denis Kakembo, managing partner at Cristal Advocates and a former Deloitte tax adviser, believes it could not survive a vote today.

‘If we are still feuding and disputing over a tax, why do you require that I pay 30 percent in advance? When you look at transfer pricing disputes, or some of the disputes that telecoms have, those assessments are scary. You will be assessed Shs300b, and you are expected to pay 30 percent before your matter is determined. Clearly you wouldn’t have the capacity to do that without closing shop or having to borrow,’ he says.

Asking for 30 percent upfront only makes sense if URA’s bill is close to correct. The tribunal’s own figures show it often is not.

In the year to June 2025, URA dropped 70 percent of the tax it had originally assessed in cases settled by agreement at the tribunal, according to the Tribunal’s performance report.

Yet the taxpayer had already paid 30 percent of the original figure just to be heard.

That is the core weakness of the rule. It charges an entry fee on a number that frequently does not survive scrutiny.

The problem is that the deposit may also decide where cases end. A deal at URA’s own free dispute office brings in no money upfront, while a deal at the Tribunal comes after URA has been paid 30 percent.

That gives URA a reason to prefer the Tribunal, especially now when it’s under immense pressure from government to collect more taxes.

Uganda’s current 14.2 percent tax-to-GDP ratio is way below the sub-Saharan Africa average of 16 percent to 18 percent. Uganda’s peers have chosen differently. Kenya requires only the undisputed tax, and its Parliament threw out a proposed 20 percent deposit in 2023.

Tanzania asks for one-third but lets its Tribunal waive it. The UK and Nigeria demand nothing upfront.

Uganda’s rule, business groups told Parliament in April, is uniquely rigid because it doesn’t even allow for a bank guarantee and there is no instalment plan in law.

Legal cracks

The first blow came in July 2020, in a case brought by fuel company Fuelex.

The Constitutional Court, which decides whether laws respect the constitution, ruled that the deposit is unfair when a taxpayer is not arguing about how much it owes, but about whether it owes the tax at all.

That meant that if you argue about the numbers, you pay, but if you argue about the law, you don’t.

Most real cases are both, and that is where the confusion starts. The Tribunal has started giving ground, sometimes accepting property or instalments instead of cash.

Joseph Luswata, a partner at S and L Advocates, says the tribunal is bending because the rule is harsh, but he does not think the rule has collapsed.

‘I believe the tribunal and the taxpayers are reacting to the unfairness of the 30 percent. The test is not as easy to apply as it might appear, because cases are always a mixture of legal issues as well as computational issues. I think the situation is not as fluid as Kalungi says, although definitely the requirement is coming under heavy attack,’ he says.

Since Fuelex, taxpayers have tried every angle to avoid paying cash.

In a case involving Vivo Energy decided in early 2025, the Tribunal refused a bank guarantee, a promise from a bank to pay if the taxpayer loses: the law asks for payment, not a promise.

This year the High Court went further, ruling that property URA has already seized over the tax must count toward the 30 percent. Demanding cash on top, it said, punishes the taxpayer twice.

Even the Tribunal wants the rule changed. In its 2025 report, it asked for clear legal power to decide the deposit case-by-case.

Kalungi calls this judicial activism, judges stretching the law beyond what Parliament wrote. Since almost every dispute touches the law, he worries the Fuelex exception will swallow the rule.

Luswata thinks that fear is overblown. By his estimate, more than 95 percent of taxpayers at the Tribunal still pay the 30 percent, and the few who ask to be excused rarely succeed.

Courts have carved out so many exceptions that no one can say for sure which taxpayer must pay. Businesses bear the cost of that confusion.

No precedent

Say the tribunal lets one company offer a building or a bank guarantee instead of cash. The next company cannot rely on that.

It must ask, and pay lawyers, all over again, because URA does not treat the decision as a rule for everyone.

‘We do not apply it uniformly. The tribunal has reasons as to why it has allowed a particular taxpayer to present a bank cheque, another one to present a bank guarantee, another one to present physical assets, or has waived the 30 percent. So, it’s on a case-by-case basis,’ Ms Mubiru says.

The 30 percent has also spread to places the law never put it. The rule is meant for taxpayers fighting a bill at the tribunal.

But tax lawyers say URA officers often ask for 30 percent even from taxpayers who accept the bill and only want to pay in instalments.

‘If the taxpayer is willing to pay the millions they have already accepted, the least you can do is give them a favourable timeline. Not push them to the wall again, asking them to pay 30 percent for you to listen to them,’ Rolant Kule, a tax lawyer at SM and Co Advocates, says.

URA says the officer at the desk does not make that call. Ms Mubiru says five levels of officials approve instalment requests, and part-payment upfront means less interest.less queue

Paying the deposit only gets a taxpayer into the queue, and the queue is long. New cases at the tribunal more than doubled between 2020 and 2025.

Pending cases nearly tripled, from about 169 in 2022/23 to about 476 by June 2025.

The Auditor General says the Tribunal handles cases very slowly and estimates that about Shs1.5 trillion is stuck.

The tribunal is getting faster by pushing both sides to agree through mediation, settling 146 disputes worth Shs203b in the six months to December 2025.

But the losing side can appeal to the High Court, then the Court of Appeal, then the Supreme Court. Luswata says the real jam is at the Court of Appeal.

‘An appeal takes on average 10 years to be disposed of in the Court of Appeal, and maybe three years in the Supreme Court. There has not been a Court of Appeal judgment on tax matters for a long time, and I know that so many are on their way there,’ he notes.

Kalungi thinks the ladder itself is the problem: cases start before tax specialists, then climb into ordinary courts.

He suggests copying UK, where tax appeals go through two specialist tribunals and usually end there.

The fix

In April, Private Sector Foundation Uganda and Uganda Manufacturers Association, two leading business lobbies, asked Parliament to change Section 15, backed by Uganda Law Society, among others.

They asked that the deposit be scrapped or scaled to 10 percent for small disputes and 2 percent for bigger ones.

So far, nothing has moved. Kakembo argues for the creation of a tax ombudsman, an independent office that can check URA’s bills before they reach the Tribunal.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *