Zaldy Co won’t come home, cites threats

Resigned Ako Bicol Rep. Elizaldy ‘Zaldy’ Co is not returning home soon to face the allegations over his role in the budget insertions and kickbacks from allegedly anomalous flood control projects.

Co’s lawyer, Ruy Rondain, said at a media briefing on Wednesday at the Midas Hotel and Casino in Pasay City, that the former lawmaker wanted to personally respond to the issues but could not do so at this time because of security concerns.

‘Representative Co would have wanted to be here himself to answer your questions. Unfortunately, there are credible and serious threats to his life. He has a general fear of being shot-whether by a vigilante or a political enemy he doesn’t even know,’ Rondain noted.

The only time Co would consider returning to the Philippines is when ‘the threat to his life [has] abated,’ he added. ‘We’ll see him as soon as the fear of violence against him abates. So, I don’t know. Might be next week, might be January. I don’t know.’

As of now, Rondain said coming home is not an option for his client because of the ‘serious threats to his life.’

‘Half of the country wants to throw him in jail and throw away the key. The other half wants to string him up by the nearest tree. Would you come home under those circumstances? I wouldn’t recommend that he come home,’ Rondain said.

Co was linked to alleged irregularities in the P289.5-million flood control project in Naujan, Oriental Mindoro.

In its first interim report, the Independent Commission for Infrastructure (ICI) urged the Office of the Ombudsman to determine the appropriate charges to be filed against 18 public officials, including Co. A month later, the commission recommended criminal and administrative charges against Senators Jinggoy Estrada and Joel Villanueva, Co, and three others in connection with suspected ‘ghost’ flood control projects.

The recommendations stemmed from an alleged kickback scheme, based on sworn affidavits and corroborating evidence from former Department of Public Works and Highways engineers Henry Alcantara, Brice Hernandez, and Jaypee Mendoza.

Addressing questions about Co’s whereabouts, Rondain said he does not know where the former lawmaker is now.

‘Let me get ahead of the inevitable question: I don’t know where he is. I never asked, because it’s not relevant to his defense,’ Rondain said. ‘And frankly, I didn’t want to be in a position where I’d have to lie to anyone if I were asked that question. So no, I don’t know where he is.’

He disclosed that the last information he received about Co’s whereabouts was that he was in Boston, sometime between September and October, for medical reasons.

Rondain said he was able to speak with Co ‘last night,’ but could not say where he has been staying overseas.

‘And I don’t want to lie to you. I’m telling you honestly that I don’t know because I never asked him. Again, because that knowledge is not relevant to me at this time,’ he said.

‘I’m not saying that he was in Boston last night when I talked to him,’ he quickly clarified.

When he resigned as congressman on Sept. 29, Co also cited ‘grave and imminent threat.’

He sought clearance to fly to the United States only in August, but he never showed up at any of the sessions since the 20th Congress opened in July. Hearsay

Rondain, who also served as counsel for former Pampanga Rep. Mikey Arroyo in his tax cases, also dismissed as ‘hearsay and speculation’ the ongoing probe into the purported massive corruption in public infrastructure projects that implicated Co in the various kickback schemes.

For him, Ombudsman Jesus Crispin Remulla had already ‘prejudged’ the possible cases against Co and that there is ‘no tactical benefit’ to filing a counteraffidavit in the Office of the Ombudsman.

Net worth

This, however, was refuted by Brian Hosaka, executive director of the ICI.

All the recommendations for the filing of charges that the fact-finding panel had so far filed were ‘on the basis of the testimonies and on the basis of the evidence given to us’ and testimonies from personalities who themselves admitted involvement, Hosaka said.

The ICI has recommended the filing of plunder, bribery, and corruption charges against Co and five other officials for allegedly being part of a multimillion-peso kickback scheme behind public works projects.

Rondain also pointed out that Co had a net worth of P4.1 billion in 2019, the year he was elected to the House. The lawyer did not show a copy of Co’s 2019 statement of assets, liabilities, and net worth but said he was willing to provide one.

Marcos approves DepEd-World Bank PLUS-D initiative for learning recovery

President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., as chair of the Economy and Development (ED) Council, has approved the Project for Learning Upgrade Support and Decentralization (PLUS-D), a nationwide education initiative aimed at addressing learning losses and granting greater autonomy to regions and schools in implementing improvements.

Managed by the Department of Education (DepEd), PLUS-D will channel resources and technical support directly to schools and regional offices to accelerate learning recovery in the early grades and enhance instruction in junior high. The project combines nationwide learning interventions with targeted grants to more than 11,000 schools identified as ready to implement decentralized activities.

Supported by the Department of Economy, Planning, and Development (DEPDev), the six-year project will be financed through a P34.79 billion ($600 million) World Bank loan and a P3.47 billion ($60 million) counterpart from the Philippine government. Around 21.2 million K-10 learners are expected to benefit from the combined nationwide and targeted interventions.

Education Secretary Sonny Angara said the approval signals a major shift toward empowering those closest to learners to make decisions that directly affect education outcomes.

‘We know that a one-size-fits-all solution is not necessary to address learning gaps in every classroom. With PLUS-D, schools that have the capacity and readiness can move faster, innovate more, and be held accountable for real results for learners. We need to trust those closest to the children,’ Angara said. PLUS-D will provide system-level interventions, including technical and operational support for a nationwide learning acceleration program addressing gaps from Kindergarten to Grade 6, complementing the ongoing Academic Recovery and Accessible Learning (ARAL) Program.

A key feature of the project is a grant program for regional offices and schools, enabling them to finance targeted interventions for local learning improvement, teachers’ capacity building, and inclusive education. The initiative also strengthens performance-based accountability, where schools that significantly improve learning outcomes may receive additional funding and public recognition. The program will also expand the number of teachers receiving laptops to complement the existing Computerization Program and support DepEd’s digital transformation in basic education.

Implementation will begin in select regions, based on readiness indicators such as planning capacity, financial management, and school governance systems.

’Tino’ death toll surges to 114; 127 still missing

At least 114 people have died in Typhoon Tino’s wake, the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC) reported on Thursday, November 6.

Most of the death toll is concentrated in Cebu, with at least 71 people reported dead. Negors Occidental had the second-highest death toll at 18 people.

At least 12 others were killed in Negoros Oriental while six died in Agusan del Sur. At least two other people died in Southern Leyte.

Meanwhile, Antique, Capiz, Iloilo, Bohol and Leyte, had one death each.

The NDRRMC said that at least 65 other people are missing in Cebu and 62 are also still missing in Negors Occidental.

Cebu also recorded the highest number of wounded persons, with 69 people sustaining injuries. At least 82 people have been recorded as injured overall.

In an earlier report, the NDRRMC said that around 1.95 million people have been affected by Tino.

More than half a million people have been displaced across evacuation centers.

While Tino has left the Philippine area of responsibility (PAR), another cyclone is set to hit the Philippines.

Tropical Storm Fung-Wong, which will be named Uwan once it enters the PAR, is expected to reach typhoon category by Friday.

Meteorologists predict that Fung-Wong could even become a super typhoon by Saturday.

The new cyclone is expected to hit northern and central Luzon, warning that Signal No. 5 is possible.

Philippines declares state of calamity after Tino’s onslaught

President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. on Thursday, November 6, declared a national state of calamity following the disastrous onslaught of Typhoon Tino.

Following a situation briefing with his ministers, Marcos said that Tino has devastated the country, particularly Cebu.

‘Because of the scope, shall we say, problem areas, that have been hit by Tino, and will be hit by Uwan, there was a proposal from the NDRRMC (National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council), that we will declare a national calamity,’ Marcos said.

‘We are doing everything we can to anticipate and prepare for the coming Typhoon Uwan,’ he added.

Tino’s death toll has reached at least 114, with 127 people still missing across the country.

Marcos said that around 10 to 12 regions have been affected or are expected to be affected by the twin cyclones.

That scope justified the declaration, he said, as it would give the government quicker access to emergency funds.

It would also streamline the procurement process, as it skips the usual procedures, Marcos said.

Over 1.9 million Filipinos have already been affected by Tino. While it is still in the tropical storm category, Uwan is expected to intensify into a super typhoon by Saturday.

War crimes trial of Ruben Vardanyan advances as victims testify in Baku [PHOTOS]

The criminal case against Armenian citizen Ruben Vardanyan, charged under articles of the Republic of Azerbaijan’s Criminal Code related to crimes against peace and humanity, war crimes, terrorism, financing of terrorism, and other serious offenses, continued on November 4.

The open court session at Baku Military Court-presided by Judge Zeynal Agayev, with Judges Anar Rzayev and Jamal Ramazanov (reserve Judge Gunel Samadova)-provided the accused with an interpreter in his native language, Russian, and state-funded legal representation.

Judge Zeynal Agayev introduced the court panel, state prosecutors, interpreters, and others to the victims participating for the first time and their legal heirs or representatives, explaining their rights and obligations as stipulated by legislation.

Subsequently, Emil Babishov, the new lawyer defending Ruben Vardanyan’s rights, submitted a motion to the court.

He noted that in previous sessions, Vardanyan and his then-lawyer had filed several motions. The full extracts of the court’s decisions on those motions had not been provided to the defense. The lawyer requested that the full extracts be delivered to the defense side.

It should be recalled that in the previous session, a new state-appointed lawyer was assigned to Ruben Vardanyan. Until then, his rights were defended by a lawyer of his own choice. Two sessions prior, Vardanyan had waived his chosen lawyer.

Judge Zeynal Agayev stated that the extracts in question had already been provided to the defense and that they could continue to exercise this right.

Ruben Vardanyan then submitted another motion, requesting the summoning of a representative from the State Border Service to the court session. He explained that this relates to one of the charges against him-illegal crossing of the Republic of Azerbaijan’s state border.

Vardanyan’s defense lawyer, Emil Babishov, also supported the accused’s position and motion, requesting its satisfaction.

Addressing the motion, Senior Assistant to the Prosecutor General Vusal Aliyev stated that the defense’s motion did not clearly indicate who should be summoned and for what reason, what testimony that person could provide in the witness phase, and its relevance to the charges against the accused. He added that there is no need for statements from State Border Service employees regarding illegal border crossing in the current proceedings.

Vusal Aliyev stated that if the accused claims to have crossed the Republic of Azerbaijan’s state border legally-contrary to the charge-and wishes to prove it, there are procedures provided by law. If the accused entered Azerbaijani territory legally, his civilian passport should bear the stamp of the State Border Service. He can prove this by presenting the stamp in his passport.

Vusal Aliyev requested that the motion not be granted.

After hearing the parties, the court issued a decision: the motion was left without consideration.

Judge Zeynal Agayev also noted that if information about the individual is provided in accordance with the law, the matter can be discussed.

The judge then announced that a group of recognized victims had submitted applications to the court, stating that due to valid reasons they could not attend the proceedings and confirming their preliminary investigation testimonies.

The parties raised no objections to the announcement of these testimonies in court.

Subsequently, victims who suffered from Armenia’s aggressive war and occupation policy gave statements.

Responding to questions from state prosecutor Terane Mammadova, victim Sagif Mikayilov said he was injured due to provocations by remnants of the Armenian army and illegal Armenian armed groups in the direction of Asgaran settlement, Khojaly district.

Victim Aydin Garibov stated that in Khalfali village, Shusha district, he, Ceyhun Shahnamazli, and Tarlan Jabbarov were wounded by enemy fire.

Answering questions from Nasir Bayramov, Head of the Department for Defense of State Prosecution at the Prosecutor General’s Office, victim Kenan Abilov said he received a bullet wound to his left arm from enemy small arms fire on an unnamed height in Khankendi district.

Victim Yusif Veysov stated that in Chanagchi village, Khojaly district, he suffered shrapnel wounds to the kneecap when a mortar shell fired by remnants of Armenian armed forces and illegal groups exploded nearby.

Victim Rahib Mammadov, answering questions from state prosecutor Fuad Musayev, said that in Zangezur district, due to an enemy hand grenade explosion, Farid Mehbaliyev and Tabriz Rahimov were killed, while he, Ibrahim Mayilli, Seymur Hasanov, and several others whose names he does not currently recall were injured.

Togrul Najafli emphasized that in Zangezur district, due to enemy provocation, he and several others were injured, while Farid Rustamov, Farid Mehbaliyev, and Tabriz Rahimov were killed.

Answering questions from state prosecutor Vusal Abdullayev, victim Faiq Jafarov noted that in Lachin district, due to an enemy mortar shell explosion, he and several others were injured, while several more were killed.

Victim Emin Mammadov, responding to questions from Senior Assistant to the Prosecutor General Vusal Aliyev, said that in Lachin district, due to an enemy hand grenade explosion, Ali Aliyev was killed, while he, Tural Aghjabayov, Gabil Mammadov, and several others whose names he does not recall suffered various bodily injuries.

Ramazan Mahammadov stated that in Khojavend district, due to an enemy artillery shell exploding nearby, he and several others were injured.

Victims Seyran Eminov, Vuqar Mammadov, Tural Bagirov, Narmaddin Guliyev, Ali Rustamov, Ahmad Ibrahimov, Tural Imamguliyev, Saleh Ismayilov, Asif Mammadov, Ariz Hashimov, Vidadi Khaniyev, and Nazir Gulaliyev reported being injured due to enemy provocations in Kalbajar district.

Gulu Guliyev, Boyukaga Hasanov, and Sakhavat Guliyev stated they were injured in Lachin district; Seymur Hasanov, Asif Mammadov, and Ugur Shukurlu in Zangezur district due to enemy provocations.

Subsequently, Ibad Ismayilov, Ilkin Rahimov, and Elmir Beydullayev stated they were injured in Khojavend district; Aykhan Abdullayev near Isa Spring in Shusha city; Gunduz Gurbanov in Khalfali village, Shusha district; Rafael Salimov in Aghdam district; and Hijran Sultanov in Aghdara district due to provocations by remnants of the Armenian army and illegal armed groups.

Documents from the criminal case materials collected during the preliminary investigation were also announced in court, and evidence was examined.

The next court session is scheduled for November 18.

Ruben Vardanyan faces multiple charges under the Criminal Code of the Republic of Azerbaijan, including Articles 100.1, 100.2 (planning, preparing, initiating, and waging a war of aggression), 107 (deportation and forced displacement of the population), 109 (persecution), 110 (forcible disappearance of persons), 112 (deprivation of liberty contrary to international law), 113 (torture), 114.1 (mercenary activity), 115.2 (violation of the laws and customs of warfare), 116.0.1, 116.0.2, 116.0.10, 116.0.11, 116.0.16, 116.0.18 (violation of international humanitarian law norms during an armed conflict), 120.2.1, 120.2.3, 120.2.4, 120.2.7, 120.2.11, 120.2.12 (intentional murder), 29.120.2.1, 29.120.2.3, 29.120.2.4, 29.120.2.7, 29.120.2.11, 29.120.2.12 (attempted intentional murder), 192.3.1 (illegal entrepreneurship), 214.2.1, 214.2.3, 214.2.4 (terrorism), 214-1 (financing of terrorism), 218.1, 218.2 (creation of a criminal group), 228.3 (illegal acquisition, transfer, sale, storage, transportation, and possession of firearms, ammunition, explosives, and devices), 270-1.2, 270-1.4 (acts threatening aviation safety), 278.1 (forcible seizure or retention of power, forcible change of the constitutional structure of the state), 279.1, 279.2, 279.3 (creation of armed formations not provided for by law), and 318.2 (illegal crossing of the state border of the Republic of Azerbaijan).

Pruksa expands into apartment-for-rent sector

SET-listed housing developer Pruksa Holding has diversified into the apartment-for-rent business to secure recurring income amid a sluggish residential market, targeting a rental yield of 6-8%.

Piya Prayong, chief executive of Inno Home Construction Co (IHC), a subsidiary of Pruksa, said the company aims to increase its proportion of recurring income from rental housing under the new “iPlern” brand, with rents starting from 2,000 baht a month.

“We plan to invest about 100 million baht in the fourth quarter of this year to launch the first five iPlern projects in Rangsit, Lam Luk Ka and Bo Win — locations surrounded by factories and universities,” he said.

These projects are expected to generate about 1 million baht in annual recurring rental income, providing additional cash flow during the housing market downturn.

In the first half of 2025, Pruksa reported total revenue of 6.94 billion baht, down 30% from the same period last year, with about 74% deriving from residential sales. Net profit plunged 76% year-on-year to 90 million baht.

He said the apartment rental market in Thailand remains promising, with around 745,000 units worth around 27 billion baht, expanding about 3% annually.

The market enjoys an average occupancy rate of 90%, driven mainly by Gen Z renters, particularly students and first jobbers.

To capture this growing segment, IHC plans to redevelop Pruksa’s existing land previously allocated for townhouse and condo projects into apartment complexes in high-demand locations, such as industrial zones and university districts.

In 2026, the company expects to ramp up investment to 2 billion baht to develop 100 additional projects nationwide.

By 2029, IHC aims to operate 316 apartment projects, generating around 640 million baht in annual rental income and holding total assets worth 6.3 billion baht.

The firm plans to later divest these assets into a real estate investment trust (REIT) to fund future expansion.

“Our focus next year will be on major university areas across Thailand, such as Bangkok University and Kasetsart University,” Mr Piya said. The projects will target students (40%), factory workers (35%) and first jobbers (25%).

Rental rates will vary by location and room size, starting from 21 square metres. Apartments near universities are set with 4,000-5,000 baht a month, compared with condos at 7,000-10,000 baht.

Units near industrial zones will start from 2,000-3,000 baht, while those in city centres will command 8,000-10,000 baht a month.

Mr Piya said IHC aims to capture a lower purchasing segment than that of condos to avoid direct competition with Pruksa’s flagship Plum Condo brand, with the monthly rate of 7,000-8,000 baht.

In the longer term, IHC plans to introduce a hybrid “Plern” model combining apartments and affordable condos within the same development — though in separate buildings — with condo prices starting from 600,000 to 700,000 baht.

IHC projects an internal rate of return of 13-15% and an annual yield of 8-10% from its apartment portfolio.

Typhoon Kalmaegi to bring heavy rain, floods

Heavy rain and floods are possible in the Northeast, the East, the Central Plains and the North from Friday to Sunday due to the influence of incoming Typhoon Kalmaegi, warns the Meteorological Department.

Sugunyanee Yavinchan, director-general of the department, said that Typhoon Kalmaegi was located in the South China Sea at 4am on Wednesday and would reach central Vietnam on Thursday or Friday before weakening into a tropical storm and a depression.

Consequently, rain would increase and isolated heavy rain would occur in upper regions of the country, starting from the Northeast and then expanding to the East, the Central Plains and the North. Flash floods, run-offs and overflowing waterways would be possible in the regions from Friday to Sunday, Ms Sugunyanee said.

She advised small boats be kept ashore instead of going into the Andaman Sea on Thursday and Friday due to rough sea.

Aramco’s $21bn dividend puts NNPC under spotlight

Saudi Aramco’s latest financial results have reinforced the company’s reputation as the world’s most profitable national oil corporation, while at the same time placing Nigeria’s Nigerian National Petroleum Company (NNPC) Limited under renewed scrutiny.

Aramco announced a dividend payout of more than $21 billion after posting a robust third-quarter profit of $28 billion, a stark comparison to NNPC’s failure to remit a single dividend to Nigeria’s treasury through the first eight months of 2025, despite earning over N1.06 trillion from oil production-sharing revenues within the same period.

Experts say the contrast has implications that reach beyond the financial performance of the two firms. It reflects the different roles national oil companies play in their respective economies and exposes the consequences of what critics describe as limited transparency and weak accountability at NNPC.

For a Nigerian government struggling with revenue shortages and rising borrowing costs, NNPC’s refusal, or inability, to remit projected dividends of more than N2.16 trillion is becoming a structural fiscal headache.

Aramco delivers profits

Saudi Aramco’s third-quarter (Q3) earnings show a company operating on a different plane from its global peers. It booked net earnings of $28 billion, benefiting from an increase in crude production after OPEC+ gradually unwound voluntary production cuts and from improved international prices. The company reported free cash flow of $23.6 billion and cash flow from operating activities of $36.1 billion.

Aramco’s average realised crude price rose to $70.10 per barrel during the quarter, compared to $66.70 in the previous quarter. Prices remained lower on a year-on-year basis, but the company compensated by increasing output.

Amin Nasser, chief executive of Aramco, highlighted Aramco’s ability to scale production ‘with minimal incremental cost,’ a characteristic that allows it to remain profitable even in downturns.

But the standout figure from the results was the dividend payout: a base dividend of $21.1 billion, plus a $200 million performance bonus.

For Saudi Arabia, Aramco’s dividends are not merely corporate disbursements; they are an extension of the government’s fiscal toolkit. These payments are essential to financing Vision 2030, the nation’s economic diversification programme, and they enable the kingdom to avoid excessive public borrowing.

While delivering dividends, Aramco is accelerating its investment programme. It has raised its gas production growth target to 80 percent by 2030 from 2021 levels, revised upward from the previous 60 percent goal.

The company’s marquee gas project, the Jafurah shale field, contains an estimated 229 trillion cubic feet of gas and 75 billion barrels of condensate and is positioned to become one of the largest unconventional gas operations outside the United States. Just weeks ago, Aramco signed an $11 billion infrastructure lease deal with Global Infrastructure Partners, monetising assets without relinquishing operational control.

In essence, Aramco is simultaneously paying record dividends and investing heavily in the future of Saudi energy.

NNPC records billions in revenue but remits nothing

In Nigeria, NNPC Limited disclosed in its August 2025 FAAC report that it earned N1.06 trillion from production sharing contract (PSC) profit oil between January and August. PSC profit oil refers to the portion of crude production that remains after oil companies recover their costs – the balance is then shared with the NNPC and ultimately the federation.

The revenue data shows monthly inflows that fluctuate sharply: N105.91 billion in January, N127.66 billion in February, and N204.96 billion in March. After a temporary decline to just N22.77 billion in June, revenues surged to N263.13 billion in August, the highest in the year to date.

Yet, alongside these revenue figures, the FAAC document includes a separate line titled ‘NNPC Ltd Calendarised Interim Dividend to Federation Account.’

The entry remains blank for every month. The company was expected to remit N2.168 trillion to the federation account during the eight months, but instead remitted nothing.

‘You don’t spend billions exploring oil we don’t know exists, while refusing to remit dividends from oil that already exists,’ said Aisha Mohammed, an energy analyst at the Lagos-based Centre for Development Studies.

The FAAC report shows that NNPC split the N1.06 trillion earned from PSC profit oil into three internal allocations: 30 percent as an NNPC management fee; 30 percent to the Frontier Exploration Fund, and 40 percent as the federation share.

In practice, the company retained N318.05 billion as management fees, transferred an equal amount to the Frontier Exploration Fund, and passed N424.07 billion to the federation. The funds allocated to frontier exploration are used to search for oil in prospective basins such as Sokoto, Benue, and Chad – areas where no commercial discoveries have yet been declared.

Meanwhile, the budget expectations tell a different story. Against a revenue projection of N1.58 trillion for PSC earnings, NNPC’s actual collections fell short by more than N518 billion. But the shortfall in PSC revenue pales in comparison to the missing dividend line: a deficit of N2.169 trillion.

Mohammed said, ‘NNPC wants to behave like a private company when reporting revenue, but like a government agency when spending money.’

Agora Policy, an Abuja-based public policy think tank that reviewed the FAAC document, warned that the situation is undermining the country’s fiscal stability. According to the organisation, NNPC has achieved only 15 percent of its projected revenue target to the federation, even though it has delivered 67 percent of the profit oil due to the government.

The transformation of NNPC into a limited liability company under the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) was intended to create a commercially viable entity comparable to Petrobras or Aramco. Instead, NNPC still operates as a revenue gatekeeper, collecting earnings and distributing them through internal mechanisms that lack public visibility.

Nigerian professors earn far less than African peers

A comparative analysis of academic salaries across Africa has revealed that Nigerian university professors are among the lowest earners on the continent, taking home less than $400 (N550,000) monthly, about 13 times lower than what their South African counterparts earn.

The disparity, which education experts say is fuelling a massive brain drain in Nigeria’s tertiary institutions, highlights the deepening crisis in the nation’s university system, where poor remuneration, worsening economic conditions, and inadequate research funding have combined to erode morale and productivity among lecturers.

Despite holding some of the most advanced qualifications and responsibilities in the country, Nigerian academics say their pay no longer reflects the value of their work, especially when compared to peers across Africa.

The Academic Staff Union of Universities (ASUU) has also raised the alarm over the worsening conditions of service for Nigerian academics, warning that the poor remuneration of university lecturers is accelerating the rate of brain drain and eroding the quality of higher education in the country.

Recent data comparing academic salaries across African countries show that Nigeria ranks among the lowest on the continent, with professors earning an average of just $366.66 (N550,000) monthly, according to ASUU salary summaries and media reports, a figure that pales in comparison to their counterparts in South Africa, who take home about $4,800, and Uganda, where professors earn around $1,166 monthly.

According to the analysis, Nigerian professors also earn 13 times less than their South African peers, while those in Kenya ($1,316), Ghana ($720.72) and Lesotho ($834) take home significantly higher pay, according to the University of Nairobi terms-of-service (professor band), Ghana media / university reporting estimates and World Salaries summary for Lesotho academic staff.

Even lecturers in smaller economies such as Malawi ($374), Seychelles (US$1,538.46) and Zimbabwe ($300) earn more than many of their Nigerian colleagues.

The study also revealed that while a South African professor earns an annual average of $58,044, a Nigerian professor earns barely $4,400, underscoring a deep gulf in academic compensation across the continent.

However, while analysts say the devaluation of the naira has contributed to worsen the Nigerian professor’s plight.

Olujimi Dada, chairperson of ASUU at the Ladoke Akintola University of Technology (LAUTECH), described the situation as unsustainable and demoralising, lamenting that Nigerian lecturers now find themselves among the poorest paid in Africa.

‘The remuneration of academic work is not an individual matter; it’s a public document. Even without asking anyone, you can go online and compare what Nigerian lecturers earn with their peers elsewhere in Africa, not to mention in advanced countries. Our government is not doing the right thing. It expects better output from us, but what about the input?’ Dada said

He recalled that Nigeria once attracted academics from around the world due to competitive remuneration and world-class facilities but has now become unattractive to both local and foreign scholars.

‘There was a time when our universities were filled with expatriates from different parts of the world. That can no longer be said now. Today, a Nigerian professor earns less than $500, while others earn in excess of $2,000. How do you define that?’ he asked.

Dada also criticised government policies that, according to him, contradict domestic realities.

‘Let me shock you, the same Nigerian government that pays its professors less than $500 sends Nigerians to work in other African countries, spending around $2,000 on them monthly. How can you justify that? Do you think people will leave their comfort zones in Rwanda or Lesotho to come and teach in Nigeria? Nobody will come,’ he stated.

He warned that unless the government takes an urgent action, Nigeria’s tertiary institutions risk returning to the post-independence era when most of their teaching staff were foreigners.

‘We are already at the stage where our universities are losing experts. If you look at our departments today, many no longer have specialists. In the medical field, we hardly have people left. Everyone is leaving because they can’t survive on what they earn here,’ Dada said.

He noted that only fewer graduates are returning to academia, citing the unattractive pay and poor working conditions as major deterrents.

‘If our students can see that there’s no hope in our career, what do you expect them to do? They won’t come back. And when that happens is that you have average people doing the work of experts, and the quality of our graduates will continue to drop.

‘We have made too many sacrifices already. The question now is whether the federal government will seize this opportunity to fix the system, or allow our universities to collapse completely,’ he added.

Experts have repeatedly warned that the sustained neglect of the education sector will deepen the brain drain crisis, with long-term consequences for national development.

At the national level, Chris Piwuna, ASUU president, also reiterated the union’s demands for a comprehensive review of the 2009 ASUU-FGN Agreement, sustainable funding of public universities, payment of outstanding salary arrears and third-party deductions, and revitalisation of the tertiary education system.

Piwuna noted that although the union has temporarily suspended its two-week warning strike, it would not hesitate to resume industrial action should the government fail to address the lingering issues within the one-month window agreed upon.

He noted that ASUU had temporarily suspended its two-week warning strike following a marathon National Executive Council (NEC) meeting in Abuja but warned that the union could resume the strike if progress was not made within the agreed timeframe.

Echoing his concerns, a professor from Oyo State, who preferred not to be named, described the current remuneration of lecturers as depressing and said the worsening economy has further eroded the dignity of academic work.

‘Imagine a situation where someone at the peak of their career- a professor – is not earning up to £500. What you earn is a major motivator, and if that’s poor, it affects your mental health, your welfare, and ultimately your output,’ he explained.

He noted that the high cost of living, inflation, and lack of welfare support have made it nearly impossible for lecturers to live decently, let alone conduct research.

‘A professor is expected to fund part of their research from personal income, but when you can’t even feed your family, how do you fund research? Many lecturers can’t afford basic things. Imagine a professor unable to buy a fairly used 2006 Toyota Corolla worth about N10 million. It would take five years of savings to afford that. What do you expect of junior lecturers?’

He added that the poor state of pay is not just an individual problem but one that threatens the intellectual future of the country.

‘We train the nation’s professionals – doctors, politicians, academics – yet those we train now earn far more than us. It’s disheartening. The system must be regulated to reflect fairness and sustainability,’ he stressed.

Foreign airlines defend dollar ticket sales

Foreign airlines say that their continued sale of flight tickets in dollars is in line with existing agreements with the federal government and not an imposition on Nigerian travellers.

The clarification follows growing criticism from travel agents who say that despite the federal government’s clearance of trapped airline funds, some carriers still charge in dollars, thereby contravening Nigerian laws, worsening forex pressure, and undermining the naira.

Travel agents who spoke with BusinessDay mentioned three airlines currently collecting ticket sales in dollars to include Emirates, Delta and United airlines.

According to United Airlines, ticket sales in Nigeria are offered in both naira and dollars, noting that it has been selling tickets in both currencies since early October.

Delta Air Lines also offers its tickets in dollars. Justifying the rationale behind the action, Mary Gbobaniyi, sales manager for West Africa, Delta Air Lines, told BusinessDay that ‘Delta’s continued sale of tickets in U.S. dollars is consistent with the provisions of the Bilateral Air Services Agreement (BASA) between Nigeria and the United States.’

As of the time of filing this report, Emirates had yet to speak on the issue as the airline could not be reached.

However, a source close to the airline told BusinessDay that the decision of Emirates to collect ticket sales in dollars was part of the agreement it reached with the federal government before resuming flight operations into Nigeria.

The airline resumed operations into Nigeria in October 2024, two years after it suspended flight operations from the country over trapped funds.

Kingsley Nwokoma, president, Foreign Airlines and Representative in Nigeria (AFARN), told BusinessDay that the decision to sell tickets in dollars is predicated on BASA – an agreement regulating the operations of air services between two countries.

‘These agreements are most times reciprocal agreements. If there wasn’t an agreement entered with the government, then the Nigeria Civil Aviation Authority (NCAA) would have long sanctioned these airlines,’ Nwokoma said.

He explained that Emirates had previously suspended operations due to trapped funds, and if their BASA was reviewed before their return, it was aimed at enabling them to operate more efficiently and confidently while addressing their earlier concerns.

The AFARN president however hinted that the majority of the foreign airlines sell tickets in naira, and no airline will deliberately contravene the rules of the country.

Trapped funds’ measures

In 2023, when foreign airlines’ trapped funds in Nigeria reached $744 million, they introduced several measures to reduce delays in repatriating their earnings, which became a significant issue due to foreign exchange (FX) shortages and restrictions.

The measures included increasing ticket prices to hedge against future forex losses, selling tickets in U.S. dollars instead of the naira, and reducing the number of flights or seat inventory available in the Nigerian market.

Airlines also blocked low-ticket inventories, leaving high inventories to be sold in naira only, while the low-ticket inventories on most airlines’ websites could only be bought with dollar cards.

Nearly two years after the federal government cleared the trapped funds, some foreign airlines have continued to sell tickets in dollars.

Foreign airlines criticised

Susan Akporaiye, managing director and CEO, Topaz Travels and Tours, told BusinessDay that airlines still selling tickets in dollars have absolutely no reason to continue to do so. ‘Personally, it’s a total disregard and lack of respect for our country Nigeria,’ she said.

‘No reason to do so’

Akporaiye, who is also the former president of the National Association of Nigeria Travel Agencies (NANTA), further said that the practice could result in market marginalisation and naira devaluation.

Yinka Folami, current president of NANTA, told BusinessDay that even if BASA agreements were signed in the past, these agreements could be reviewed in line with current realities.

Folami described it as anti-trade, disrespectful, and harmful to the nation’s aviation industry.

Folarin stressed that such actions have contributed to the rise in ticket prices, further straining passengers and weakening local travel businesses across Nigeria.

He called on the Nigerian government to assert its sovereignty by mandating airlines to accommodate naira transactions in their booking systems.

‘The naira is stabilising, and we must respect it. There’s no need for dollar-only trade in this market anymore,’ Folarin said. ‘The Central Bank of Nigeria is on top of the situation, and there’s liquidity and transparency. We should be congratulating the CBN and assisting the government to support the naira.’

Folarin also warned against potential job losses if the practice continues.

NCAA responds

Mike Achimugu, director, Public Affairs and Consumer Protection, NCAA, said the Director of Air Transport Regulations

has received similar reports of ticket sales in dollars and has commenced investigations into them. Achimugu said the director is writing to all airlines, noting that the findings will be made public.