Why East African firms must rethink operations in AI race

In the bustling heart of Nairobi, a quiet shift is happening that will determine the winners and losers of the next decade.

For years, the conversation around digital transformation in East Africa has centred on the simple act of going digital, moving from paper to screens or launching a mobile application. Today, the stakes have evolved.

As banks, insurers and manufacturers across Kenya, Uganda and Tanzania scale to serve millions of people across borders, they are hitting a structural wall.

The traditional way of doing business where growth in customers requires proportional growth in staff is no longer sustainable. To compete in an economy increasingly defined by artificial intelligence, our regional enterprises must rethink the mechanics of how they operate.

We operate in a landscape where demand for services is skyrocketing, yet we face unique constraints: mobile-first customers who expect instant gratification, uneven internet connectivity and a complex web of data-sovereignty regulations. Most organisations spend a staggering amount of their most valuable resource, human talent, on predictable and repetitive tasks.

Whether it is a bank teller processing a routine balance inquiry or a logistics coordinator tracking a delayed shipment, these interactions consume skilled capacity without adding a single cent of differentiated value.

This is the structural mismatch we must solve.

Leading organisations are beginning to realise that the goal is not merely to handle demand more efficiently, but to reduce it at the source.

This requires a fundamental shift from siloed systems to orchestrated digital journeys. We are moving toward a world where the primary layer of operations is managed by agentic artificial intelligence. Unlike the basic chatbots many of us have encountered, agentic systems do not just talk, they act.

This shift is not about replacing our people. On the contrary, it is about liberating them. When we automate the mundane, we allow our teams to focus on the high-value work that actually grows a business. However, in a regulated environment like ours, this must be built on a foundation of trust.

We need human-in-the-loop controls and clear policy-based guardrails to ensure that artificial intelligence acts within the law and our own ethical standards.

The success of this intelligent layer depends entirely on the pipes that carry it. In East Africa, connectivity can no longer be viewed as a simple utility like water or electricity, it is a strategic capability. This means that connectivity must be programmed and based on policies.

By treating connectivity as a software-defined service, an enterprise can deliver a seamless digital experience even when the underlying network is unstable.

The increasing presence of hyperscale cloud infrastructure and regional data centers across Africa provides the perfect opportunity to consolidate these efforts. Instead of building fragmented technology stacks in every country of operation, organizations can now centralize their intelligence and governance.

This model uses the cloud as a central control plane. While the execution happens locally to meet regulatory requirements and ensure low latency, the orchestration is unified.

Transitioning to this level of maturity requires a practical and phased roadmap. It begins with a foundation of observability, identifying where the high-volume interactions are and setting up the necessary governance.

The second phase introduces intelligence, where agentic artificial intelligence begins to orchestrate tasks with human oversight. Finally, the enterprise expands into a true ecosystem, monetizing its scale and inviting partners to build on its platform.

Is securities lending and borrowing the next growth frontier?

During a recent chat with a friend, we somehow drifted into a discussion about some of the complex terms and capital market products. Something interesting that caught my attention, was how money market funds and Ziidi Trader dominated the conversation. Securities lending and borrowing (SLB) also came up.

SLB is the lending and/or borrowing of capital market securities (shares, bonds, among others) for a definite period, with a simultaneous agreement to return them (or their cash equivalent) at an agreed future date, together with an agreed lending/borrowing fee.

Under SLB, one can lend ‘idle’ securities they own but do not intend to sell. This therefore implies that for it to be successful, an SLB transaction needs to have a lender, a borrower, an agreement (usually referred to as SLB agreement), an SLB consideration (or fee) and a platform where the transaction is effected.

A common question is: why would someone participate in an SLB transaction? An SLB transaction is driven by one of three reasons: First, a borrower may need to settle an existing securities debt arising from a previous transaction, where they owe securities to a counterparty.

Secondly, there may be a need to sell borrowed securities with the expectation that prices will fall, allowing the borrower to repurchase them at a lower price, make a profit, and settle their obligation. This is known as short selling.

Thirdly, a borrower with an underlying derivative contract (such as a future, forward, or option) may use SLB to hedge against potential losses by protecting themselves from adverse price movements in the underlying asset.

SLB can generate forward and backward linkages with stakeholders such as custodians, clearing and settlement institutions, derivatives traders, fund managers, pension schemes and investment banks among others, contributing to the establishment and sustenance of a vibrant SLB market.

For securities lenders specifically, it is an ideal opportunity to make extra income by availing their ‘idle’ securities portfolios to those willing to borrow them at a fee, with a commitment to return them at the agreed time.

One of the most important documents in any SLB transaction is the agreement; a contract between counterparties in the transaction. This allows temporary transfer of securities from the lender to the borrower for a fee. It details the name of the borrower/lender identification, the loaned securities, fees payable, collateral provided (by the borrower) to stand-in for the value of the borrowed securities.

The agreement also includes details on how corporate actions (dividends, interest, or voting rights to the lender) will be handled, default provisions, the applicable law and agreement termination clauses. At the international stage, we have the Global Master Securities Lending Agreement, which is a standardised legal framework that governs cross-border securities lending transactions.

So, how are SLB transactions executed? There are three main ways; trading through SLB through bilateral trading, screen-based trading, and hybrid trading. In bilateral trades agreements are direct over the counter customised deals with lenders (like custodians, pension schemes, stockbrokers etc.) using an SLB to directly lend securities to interested borrowers.

Bilateral SLB transactions allow flexible terms on dates, fees and margins among others.

In screen-traded SLB, multilateral transactions involving many borrowers and lenders are executed through an on-exchange formal platform that uses automated processes to execute transactions with borrow/lend orders being matched, based on price-time priority of the SLB orders.

On its part, hybrid SLB trading implies that stakeholders use a combination of both screen-based and bilateral approaches. This leverages quick, anonymous, exchange-traded transactions with the need for customized transactions to optimise efficiency and improve liquidity.

However, SLB activity in Kenya’s capital markets has remained relatively low since the framework was introduced, with only a handful of transactions recorded.

This is largely due to low market awareness, limited availability of lendable securities, operational complexities, and cautious risk appetite among market participants.

To address these challenges, SLB needs positioning as a key tool for improving market liquidity, price discovery, and overall efficiency in Kenya’s capital markets.

In terms of the regulatory environment for SLB in Kenya, all SLB activity is regulated by the Capital Markets Authority (CMA) under the Capital Markets (Securities Lending, Borrowing and Short Selling) Regulations 2017, and the Central Depository (Securities Lending and Borrowing) Rules 2019.

The two legal instruments guide CMA in ensuring market discipline through regulatory oversight, approval and supervision and policy advisory. The Central Depository and Settlement Corporation (CDSC) ensures protection of the parties to any SLB transaction through mandatory collateralisation, daily transaction monitoring and provision of settlement guarantee services for all executed transactions.

However, SLB activity in Kenya’s capital markets has remained relatively low since the framework was introduced, with only a handful of transactions recorded. This subdued uptake is attributed to factors such as low market awareness, limited availability of lendable securities, operational complexities, and cautious risk appetite among market participants.

To address these challenges, SLB needs positioning as a key tool for improving market liquidity, price discovery, and overall efficiency in Kenya’s capital markets.

Micro-lender bosses face prosecution over ex-employee image use

The Office of the Data Protection Commissioner (ODPC) has recommended the prosecution of directors of a micro-lender for failing to respond to a complaint filed by a former employee over the publication of his images on social media without consent.

Data Protection Commissioner Immaculate Kassait said LOLC Micro Finance Bank published the personal data of Peter Macharia Waithira in public notices and on its social media platforms without his consent.

Ms Kassait noted that despite being served with notification of the complaint, the micro-lender failed to respond.

She said the directors should be prosecuted for obstructing the Data Commissioner, contrary to Section 61(b) of the Act.

‘By failing to respond to the notification of complaint, the respondent obstructed the Data Commissioner in the exercise of her powers under Section 9,’ Ms Kassait said.

Evidence presented before the ODPC showed that Mr Macharia was previously employed by the lender on a contract basis.

On July 28, 2025, he formally tendered his resignation via email, which was received by the employer.

Despite his resignation, the micro-lender allegedly proceeded to publish highly sensitive public notices on its social media platforms, claiming he was no longer associated with the institution and warning the public against transacting with him.

The commissioner noted that the microfinance posted Mr Macharia’s images on its Facebook platform.

During the hearing, the complainant maintained that he did not consent to the processing of his personal data.

‘In light of the above, the office finds that the respondent unlawfully processed the complainant’s personal data,’ Ms Kassait said.

The commissioner added that the lender failed to demonstrate a lawful basis for processing the complainant’s personal data by not responding to the notification.

The lender was given 14 days from the date of the decision to erase the complainant’s images from its online platforms. Failure to comply will result in an enforcement notice being issued against the bank.

Fuel stations risk taxman audits as Ruto VAT order triggers compliance rush

The Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) has directed oil marketing firms to reconfigure their invoicing systems to align with the reduced eight percent value-added tax (VAT) on fuel, intensifying a compliance race and exposing petrol stations to audits.

The directive, issued through KRA’s eTIMS/TIMS operations office, requires fuel stations using third-party tax invoicing systems to introduce a new tax category and update product classification codes.

They are also required to control how the reduced VAT rate is applied within a defined three-month window ending mid-July.

‘The TIS [third-party Tax Invoicing Solutions] should restrict the inclusion of items created with the UNSPSC codes with Tax Type – 8 percent in original sales invoices to between April 15, 2026, and July 14, 2026,’ KRA said in the circular, effectively locking businesses into a narrow compliance timeline with little room for error.

‘Credit notes shall be generated as per the prevailing credit note business rules,’ the taxman said.

The United Nations Standard Products and Services Code (UNSPSC) is a global system used to classify goods and services for financial reporting within enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems.

The VAT cut directive by President William Ruto has proved an operational challenge for fuel stations, which must ensure every transaction is correctly coded, timed and reported within the tax authority’s digital system.

The challenge is compounded by the integration of business systems with KRA’s electronic Tax Invoice Management System (eTIMS), which captures transactions in real time.

This means any errors in applying the new VAT rate – whether due to incorrect coding or timing – are immediately recorded, increasing the risk of penalties and future audits.

The compliance burden is heavier for smaller businesses that rely on external vendors to manage invoicing systems. The tax change requires system updates, testing and deployment within tight timelines, raising costs.

Audit trail

Industry insiders told Business Daily that the directive signals a heightened audit environment. By enforcing strict tax codes and timelines through eTIMS, KRA is creating a detailed digital trail of transactions that can be analysed for compliance after the three-month relief period ends.

This raises the likelihood of scrutiny over how firms applied the reduced VAT rate, particularly where transactions fall outside the prescribed window or system errors occur.

The VAT relief saw the price of super petrol in Nairobi drop by Sh9.37 to Sh197.60 a litre in the latest review by the Energy and Petroleum Regulatory Authority, while diesel declined by Sh10.21 to Sh196.63.

The reductions came barely 24 hours after prices had surged past Sh206 per litre under a 13 percent VAT regime, itself a short-lived revision from the statutory 16 percent rate.

While the temporary VAT cut has eased inflationary pressure in the short term for an economy that runs on fuel, the accompanying compliance demands highlight the trade-off between policy responsiveness and operational stability.

Sidian Bank’s Sh3bn capital raise to sustain growth

Sidian Bank has raised Sh3 billion in fresh capital through a rights issue, consolidating a series of fundraisers as it seeks to boost capital and sustain growth.

The money was raised in two tranches in January and February this year, following approval by the bank’s management board on November 28, 2025.

The latest fundraiser means that Sidian has now increased its capital for the third straight year through a rights issue, coinciding with a strong growth phase for the lender, which has been elevated to a mid-tier bank.

‘The capital injection will support continued business growth and improve the bank’s regulatory capital,’ says the lender in its latest annual report.

Sidian says it raised Sh1.935 billion in January this year, followed by Sh1.065 billion in February. The latest round of capital-raising follows the Sh1.095 billion raised in 2025 and Sh1.891 billion in the previous year from shareholders.

This means that over the past three years, Sidian has raised close to Sh6 billion in fresh capital from shareholders to firm up its growth strategy. The lender graduated to tier II (medium bank) status in the third quarter of last year from a tier III (small lender) ranking.

The lender now wants to sustain the momentum through various strategies, including digital banking, anchor clients and ecosystem banking, trade finance, infrastructure financing, brand positioning, sustainability, and risk management.

‘As at September 30, 2025, the bank attained tier II (medium) status based on its growth. The bank’s strategies in 2026 are aimed at further growing and propelling the bank towards becoming a top-tier II bank,’ said the lender.

Sidian’s core capital rose to Sh11.63 billion as at the end of February 2026 from Sh8.15 billion it held at the end of December last year, pointing to the impact of the rights issue on the balance sheet.

The lender’s series of fundraising comes amid the revised core capital requirements for Kenyan banks, from a minimum of Sh1 billion to Sh10 billion, which banks have to comply with by the end of 2029 in phases.

The Business Laws (Amendment) Act 2024 revised the minimum core capital in the banking sector from Sh1 billion to Sh3 billion by the end of December 2025, Sh5 billion by the close of 2026, Sh6 billion by the end of 2027, Sh8 billion in 2028, and Sh10 billion by the close of 2029.

Sidian’s latest core capital means it may still require some additional capital for full compliance come December 2029, unless organic growth fully covers the shortfall.

The lender has seen an accelerated pace of growth over the last two years, with net profit rising six times to Sh1.72 billion in 2025 from Sh287.35 million in 2024. It had posted a net loss of Sh447.95 million in 2023.

Sidian’s assets hit Sh90.8 billion as of December 2025, up from 60.2 billion in a similar period in 2024 and Sh44.74 billion in 2023.

Deposits from customers have more than doubled in three years to hit Sh72.3 billion in December 2025 from Sh27.6 billion in December 2023.

Rising fuel prices not a domestic problem

When fuel prices rise in Kenya, the first instinct is to look inward. The debate quickly turns to taxes, subsidies, and government policy.

But the latest increase calls for a different reading. This is not, at its core, a domestic crisis. It is a global shock landing in a vulnerable economy.

Kenyans need to appreciate what is happening. The recent surge in oil prices has less to do with decisions made in Nairobi than with tensions far beyond Kenya’s borders.

Developments in Venezuela, and more recently the Middle East, have unsettled energy markets and pushed prices upward. For an oil-importing frontier economy such as Kenya, those effects are felt almost immediately.

Oil markets move not only on supply, but also on fear, speculation, and expectation. The mere possibility of conflict, sanctions, or disruption raises risk premiums. Those costs are then passed on to consumers. Kenya does not determine global oil prices. It absorbs them. That distinction matters, because it shifts the conversation from blame to preparation.

The effects are already plain to see. Higher fuel prices feed directly into transport costs, food prices, and business expenses. For many households, inflation is not a matter of charts and percentages.

It is the daily struggle of commuting, shopping, and keeping small businesses afloat. What looks like a domestic price spike is in fact the local face of global instability.

This does not mean domestic policy is irrelevant. Taxes, levies, and regulatory choices influence how pain is distributed across the economy. But they do not create the initial shock. When discussion focuses only on local policy, it risks missing the larger issue. Kenya remains deeply exposed to changes in global energy markets, and that exposure is structural.

The macroeconomic consequences are serious. Higher oil prices raise the import bill, widen the current account deficit, and put pressure on the shilling. Once the currency weakens, imports become more expensive, and inflation grows harder to contain.

The central bank is then forced into an uncomfortable trade-off. It may need to keep monetary policy tight to tame prices, but that comes at the cost of slower economic activity and more expensive credit.

The fiscal picture is no easier. As fuel prices rise, pressure mounts on the government to respond through subsidies, tax relief, or both. Yet Kenya’s fiscal room is already narrow.

Debt servicing obligations are heavy, and recent revenue measures have already met public resistance. Policymakers are left trying to cushion a blow they did not cause, using tools that are increasingly constrained.

There is also a political side to this, especially as the country moves closer to another election cycle. Fuel prices are among the most visible and politically charged indicators in any economy.

They shape public perceptions quickly, regardless of where the shock began. When an externally driven rise is read only as a domestic failure, frustration deepens and the pressure for quick fixes grows. In that setting, leaders may be tempted to pursue politically attractive but fiscally reckless measures.

That is why public communication matters. Citizens need honesty about the fact that not every economic shock begins at home.

What is happening now is unlikely to be the last episode of this kind. The world economy is entering a period of sharper geopolitical rivalry, where conflict and instability increasingly shape markets. From Eastern Europe to the Middle East and Latin America, disruption is becoming normal.

For countries like Kenya, this means external shocks will arrive more often and with less warning.

That should force a change in how Kenya thinks about resilience. Reducing dependence on imported oil is no longer only a climate question. It is a hard economic necessity.

Kenya’s geothermal, wind, and solar investments offer some insulation, but the pace needs to quicken. The same applies to trade, manufacturing, and debt management.

A country cannot control global turbulence, but it can reduce how exposed it is to it.

The rise in fuel prices should therefore be understood for what it is: not simply a domestic policy failure, but a sign of Kenya’s place in a volatile world. The sooner that is understood, the better the country can respond.

Starlink growth slows as fibre rivals tighten grip on market

The sustained slowdown in Starlink’s subscriber growth has exposed the structural limits of satellite internet in Kenya, even as demand for high-speed connectivity continues to surge.

Latest data from the Communications Authority of Kenya (CA) shows the Elon Musk-owned provider added just 3,136 new users in 2025, a sharp deceleration from the explosive uptake seen in its first year of operations.

The modest additions pushed Starlink’s market share down to 0.9 percent as of last December, from 1.1 percent in a similar month a year earlier, signalling a loss of momentum in a fast-expanding fixed internet market.

This contrasts sharply with its early trajectory following its July 2023 entry, when pent-up demand for reliable, high-speed internet drove rapid adoption across households, businesses, and public institutions.

Starlink signed up 8,063 users in its first full year of operations and added a further 11,083 subscribers within the successive six months, underlining the initial strength of its value proposition in underserved areas.

The early surge was driven by its promise of speeds exceeding 200 megabits per second in regions where fiber rollout had lagged, positioning the service as a premium alternative to terrestrial networks.

Capacity strain

The rapid uptake, however, now appears to have strained its capacity, exposing limitations in its satellite-based model when confronted with concentrated urban demand.

The firm was, for instance, forced to suspend new activations in key counties including Nairobi, Kiambu, Machakos, Kajiado and Murang’a in 2024, citing network congestion and the need to stabilise performance.

This marked a turning point in its Kenyan expansion, demonstrating that global satellite infrastructure alone could not seamlessly absorb the intensity of local demand without complementary ground capacity.

Users would later begin reporting declining speeds and increased latency, eroding the premium experience that had initially distinguished Starlink from fibre and fixed wireless alternatives.

The performance challenges coincided with aggressive price cuts by the multinational, aimed at sustaining growth, including a reduction in hardware costs and the introduction of rental plans to lower entry barriers.

While the pricing strategy attracted new users, it also deepened network strain by onboarding more subscribers onto already congested satellite beams, undermining quality.

Market positioning

The resultant dynamic has since reshaped the competitive positioning of Kenya’s broadband market, where terrestrial providers have capitalised on Starlink’s constraints to reinforce their dominance.

Market leader Safaricom has stamped its lead in fixed internet, closing last year with 858,394 subscribers, which accounted for 34.9 percent market share.

Jamii Telecommunications follows with 494,150 users, as Wananchi Group-owned Zuku comes third with 272,802 subscribers, with the two accounting for 20.1 percent and 11.1 percent share of the market, respectively.

The broader fixed internet market expanded rapidly, with total subscriptions across all operators rising 43.2 percent to 2.5 million by the close of last year, up from 1.7 million a year earlier, highlighting strong underlying demand.

Fibre networks, while capital-intensive, offer consistent speeds and scalability in dense urban settings, giving them an advantage over satellite solutions in high-demand environments.

Satellite internet, on the other hand, is better suited for low-density and remote regions where laying fibre is either uneconomical or logistically challenging.

Strategic pivot

Starlink’s experience in Kenya has forced it into a strategic pivot, culminating in a partnership with Safaricom through the latter’s South African parent firm Vodacom to stabilise operations and expand reach.

The deal allows Safaricom to distribute Starlink kits and integrate satellite backhaul into its network, particularly in rural areas where fibre expansion remains limited.

For Starlink, the partnership provides access to established distribution channels and local infrastructure, helping manage congestion while maintaining local market relevance.

Airtel has also partnered with Musk’s SpaceX to introduce Starlink’s direct-to-cell (D2C) satellite technology to all its 14 African markets, including Kenya.

The service, which works by turning satellites into space-based mobile towers and allows phones to connect in areas where terrestrial networks are absent or unreliable, marks the first time in Kenya that a satellite operator is collaborating with a mobile phone network to provide telecommunications services from space.

SpaceX says it operates over 8,000 low-Earth orbit satellites, 650 of which are dedicated to D2C services.

Fuel stations risk taxman audits as Ruto VAT order triggers compliance rush

The Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) has directed oil marketing firms to reconfigure their invoicing systems to align with the reduced eight percent value-added tax (VAT) on fuel, intensifying a compliance race and exposing petrol stations to audits.

The directive, issued through KRA’s eTIMS/TIMS operations office, requires fuel stations using third-party tax invoicing systems to introduce a new tax category and update product classification codes.

They are also required to control how the reduced VAT rate is applied within a defined three-month window ending mid-July.

‘The TIS [third-party Tax Invoicing Solutions] should restrict the inclusion of items created with the UNSPSC codes with Tax Type – 8 percent in original sales invoices to between April 15, 2026, and July 14, 2026,’ KRA said in the circular, effectively locking businesses into a narrow compliance timeline with little room for error.

‘Credit notes shall be generated as per the prevailing credit note business rules,’ the taxman said.

The United Nations Standard Products and Services Code (UNSPSC) is a global system used to classify goods and services for financial reporting within enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems.

The VAT cut directive by President William Ruto has proved an operational challenge for fuel stations, which must ensure every transaction is correctly coded, timed and reported within the tax authority’s digital system.

Read: Ruto VAT flip-flop triggers compliance chaos for oil firms

The challenge is compounded by the integration of business systems with KRA’s electronic Tax Invoice Management System (eTIMS), which captures transactions in real time.

This means any errors in applying the new VAT rate – whether due to incorrect coding or timing – are immediately recorded, increasing the risk of penalties and future audits.

The compliance burden is heavier for smaller businesses that rely on external vendors to manage invoicing systems. The tax change requires system updates, testing and deployment within tight timelines, raising costs.

Audit trail

Industry insiders told Business Daily that the directive signals a heightened audit environment. By enforcing strict tax codes and timelines through eTIMS, KRA is creating a detailed digital trail of transactions that can be analysed for compliance after the three-month relief period ends.

This raises the likelihood of scrutiny over how firms applied the reduced VAT rate, particularly where transactions fall outside the prescribed window or system errors occur.

The VAT relief saw the price of super petrol in Nairobi drop by Sh9.37 to Sh197.60 a litre in the latest review by the Energy and Petroleum Regulatory Authority, while diesel declined by Sh10.21 to Sh196.63.

The reductions came barely 24 hours after prices had surged past Sh206 per litre under a 13 percent VAT regime, itself a short-lived revision from the statutory 16 percent rate.

While the temporary VAT cut has eased inflationary pressure in the short term for an economy that runs on fuel, the accompanying compliance demands highlight the trade-off between policy responsiveness and operational stability.

Court rejects pause of county cess fees on farm produce exports

Growers and exporters will continue paying county governments cess on export-bound agricultural produce, even within Special Economic Zones, despite claims that the levy amounts to double taxation and encroaches on the national government’s exclusive mandate over export trade.

This follows a decision by the Court of Appeal to decline to suspend the charges pending appeal in a suit lodged by Royal Herbs Exporters (SEZ) Limited, allowing counties to continue enforcing the levies.

The appellate judges found that although the company had raised arguable constitutional questions, it failed to prove that continued payment of the cess would render its appeal nugatory.

They ruled that the charges are monetary and recoverable if the appeal succeeds, meaning exporters must comply with the county law unless and until it is overturned.

The dispute stems from a November 2025 High Court judgment, which upheld Section 8 of the Nyandarua County Finance Act, 2024, and affirmed the county’s authority to impose cess as a service charge.

Royal Herbs, an SEZ enterprise exporting fresh herbs to global markets, had moved to the appellate court seeking temporary orders to block the cess, arguing it was unconstitutional and harmful to its time-sensitive export business.

The company told the court that it risks ‘business sustainability’ challenges due to cumulative charges and warned that continued enforcement could lead to financial losses and possible job cuts.

It also argued that the county government was not providing any direct services to justify the levy and questioned its ability to refund the fees if the appeal succeeds.

But the appellate judges found that, though the appeal raised arguable issues, an interim relief against the contested levy could not be issued.

‘An arguable appeal is not one which must necessarily succeed,’ the judges said, adding that the case raises issues that should be fully ventilated at the main hearing.

However, the court stressed that the exporter had not met the second legal test required for such relief.

It held that the exporter failed to prove that denying the injunction would render its appeal worthless.

‘The cess that it will pay is well tabulated and monetary in nature. The money paid is recoverable if the appeal is successful,’ the judges ruled.

They added that the law underpinning the charges remains valid unless overturned, stating that statutory provisions are presumed constitutional until declared otherwise.

The decision means Royal Herbs must continue paying cess like other exporters while pursuing its substantive appeal.

The company’s case traces back to a petition filed in May 2025, challenging the legality of cess on horticultural exports and seeking to nullify the county law. It complained of double taxation.

It argued that counties lack authority to impose charges on export goods, a mandate it said belongs exclusively to the national government under Articles 209 and 210 of the Constitution.

The exporter also cited an April 2025 incident in which county officials impounded its truck carrying perishable herbs and demanded Sh161,000 before release, highlighting the commercial risks tied to delays.

But Nyandarua County government defended the levy as a lawful user fee tied to devolved functions, including agriculture, road maintenance, and inspection of produce.

In dismissing the petition, the High Court distinguished taxes and fees.

The court ruled that the Constitution provides that the national and county governments may impose charges for the services they provide.

It said that the petitioner had failed to prove the cess amounted to taxation.

The court found that cess is a charge linked to specific services and must remain proportionate to the benefit provided, rather than a general revenue-raising tax.

Cess is commonly imposed by counties on agricultural produce moving through their jurisdictions, often justified as funding local infrastructure, inspection systems, and extension services.

For exporters, especially those dealing in perishable goods like herbs, the charges add cost and logistical pressure to already tight supply chains.

“It is therefore clear that cess and tax are two separate payments with different purposes. The petitioner seems not to have recognized the differences,” the High Court said.

“Article 209 (4) of the Constitution of Kenya provides as follows: The national and county governments may impose charges for the services they provide. The petitioner has failed to prove how payment of the cess amounts to taxation,” he stated in the contested judgement.

The appellate ruling now strengthens counties’ ability to continue collecting such fees, even on goods destined for export, unless overturned in the main appeal.

Micro-lender bosses face prosecution over ex-employee image use

The Office of the Data Protection Commissioner (ODPC) has recommended the prosecution of directors of a micro-lender for failing to respond to a complaint filed by a former employee over the publication of his images on social media without consent.

Data Protection Commissioner Immaculate Kassait said LOLC Micro Finance Bank published the personal data of Peter Macharia Waithira in public notices and on its social media platforms without his consent.

Ms Kassait noted that despite being served with notification of the complaint, the micro-lender failed to respond.

She said the directors should be prosecuted for obstructing the Data Commissioner, contrary to Section 61(b) of the Act.

‘By failing to respond to the notification of complaint, the respondent obstructed the Data Commissioner in the exercise of her powers under Section 9,’ Ms Kassait said.

Evidence presented before the ODPC showed that Mr Macharia was previously employed by the lender on a contract basis.

On July 28, 2025, he formally tendered his resignation via email, which was received by the employer.

Despite his resignation, the micro-lender allegedly proceeded to publish highly sensitive public notices on its social media platforms, claiming he was no longer associated with the institution and warning the public against transacting with him.

The commissioner noted that the microfinance posted Mr Macharia’s images on its Facebook platform.

During the hearing, the complainant maintained that he did not consent to the processing of his personal data.

‘In light of the above, the office finds that the respondent unlawfully processed the complainant’s personal data,’ Ms Kassait said.

The commissioner added that the lender failed to demonstrate a lawful basis for processing the complainant’s personal data by not responding to the notification.

The lender was given 14 days from the date of the decision to erase the complainant’s images from its online platforms. Failure to comply will result in an enforcement notice being issued against the bank.