An independent review has unanimously ruled Jonathan Haggerty’s disputed knee against Hiroki Akimoto legal, the Bangkok Post understands, leaving his ONE Championship bantamweight kickboxing title victory intact.
A 12-member commission voted 12-0 in favour of the strike’s legality, and Akimoto’s team has been informed of the outcome, a source close to the situation said.
The commission is understood to have based its unanimous verdict primarily on a finding that Haggerty did not have both hands on Akimoto during the disputed sequence.
Central to that assessment was the interpretation of a clinch as involving both hands around an opponent’s head and neck.
The finding follows a protest from the Japanese challenger’s camp over the finishing sequence at ONE Samurai 4 on Oct 17, when Haggerty retained his title with a third-round stoppage at Tokyo’s Ariake Arena.
Had the finish been ruled illegal and Haggerty’s victory changed to a disqualification loss, he could have lost the belt to Akimoto. ONE titles have changed hands by disqualification, including Joshua Pacio’s strawweight MMA win over Jarred Brooks after an illegal slam in Qatar in March 2024, although that ruling was made on the night.
An adverse finding would also have raised questions over whether Haggerty would have to return his US$100,000 performance bonus. ONE had not publicly clarified what an illegal-strike ruling would mean for the result, title or bonus.
Akimoto’s camp alleged that Haggerty held and pulled Akimoto into knee strikes, breaching restrictions it said were explained during the pre-fight rules briefing.
‘Under ONE Championship’s kickboxing rules, holding an opponent, pulling them in and delivering knee strikes is prohibited,’ Akimoto’s manager wrote in the English version of the team’s initial Instagram statement.
The camp subsequently questioned referee Olivier Coste’s handling of two incidents, saying no warning was given after the knee that caused the first knockdown, or after a similar action shortly afterwards.
In an Oct 21 update, Akimoto’s management said ONE had agreed to a formal video review involving a third party, with an answer expected within a week.
The commission’s membership and detailed reasoning were not available to the Bangkok Post.
ONE chairman and CEO Chatri Sityodtong had publicly defended the finish during a Facebook Live broadcast last week on the promotion’s Thailand page, without announcing the review’s findings.
‘There was no foul,’ he said in Thai.
Chatri argued that Haggerty had used one hand and had not pulled Akimoto into the strike.
‘If you watch the slow motion, when the knee hits Akimoto’s face, Haggerty’s hand has already slipped free,’ he said.
‘It is near his head, but it isn’t in contact.’
Those remarks offered a more detailed defence than his initial assessment at the post-event press conference, when he acknowledged he had not yet reviewed the footage.
The finishing sequence began with a right hand from Haggerty before a knee dropped Akimoto. The challenger beat the count, but further punches and another knee prompted his corner to throw in the towel after 42 seconds of the third round.
The 29-year-old British champion received a US$100,000 performance bonus for the victory, his third successful kickboxing title defence after wins over Wei Rui and Yuki Yoza.
Akimoto’s manager reported that the 34-year-old had suffered a nasal fracture and a cut to the bridge of his nose. The Oct 21 update said he was undergoing detailed examinations and preparing for surgery.
The defeat ended his three-fight winning streak against John Lineker, Wei and Taimu Hisai, which had earned him another opportunity to reclaim the title he lost to Petchtanong Petchfergus in November 2022.
Haggerty has described the use of his knees as a tactical adjustment, explaining in an interview published by ONE how he discussed bringing them into the fight with coach Christian Knowles.
‘My knees are my new elbows,’ he said.
A return to Muay Thai remains among his ambitions. Haggerty has not competed under that ruleset since losing his bantamweight title to Superlek Kiatmoo9 in September 2024.
During last week’s Facebook Live, Chatri indicated Haggerty was expected to return in 2027 and expressed interest in a fight with current Muay Thai champion Yod-IQ Or Pimolsri.
Yod-IQ’s foot injury has been affecting his training, however, and the match-up has not been confirmed.