In an interview over radio station dzBB with anchors Arnold Clavio and Connie Sison on the devastation left by typhoon Tino, geologist Mahar Lagmay asked a question lingering in the minds of many others: ‘Why did this happen despite all the warnings?’
Lagmay, executive director of Project NOAH or Nationwide Operational Assessment of Hazards, said there has been ample warnings from the government weather bureau Philippine Atmospheric Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (Pagasa) and other disaster monitoring government agencies about the path, strength and dangers of Tino.
‘It seems like the warnings were not implemented,’ he said in Filipino.
Tino (Kalmagi) joined the list of storms that left the heaviest damage and most fatalities in Philippine history inckuding Supertyphoon Yolanda (Haiyan) which made landfall in the country as among the world’s most powerful storms in 2013 also in Novwmber.
As of Friday (Nov 7) the death toll from Tino is already 188 with at least 136 persons missing.
But the numbers cannot depict the actual tragedy, pain, fear, loss and agony of the people living in communities turned upside down by Tino.
One woman, interviewed by Clavio and Sison on dzBB, recounted the pain of helplessness as she watched her husband and three childen drown in rampaging floodwaters in Liloan, Cebu, the worst hit by Tino in the province.
‘We took shelter in a house but the flood rose so fast we did not have time to move to another safe place,’ the Liloan resident said in a mix of Cebuano and Filipino.
‘We lost our grip and in no time, my husband and three childen are already in the water. I saw they were already desd,’ the woman, who survived the tragedy, said.
Now, the waman said, she doesn’t know how to go on living but pins her hope that her mother and cousins, or what’s left of her family, are still alive.
‘I don’t know how to live anymore,’ rhe survivor said.
Multiple reports as of Nov 7 said at least 35 are desd in Liloan, a town known for its century-old lighthouse and famous for its brittle barquillos, a Spanish-era delicacy of rolled thin wafer made of egg whites, flour, sugar and butter.
That life is as fragile as barqulllos in Liloan showed itself to be true when Tino hammered the town.
One survivor also in Liloan, whose ordeal was recounted as told to Clavio and Sison, escaped the flooding that already filled her house by destroying the ceiling to use it as access to the roof.
On the roof, Clavio and Sison recounted the ordeal as told to them, the survivor saw her entire community turn into a lake with only roofs of houses as reminders that people lived there.
It was a reminder of the ordeal at the height of Yolanda in Tacloban of mayor Alfred Romualdez and his family which became one of the most illustrative of the horror brought by the catastrophic weather anomaly.
The ordeal was repeated many times over diring Tino in Liloan on people not as well known as the Tacloban mayor but just as drastically shaken as the mayor and his family were in the biggest climate disaster of 2013.
In an interview with multiple media outlets on Nov 6 as he inspected the damage in Cebu, Pubkic Works Secretary Vince Dizon said there was obviously a failure in the more than 400 flood control structures built in the province.
‘Someone should be held accountable,’ said Dizon. The investigation, he said, will proceed after the Departmrnt of Public Works amd Highways (DPWH) now reeling from a corruption scandal of an unprecedented scale, helps in recovery efforts.
In Cebu City, dozens of cars rested on top of each other when floodwaters receded, stuck on dirt-filled streets after the rush of water lifted them off like soda caps and carried them hundreds of meters from where their owners thought it safe to park them.
It reminded of typhoon Ondoy (Ketsana) which barelled through Metro Manila in 2009 and brought historic flooding in the capital region. At least 464 people died during Ondoy.
The scenes of devastation around Cebu province during Tino were replications of the ones found all over Liloan town. The terror is as arresting as the grim images that unfolded in Liloan no matter the degree of severity.
In a coastal area of Cebu, news footage showed boulders as large as cars on top of the houses that they demolished, carried into the community by storm surge that some reports said reached more than five meters in height.
In many Cebuano comminities trampled upon by Tino. news footage showed people begging for food, some too dazed to speak or too weak to walk straight.
The horror spread out in other provinces and communities where Tino cut a swath of destruction and caused loss of lives.
In Dinagat Island, Inquirer correspondents Queenie Casio and Chris Panganiban reported toppled posts and trees, bridges unpassable, banana fields nearly wiped out, coconut farms severely damaged and power and xommunication lines cut off.
In Palawan, video clips and still photos posted by netizens showed trees flung to the air with roots still clinging to them. Entire houses were drifting in the wind like rags being blown off by an industrial fan. Toppled trees and electric posts blocked the roads.
On social media, memes with the words CORRUPTION KILLS are starting to trend, obviously referring to statements made by Cebu governor Pamela Baricuatro expressing anger at the failure of more than 400 flood control structires, built at a cost of more than 26 billion pesos, to protect communities and people.
The conclusion came quickly on soxial media-corruption made the flood structures fail.
Hashtag ‘corruption kills’ is likely to trend, too, as a reminder of the trillion-peso plunder of public funds through ghost, unfinished, substandard or duplicate flood control projects discovered in recent days:
In his interview over dzBB, Lagmay expressed disappointment over the priority being given to infrasticture-driven solutions to flooding.
More sensible solutions are based on the science of nature, he said. Trees, for example, can absorb huge volumes of rain that would otherwise end up as runoff water: Rain catchment basins help tremendously. Infrastructure should be just to complement the nature-based solutions, not as a first line of defense, Lagmay said.
There would be no blllions to steal in these projects, he added.
But as the nation debates and seeks answers to the devastation left by Tino, one could not help but be haunted by the anguished cry of one Liloan resident in a mix of Cebuano and Filipino: ‘We lost everything so fast, we don’t know where to start now.’