Competitive edge: Is your ‘strategy’ really an operational plan?

You can paint your car bright red, call it a Ferrari Testarossa, but it’s still a Toyota Corona. Being faster, innovative, more effective is necessary, but is that a strategy?

Is there a 90 percent chance your organisation’s ‘strategic plan’ is an operational plan? Why do we confuse garden variety business planning with having a strategy? Has the word ‘strategy’ become just a buzzword, whose meaning has been lost in a tsunami of hype?

Nothing wrong with business planning, it’s essential and relatively easy.

Our brains are wired for it with that little voice in your head — impossible to turn off — constantly saying: do this, and do that. Always thinking a few steps ahead. Somehow strategy and planning, two very different things, have been lumped together in ‘strategic planning’.

Having a plan for operational effectiveness is a basic requirement. Performing similar activities better than rivals do, for instance, lower costs, faster delivery, better quality, or using artificial intelligence [AI] is planning. Focus is on running an efficient machine, not about choosing a distinct destination.

Strategy is the secret sauce. With limited ‘underdog’ resources, what is the distinctive, leverage point approach to be taken? Strategy means performing activities differently from rivals, or performing distinct activities altogether, to deliver a unique mix of value. Plus, strategy requires choosing what not to do.

First critical thinking diagnosis

Done with a lot of noisy song and dance, plans called ‘strategic’ would sit on the shelf gathering dust. For Roger Martin, a strategic plan is ‘An integrative set of choices that positions you on the playing field of your choice, in a way that you win.’

Strategy is tricky, demanding an injection of a MRI like revealing diagnosis. In comparison, planning is easy. Anyone can do it, and anyone does. What would take two months in the past, AI can now do in seconds. Makes sense to treat AI like a sharp analyst that is lightning fast, but at times may be lacking in judgment.

There are ocean super tankers full of books, materials, videos on business strategy. Good Strategy, Bad Strategy written by Richard Rumelt has become a straight forward classic. For Rumelt strategy has a ‘kernel’ consisting of diagnosis, guiding policy and coherent action.

Dovetailing with this, applying Roger Martin’s four questions approach to strategy is helpful: 1) Aspirations? 2) Where to play? 3) How to win? and 4) Management capabilities required? – helps cut through the noise and fluff.

Companies can survive for decades on just operational planning. Just look out in the market place, whether in insurance, banking, or hotels and hospitality. If you changed the name, would you be able to tell the difference?

Paradoxically, with fierce business rivalry, comes an increasing sameness. With time, competing on the same playing, wearing the same uniform thinking companies regress towards the mean, and eventually fall prey to Schrumpeter’s creative destruction. At the edge of the corporate normal curve will be a few outliers, with a distinct strategy, seeing the big picture patterns, but managing to ‘think different’ to reimagine.

Competitive convergence risk

Part of the reason planning is necessary, but not sufficient is that it is easy to imitate. Tech improvements, benchmarking, reengineering, outsourcing, and quality improvements are easily copied by competitors. When everyone improves the same best practices, companies experience competitive convergence — they look, act, and sell the same way, often leading to destructive price wars.

Strangely efficiency is not an advantage. Being better, faster, or cheaper is a race without a finish line.

Yes, it raises the bar for the entire industry, capturing value for customers or suppliers, rather than generating sustainable returns for the business. A real strategy is an integrated, mutually reinforcing system of choices that builds a defensible position.

Inward, warm and cuddly

Planning is comforting; it does not need to be coherent. Typically, planning is done in the domain of the ‘known’ on the cost side of the organisation. Proverbial ‘action plan’ to-do list will have operational goals, for example, opening new branches, tech improvements, launching new products. These are all inward things the company can pretty much control, as they are the equivalent of an internal customer.

Outward and unpredictable

Strategy has an outward focus on the often unpredictable customer, who the company can not control.

Creating angst, strategy is uncomfortable. Good strategy applies a variant of the centuries old problem solving scientific method and is based on a hypothesis, ‘a best guess’. Hopefully based on analysis, one is saying – ‘Here is what we think will happen’. It is impossible to prove the strategy will work in advance, in the domain of the unknown.

Coherence is an absolute requirement, nothing can be contradictory. One has to lay out a transparent logic of ‘what has to true’ for the strategy to succeed, taking into account, for instance, customer preferences, unmet needs, likely competitor behaviours and broader fast moving industry trends.

Strategy is like driving down a mountainous narrow winding road in the thick fog. Forget the five year plan, escape the illusion of the crystal clear view long term planning, in a deceptive hazy cloudy reality of uncertainty, and changing rules. Best to follow the practices of the leading edge tech giants by being agile, constantly experimenting and adapting, on an almost weekly basis.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *