CHINESE Foreign Minister Wang Yi and Philippine Foreign Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro exchanged protests over the July 20 maritime clash at Ayungin Shoal, underscoring the deepening strain in bilateral ties.
China’s Foreign Ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun said Wang lodged a ‘strong protest against the reckless act’ of Philippine Navy sailors, accusing them of ramming inflatable boats into a China Coast Guard (CCG) vessel. Beijing insisted the Philippine side provoked the incident-a claim the Armed Forces of the Philippines has denied.
The exchange took place during Wang and Lazaro’s bilateral meeting on the sidelines of the Asean-related ministerial meetings in Manila, their first Foreign Minister-level engagement in two years.
The DFA earlier said Lazaro protested the ‘violent’ incident that injured a Filipino soldier, while also raising Manila’s objections to the July 10 AI-generated China Daily video portraying Filipinos as ‘stupid monkeys’ and as lackeys of the US and Japan.
On Thursday, a third incident tested the Asian neighbors’ relations: The Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) reported being harassed by the CCG as it, along with the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources (BFAR), conducted fuel subsidy missions for Filipino fishermen at Bajo de Masinloc (BdM). The CCG side used its water cannon and at one point, executed a dangerous maneuver, crossing approximately 500 meters ahead of the bow of BRP Datu Paiburong (MMOV-3018).
Relations at a crossroads
Amid this chain of incidents, Guo quoted Foreign Minister Wang as saying. ‘China-Philippines relations now stand at a crossroads, and it falls on the Philippines to make a right and rational choice about the way forward.’
Wang questioned the timing of the Ayungin clash, noting it occurred a day before his scheduled visit to Manila. He alleged that ‘some forces in the military and police’ deliberately create incidents to derail dialogue, acting on the ‘bidding of external forces’ rather than the well-being of Filipinos.
Wang warned that attempts to ‘provoke trouble with the help of external forces’ would only cause the Philippines to ‘reap what it sows.’
He urged Manila to stop provocative maritime actions, honor commitments made to China, and take steps to stabilize relations.
Teodoro: China has no right to enter
Department of National Defense (DND) Secretary Gilberto Teodoro Jr. on Thursday said Chinese maritime forces, especially its Coast Guard, have no right to enter Philippine territory in the West Philippine Sea (WPS) and interfere with Filipino troops there going about their lawful mandate.
He issued this comment after Chinese Ambassador to the Philippines Jing Quan, attempted to justify the actions of the CCG who clashed with Philippine Navy personnel manning the BRP Sierra Madre (LS-57) in Ayungin Shoal on July 20.
The Chinese envoy claimed that CCG personnel went to Ayungin Shoal after receiving reports that Filipino troops are engaging in construction activities aboard the Sierra Madre, which he said is in violation of a provisional agreement entered into by the two nations.
And while not confirming construction activities, Teodoro said, in a mix of Filipino and English, ‘They have no right to interfere, secondly, they have no right to be there.’
Asked if China’s actions are escalatory in nature in the WPS, Teodoro said, ‘it’s not an escalation. It is part of a design to control the Pacific Ocean.’
The DFA said both ministers nevertheless highlighted progress in negotiations on the Asean-China Code of Conduct and reaffirmed their willingness to conclude talks this year.
They also discussed broader cooperation in trade, investment, agriculture, tourism, connectivity, and people-to-people exchanges, in line with President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr.’s directive to pursue dialogue and diplomacy while remaining assertive in protecting Philippine interests.
Asked if China’s actions are escalatory in nature in the WPS, Teodoro said, ‘it’s not an escalation. It is part of a design to control the Pacific Ocean.’
The DFA said both ministers nevertheless highlighted progress in negotiations on the Asean-China Code of Conduct and reaffirmed their willingness to conclude talks this year.
They also discussed broader cooperation in trade, investment, agriculture, tourism, connectivity, and people-to-people exchanges, in line with President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr.’s directive to pursue dialogue and diplomacy while remaining assertive in protecting Philippine interests.