Kakuzi Plc has returned to the Supreme Court seeking a review of a judgment dismissing its appeal in a protracted ownership dispute over a 72-acre parcel of land occupied by Makuyu Club.
In an application filed following the October 23 judgment, the agricultural firm argues that the apex court made an error in finding that the failure to register a donation of the land to the club rendered the gift incomplete, paving the way for a claim of adverse possession.
‘The applicant seeks a review of the court’s judgment on the grounds that the court’s finding at paragraph 37 of the judgment was based on the erroneous finding that a donation [for specified purpose of playing golf] being a licence, was a registrable interest in land,’ Kakuzi said.
The company argues that a licence was not a registrable instrument under the now-repealed Registration of Titles Act, which was replaced by the Land Registration Act.
It further contends that in 1967, when it acquired the expansive property, there was no statutory requirement for registration of a licence under the Registration of Titles Act.
‘Consequently, the court’s finding that the failure to register the licence resulted in an automatic lapse of the licence thereby triggering the running of time for adverse possession was based on a non-existent law, hence a ground for review,’ said Ms Janet Kabaya, a legal officer at Kakuzi.
In the judgment, the Supreme Court upheld the Court of Appeal’s decision recognising Makuyu Club as the lawful owner of the contested land through adverse possession.
The judges found that the club had demonstrated continuous, uninterrupted and exclusive occupation for the period required by law, while Kakuzi failed to take clear and unequivocal steps to assert its ownership within the limitation period.
The court noted that the club had occupied the property since 1934, with the knowledge of Kakuzi and its predecessor, and continued using it after the company acquired the larger parcel in 1967.
‘The respondent (Makuyu Club), thereafter, remained in continuous, uninterrupted, and exclusive possession of the land until 2002, when, after a period of approximately thirty-five (35) years, it instituted proceedings seeking to acquire title by way of adverse possession,’ the court said.
The judges added that a subsequent owner must assert its ownership through clear and unequivocal acts capable of interrupting the adverse possessor’s occupation.
‘We are satisfied that the appellant (Kakuzi) failed to do so within the prescribed limitation period,’ the court ruled.
The dispute concerns approximately 72 acres in Murang’a County, which Makuyu Club has used as a golf course for decades.
The club maintains that white settlers donated the land in 1934 for use as a golf course, long before Kakuzi acquired the larger property in 1967.
In 2002, the club moved to court seeking to be declared the lawful owner, arguing that it had occupied the land for more than 12 years.
Kakuzi opposed the claim, maintaining that the club’s occupation had always been with the consent of the company and its predecessor, and could therefore not amount to adverse possession.
The firm argued that the club had entered the property as a donee and that its use of the land was permissive rather than hostile to the owner’s interests.
It also maintained that it had never abandoned its proprietary rights, citing various forms of assistance it had extended to the club over the years.
These included supplying diesel, petrol and lubricants, lending tractors and lawnmowers, paying wages for clubhouse watchmen and golf course employees, and providing equipment such as coats and torches.
However, the Court of Appeal had ruled that such assistance, including supplying water and grass mowers, paying workers and making donations, did not amount to an assertion of ownership capable of interrupting the club’s occupation.