Baguio may waive fees for 14 John Hay villages to end double taxation

The city council here is considering a proposal to waive the fees collected from residents and businesses in 14 barangays located within the Camp John Hay reservation to prevent double taxation, according to a draft ordinance pending before the legislative body.

Double taxation has arisen due to similar fees being collected by the John Hay Management Corp., a subsidiary of the Bases Conversion and Development Authority (BCDA) that manages the 625-hectare reservation.

The council has yet to determine the amount of revenue the city government will forgo if it implements the temporary fee waiver.

The proposed measure covers building permits, occupancy permits, electrical permits, mechanical permits, plumbing permits, business permits and other regulatory clearances required for construction, development or business operations within the affected barangays.

‘Nonetheless, residents are still required to secure the necessary permits to ensure public safety and effective monitoring of these structures,’ the draft ordinance clarified.

The fee waiver, it added, would remain in effect until the 14 villages are officially segregated from the Camp John Hay reservation or until the overlapping collection of fees is resolved.

Complete control

Camp John Hay, like all former American military bases, is under the custody of the BCDA, which, last January, has also taken over its privately developed commercial areas previously controlled by developer Camp John Hay Development Corp.

In 2023, the Supreme Court affirmed the city government’s regulatory authority over businesses operating in John Hay’s commercial areas, provided these are not registered with the Philippine Economic Zone Authority.

The business district falls under a special economic zone administered by the BCDA. But many businesses operating in the 14 barangays – including the Baguio Country Club village and the Ibaloy ancestral settlement in Barangay Loakan – are technically beyond the city’s regulatory scope until these communities are formally excluded from the BCDA’s control.

Conditions

The city’s jurisdiction over John Hay enterprises is among the 19 conditions outlined in City Resolution No. 362, which the city council passed in 1994 when it endorsed the conversion of the military base into a commercial area in the same year.

Condition No. 14 of Resolution No. 362 specifically requires the exclusion of the following John Hay barangays: Camp 7 (13,875 residents as of the 2020 census), Loakan-Apugan (2,906), Country Club Village (1,762), Lower Dagsian (1,521), Upper Dagsian (643), Greenwater (1,571), Hillside (1,549), Loakan-Liwanag (4,841), Loakan-Proper (12,006), Outlook Drive (2,237), Santa Escolastica (1,794) and Lucnab (2,206); Happy Hallow (2,674), which is also Baguio’s only Ibaloy ancestral domain; and Scout Barrio (1,329), which hosts families of former John Hay employees during the American occupation.

However, only Scout Barrio has been officially segregated through an executive order issued in 2001. The city council and its residents also asserted the process remained incomplete, as the BCDA retained control over Scout Barrio’s public spaces, including roads and a school.

Incomplete process

According to the draft ordinance authored by Councilor Paolo Salvosa, compliance with the conditions set by the city government remained incomplete due to ongoing negotiations between the city government and the BCDA over who should have jurisdiction over the 14 villages.

‘To alleviate the burden of double payment and ensure equitable treatment of residents pending the resolution of the segregation issue and full compliance with the 19 conditionalities, it is necessary to temporarily waive the collection of fees for specified permits by the Baguio City Government for properties and residents in the affected barangays,’ the draft ordinance said.

The city council has invited BCDA representatives to its Nov. 3 session to discuss the draft measure. But back channel negotiations between the city and the BCDA have been ongoing since June, after Mayor Benjamin Magalong requested the BCDA leadership to provide a categorical position on Resolution No. 362.

DSWD turns over P21.6 million for sustainable livelihood in Caraga

A total of P21.6 million has been turned over by the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) to 37 associations covered under its Sustainable Livelihood Program in the Caraga region, and another P8 million cash assistance for 554 individual beneficiaries.

The financial assistance, along with 18 three-wheeled vehicles locally known as ‘bao-bao’, were turned over at the Datu Lipus Makapandong Cultural Center in Patin-ay, Prosperidad town, last Oct. 16.

DSWD’s Sustainable Livelihood Program (SLP) is the department’s capacity-building initiative that aims to enhance the socioeconomic well-being of poor and marginalized families through skills training, enterprise development, and resource support.

Jean Paul Parajes, DSWD assistant regional director for operations, said the livelihood assistance served as an investment in the beneficiaries’ capacity to achieve long-term economic stability.

‘This DSWD-SLP livelihood assistance is more than just a grant-it is a solid step toward building your economic resilience and unlocking new growth opportunities,’ Parajes said during a ceremony attended by DSWD Caraga, local government officials, and leaders of livelihood associations.

He reminded recipients to ensure the sustainability of their projects as he thanked local government units and partner agencies for their support in implementing the program.

DSWD Caraga did not specify the different livelihood activities the beneficiaries were engaged in, but Agusan del Sur Governor Santiago Cane, Jr., suggested several income-generating activities, including egg and vegetable production.

Rep. Adolph Edward G. Plaza of Agusan del Sur’s 2nd District encouraged beneficiaries to manage their businesses responsibly and highlighted the importance of monitoring to sustain operations.

‘Agriculture-related livelihoods are vulnerable to natural and man-made hazards. Sustaining and growing a business requires study, research, and discipline,’ Plaza said.

He said he would reward outstanding livelihood associations after one year with P150,000 for the top-performing group, P100,000 for the second, and P75,000 for the third.

The three-wheeled vehicles distributed to some SPLAs also hoped to expand their business operations and reduce their transportation costs.

Among the beneficiaries, Angelito Apolo, president of the Asenso Poblacion SLPA in Bayugan City, thanked the government for the assistance.

‘Before, I earned little because I had to pay rent for my tricycle. Now, that rental cost that I would no longer be paying becomes additional income for my family,’ Apolo said. DSWD officials said they would continue monitoring and mentoring SLPAs to help them sustain their enterprises and contribute to the local economy./coa

Sunwest project in Mayon danger zone lacks permit

The controversial fencing project in Camalig town has no Environmental Compliance Certificate (ECC) and the Land Registration Authority (LRA) has no record of ownership of the lot involved, which is inside the permanent danger zone (PDZ) of Mayon Volcano in Albay.

Governor Noel Rosal revealed these on Facebook last week as he shared the response of the Environmental Management Bureau (EMB) of Bicol Region and the Registry of Deeds in Albay to his letters seeking clarification over Sunwest Inc.’s almost two-kilometer fencing project in Barangay Tumpa.

RELATED STORY: The congressman and the billions: Tracing the power of Zaldy Co

Geri Geronimo Sañez, officer-in-charge of the regional office of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources, said in a letter dated Oct. 16 that based on its online verification system and official records, ‘no ECC has been issued [.] to the said fence construction project’ on Lot No. 7745.

The lot, which is located within the volcano’s PDZ, is not registered with the LRA, as well, with the Registry of Deeds pointing out in a letter dated Oct. 16 that it does not have available records of the lot number based on the Certified True Copy of the Index Book for the Municipality of Camalig.

As Rosal said, ‘we will now call an investigation on what to do with the existing fence,’ although construction work by Sunwest Inc., which was co-founded by resigned Ako Bicol Rep. Elizaldy Co, has already ceased ‘after the discovery’ by the Provincial Environment and Natural Resources Office.

The local government of Camalig, in a letter dated Oct. 14, had told Rosal that its Municipal Engineering Office that no permit application was filed for the fencing project and that no such permit was issued by the office to the construction company, which was on the list of top 15 contractors that secured most flood control projects all over the country since 2022.

RELATED STORY: Firm tied to Zaldy Co named in DPWH complaint sent to competition body

The area 6 kilometers from the volcano is closed to all activities, with very limited regulated tourism activities allowed with strict regulation and is managed by the Mount Mayon Natural Park protected area management board, while the core zones of the cultural properties are managed by the Roman Catholic Diocese of Legazpi through their respective parishes.

PCCI steps up pressure on gov’t to yield corruption probe results

The Philippine Chamber of Commerce and Industry (PCCI), the country’s largest business organization, is pressing the Marcos administration for more ‘decisive actions and decisions’ to address the massive corruption hounding flood control and other key infrastructure projects.

‘We feel that we need more,’ said PCCI president Enunina Mangio, ‘We don’t want cover-ups. We don’t want railroading. We want really those responsible to be punished and to be identified.’

Mangio said on Monday on the sidelines of the 51st Philippine Business Conference and Expo in Pasay City that with the delivery of probe results that Filipinos are entitled to, there should be no need for more ‘drastic’ measures such as the resignation of President Marcos.

‘That’s why we are calling for his attention . We released that statement para hindi na tayo umabot doon (so that we don’t reach that point),’ said Mangio.

Mangio was referring to a joint resolution issued by 34 business groups and associations over the weekend, urging the Marcos administration to immediately address the ‘historic, massive and unprecedented corruption scandal’ affecting flood control and other infrastructure projects.

Public trust

These groups – including PCCI, Federation of Filipino-Chinese Chambers of Commerce and Industry Inc., Employers Confederation of the Philippines, Makati Business Club, and the Management Association of the Philippines – said that this crisis ‘has eroded public trust and now threatens national security.’

Among others, they urged President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. to give full legal authority and independence to the Independent Commission for Infrastructure (ICI) for conducting a swift and comprehensive investigation ‘free from political influence’ and provide regular updates on its progress.

‘We’re trying to prevent aggressive actions to take place,’ Mangio said.

Mangio acknowledged Marcos’ resolve in uncovering the extent of the anomalies in government-funded projects and to bring those responsible to justice, noting he was the one who brought the matter to light.

Prosecution

However, the PCCI said the government should become more decisive in getting to the bottom of the problem.

‘We in the business sector are looking forward to the day when our president will be able to really give us the results that we are expecting, prosecute those who are really involved in this corruption, whatever position they are holding in the country,’ Mangio stressed.

Mangio also pushed for transparency and honesty by establishing an organization or agency to monitor budget allocation and implementation.

Recto’s resignation from DOF ‘not true’ – Palace

Malacañang denied Tuesday rumors that Finance Secretary Ralph Recto had resigned.

In a Viber message, Palace Press Officer Claire Castro was asked to confirm reports that Recto had stepped down from the Department of Finance.

‘Not true,’ she told reporters.

Recto did not issue a statement regarding the matter. /mcm

PVL: Cignal to parade new import after 0-2 start

Cignal has parted ways with Greek spiker Eva Chantava after a 0-2 start in the PVL Reinforced Conference.

Through the league’s broadcast, the team said it ‘parted ways with Chantava after the coaching staff’s deliberation’, as the Super Spikers will field an All-Filipino roster against the unbeaten PLDT on Tuesday evening at Smart Araneta Coliseum.

Sources told the Inquirer that a new import in Slovakian hitter Katrin Trebichavska is set to join the team.

But Cignal will have to wait for Trebichavska’s clearance to play after just arriving in Manila.

Chantava only scored a total of 23 points in two games. She was limited to 10 points in her losing debut to Choco Mucho sans Marlee Smith and had 13 in a losing effort to Farm Fresh.

Trebichavska is a 25-year-old hitter who played for the State University of New York Buffalo Bulls in the US NCAA Division 1.

The Super Spikers hope to field their new import on Saturday against the Nxled Chameleons at Ynares Center Montalban.

Rain expected in parts of PH Oct. 21 due to easterlies

Rain is expected in several parts of the country on Tuesday, Oct. 21, due to the easterlies, or warm winds from the Pacific Ocean, the state weather bureau said.

The easterlies are likely to bring rains to Batanes province as well as the regions of Eastern Visayas, Davao, and Caraga, according to the Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (Pagasa).

The rest of Luzon and Visayas are expected to have generally fair weather with isolated or localized thunderstorms, Pagasa weather specialist Obet Badrina said in the agency’s morning weather forecast.

‘The rest of Mindanao will experience partly cloudy to cloudy skies with scattered rain showers and thunderstorms,’ he added.

Cyclone outlook, sea conditions

Apart from Severe Tropical Storm Fengshen (locally named Ramil), Pagasa said it was not monitoring any new low-pressure areas in the country’s area of responsibility.

Ramil was last located 795 kilometers west of Laoag City, Ilocos Norte, packing maximum sustained winds of up to 95 kph and gusts of up to 115 kph while moving westward at 25 kph, Pagasa said.

‘This will no longer affect the country, nor will its trough or associated clouds have any impact,’ Badrina said.

Pagasa added that waters off extreme northern Luzon will experience moderate to rough sea conditions, while the rest of the country’s seaboards will see moderate seas./mcm/abc

Pangilinan bares 3-way collusion in agricultural smuggling

A Senate inquiry into the smuggling of agricultural products has exposed an alleged collusion among Chinese syndicates, local businessmen, and government officials, similar to the operations of the now-banned Philippine offshore gaming operators (Pogos).

At the resumption on Monday of the investigation being conducted by the Senate committee on agriculture, food and agrarian reform, panel chair Sen. Francis Pangilinan noted the similarities between the smuggling of agricultural products and operations of Pogos, which were outlawed in the country in 2024.

‘The big picture is coming together. Just like in the Pogos, one of the key leaders of the powerful agricultural smuggling syndicate is from China,’ Pangilinan said.

‘And just like in the case of Pogos, there are Filipino accomplices. And most likely, the imported frozen fish was originally caught in our own waters-in the West Philippine Sea. Our fish are being stolen and sold back to us,’ he added.

Pangilinan cited the P68 million worth of smuggled frozen mackerel from China that was initially declared as P40 million worth of chicken poppers.

Government protection

Pangilinan lamented that, similar to Pogos, the bureaucracy is also being corrupted by exporters of agricultural products who all appeared to be from China.

‘Those who were caught and the companies whose goods were seized involved Chinese nationals,’ he pointed out.

Pangilinan said there is now ‘sufficient circumstantial evidence’ to believe that ‘Chinese smuggling syndicates’ have been conniving not only with local businessmen, but even with erring employees and officials in the Bureau of Customs, National Bureau of Investigation, Philippine National Police, Department of Agriculture, including the Department of Justice and Bureau of Immigration.

Ombudsman asks 204 new hires to reapply

Ombudsman Jesus Crispin Remulla said Monday he would ask 204 new employees who were hired in July to reapply so that they would not be considered ‘midnight appointees.’

At a press briefing, Remulla said he has also ordered a review of the Office of the Ombudsman’s admission and hiring process.

‘Unfortunately, last July, there were 204 new hires in the Office of the Ombudsman, and I will ask these 204 people to reapply because they are still under [a] six-month probationary period. I will ask them to reapply lest they become or be treated as midnight appointees,’ he told reporters.

‘That’s in good faith. I hope they’re all in good faith also. They can reapply, and some of them [should] probably hand in courtesy resignations just to show good faith. You don’t want to be arriving in a place [where] all the empty seats you expected for your companions were suddenly filled up,’ Remulla added.

The former justice secretary also said they have asked the Civil Service Commission (CSC) to assist his office in evaluating these cases.

CSC assistance sought

‘The CSC is very forthcoming. And they have communicated to us their willingness to help us with this issue of midnight appointees,’ Remulla said.

A midnight appointment refers to an appointment to a political office that is made during the ‘final hours’ of the appointing official’s term.

Remulla’s predecessor, former Ombudsman Samuel Martires, retired on July 27. The former associate justice of the Supreme Court was appointed to the post in 2018 by then-President Rodrigo Duterte.

Remulla, on the other hand, was named by President Marcos as the new Ombudsman on Oct. 7.

New policy on SALNs

A week after he took over, the Office of the Ombudsman lifted restrictions on public access to the statements of assets, liabilities, and net worth (SALNs) of government officials, reversing the policy imposed by Martires.

Remulla’s Memorandum Circular No. 3, which reopens public access to SALNs, will take effect 15 days after its Oct. 14 publication.

All SALNs, according to the guidelines, can be accessed, except if the Office of the Ombudsman is not the official repository, the SALN is not on file, or the request is for an unauthorized commercial purpose.

Access will also be restricted if the requesting party has a derogatory record of misuse, the request is linked to a pending case to influence or harass, there is evidence of extortion or safety threats, the identity of the requesting party is fictitious, or the purpose is contrary to law, morals, or public policy.

Access to SALNs was previously restricted under Martires through Memorandum Circular No. 1, Series of 2020.

The memorandum required anyone requesting a copy of a SALN to present a notarized letter of authority from the declarant, effectively barring the public and the media from obtaining the documents unless permitted by the official concerned.

’Third force’: Pink Movement’s moment

In nations with minimal social trust and dismal confidence in state institutions, even the most well-intentioned efforts at fighting corruption can either boomerang or deepen social discontent. The more corruption is exposed, the less trust there is in ongoing investigations. And opportunists are always ready to hijack the political moment.

From the late President Benigno Aquino III in the early 2010s to the Dilma Rousseff administration in the mid-2010s, numerous reformist presidencies paid a heavy price in spite of their sincere commitment to good governance. What corruption scandals did was open a Pandora’s box of political risks, which often tended to either degrade existing institutions or empower the darkest forces.

The three elements of credibility, competence, and communications are key to any successful anticorruption initiative. Specifically, the incumbent should be beyond reproach, the investigations should inspire public confidence, and, ultimately, the manner and speed of anticorruption initiatives should be deftly communicated to the public.

Sadly, politically successful anticorruption initiatives tend to be those that are most performative and weaponized, namely targeted against political opposition and independent voices amid a climate of fear and disinformation. Think, for instance, of how Chinese President Xi Jinping transformed from a term-limited president into a paramount leader by skillfully eliminating all his rivals, as well as the most notorious crooks under his anticorruption drive a decade ago. Tens of thousands of ‘flies,’ namely low-to-mid-level officials, as well as a few ‘tigers,’ including the vivaciously ambitious Bo Xilai, were ‘disciplined.’

‘We must uphold the fighting of tigers and flies at the same time, resolutely investigating lawbreaking cases of leading officials and also earnestly resolving the unhealthy tendencies and corruption problems which happen all around the people,’ Xi declared in a bombastically populist speech in 2013, shortly after assuming power. Within less than a decade, he had eliminated all rivals and independent centers of power, while bolstering his image as a no-nonsense and sincerely communist leader.

In the curious case of President Marcos’ anticorruption initiative, we neither see brute weaponization nor the ‘triple c’ package of credibility, competence, and communication. The ongoing investigations have, so far, been patchy, while the Marcos dynasty’s dark legacy would always cast a shadow of doubt over the incumbent’s credibility.

As for communications, Mr. Marcos has been more defensive than offensive, thus allowing the Duterte camp to either deflect from their own shady track record or, worse, steal political momentum. The traction of Cavite Rep. Kiko Barzaga’s opportunistically demagogic antics only proves my point. The President’s significant drop in the latest satisfaction rating surveys has laid bare the inherent risks of his quixotic embrace of good governance in the twilight years of his office.

Next month, according to a few uber insiders, could end up even more challenging for the incumbent. A major religious organization, they fear, could muster a massive rally that may have nothing less than replacing the current President in favor of another Duterte in Malacañang. As a sweetener, allegedly, a certain legislator-seen as a legal luminary by illiberal forces but instead a punchline among progressives and critical thinking folks-may get the vice presidency on a platter.

Even if such rumors were true, sedition would be a tall order, especially since the defense establishment is neither interested in political intervention nor in nurturing a Beijing-friendly commander in chief after years-long rehabilitation of strategic ties with the West on the heels of former President Rodrigo Duterte’s disastrous foreign policy. Secessionist destabilization attempts, however, would still be a win for them-and their foreign patrons.

Against this backdrop, the progressives have a historic opportunity to break the deadlock. As the de facto ‘third force,’ the crystallization coalition of church leaders, civil society organizations, progressive celebrities, and statesmen can collectively safeguard our democratic institutions while also pressuring the incumbent to sincerely crack down on corruption just short of political collapse.

The next two years can also serve as a runway for building a robust good governance movement led by credible, competent, and communicatively savvy progressive-liberal figures. It’s not enough for us to put a good candidate in Malacañang in 2028. We need to reform our entire political system by contesting and reforming elected offices and democratic institutions at all levels of governance. For this, we need a robust and inclusive movement, not just another savior. Nevertheless, the progressive opposition needs a clear leader to carry the mantle for the movement. We can’t wait until the 11th hour. The battle is before us.