KRA unearths Sh56m smartphone tax evasion scheme

An importer and a clearing agent face prosecution after the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) uncovered Sh56 million in under-declared tax on a consignment of mobile phones imported through the Eldoret International Airport.

KRA investigators found 55,607 basic smartphones in a shipment whose owners had only declared 3,000 gadget for taxation in customs documents. The investigators also discovered 309 undeclared high-end phones, highlighting the difficulty of relying on broad customs benchmarks to assess consolidated cargo, particularly where large quantities of high-value electronics are packed into mixed shipments.

‘All the taxes due to be demanded,’ KRA officers from Investigations and Enforcement, Business Intelligence and Customs and Border Control units have recommended in a confidential report seen by the Business Daily after determining that the consignment involved both under-declaration and non-declaration of dutiable goods.

‘Prosecute or compound upon request, both the importer and the clearing agent,’ the KRA team adds in the report, citing Section 219 of the East African Community Customs Management Act.

Under-declaration and non-declaration offences under Section 203(a), (b) and (e) of EACCMA, 2004, attract a maximum penalty of USD 20,000 (about Sh2.59 million) or 50 percent of the dutiable value of the goods involved, whichever is higher, or imprisonment of up to three years.

The law also empowers KRA to compound the offences, which means settling the case administratively out of court.

The phones were part of a much wider consolidated cargo shipment containing electronics and other consumer goods.

The manifest included 800 refurbished laptops, 1,300 MacBooks, 63 tablets, 950 mobile phone screens, 1,510 Meeto phone screens, 10 Starlink units, printers, televisions, routers, network equipment and other goods.

There were also six drones, 380 pairs of ear pods, gaming equipment and assorted cosmetics, clothing and shoes.

The KRA officers have also recommended detention of the drones found in the wider shipment pending production of proof of authority from the Kenya Civil Aviation Authority.

‘KRA is actively engaged in unearthing tax evasion schemes in order to boost tax revenue compliance as well as adherence to tax laws and procedures, hence ensuring fair trade is maintained within the market,’ Commissioner for Investigations and Enforcement, Mohamed M’maka, wrote in a press statement on Wednesday.

The case comes weeks after President William Ruto directed the tax authority to reduce the minimum customs benchmark for containerised consolidated cargo to Sh2 million, reversing an August increase that had pushed the benchmark for a 40-foot container to Sh3.2 million.

The higher benchmark had triggered protests from small traders, with the President’s September 2 directive restoring the charge to below the Sh2.5 million level that had applied for about six years.

An insider at KRA told Business Daily that the reversal would put pressure on the authority’s revenue projections.

‘The directive caught us off-guard, and there will be a lot of reviews to correct the mess from the development. The new rates had already been factored into collection projections, and placing the rates back to levels of more than six years ago will certainly cause setbacks,’ the source said.

‘Customs is a key mover for our overall numbers, and any variations on such rates reflect on the bigger picture,’ the source added.

The Eldoret case, however, involves a separate issue from the general customs benchmark, namely the accuracy of declarations made for individual shipments.

The investigation began on September 11 and 12 after KRA received intelligence that a regional airline cargo flight had arrived at Eldoret International Airport carrying suspected undeclared mobile phones and other high-end electronic goods. That triggered a physical verification of the consolidated cargo.

The probe found that the consignment weighed 49,000 kilogrammes and had been cleared through five customs entries, on which importers had paid Sh24.12 million in taxes.

At the prevailing airport benchmark of Sh440 per kilogramme, the report states, the shipment would have generated an expected Sh21.56 million tax. That meant the taxes paid appeared higher than the benchmark.

Physical inspection, however, revealed a substantial discrepancy in the quantity and type of phones contained in one of the entries.

The entry had declared 3,000 mobile phones valued at $10 (about Sh1,295) each, with Sh2.52 million paid in taxes. Investigators instead found 55,607 ordinary smartphones, resulting in an under-declaration of 52,607 units.

KRA calculated total taxes payable on the smartphones at Sh49.92 million against Sh2.52 million already paid on the declared phones, yielding an additional tax liability of Sh47.39 million, according to the investigation report.

There are also 309 undeclared premium phones, including 38 Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra units, 24 Galaxy Z Fold 8s, 24 iPhone 17 Pro Max units and 19 Galaxy S25s, among other models, raising the tax bill to Sh56 million.

The assessment includes import duty, excise duty, value-added tax, the Import Declaration Fee and Railway Development Levy.

For the ordinary smartphones, KRA used an estimated free-on-board value of $10 per unit, while the 309 high-end phones were provisionally valued at $150 each.

The authority said the assessment for the premium devices could change following a formal valuation.

‘The additional taxes applicable to the high-end mobile phones are provisional estimates, pending valuation guidance from the Customs Valuation and Tariff Unit,’ the report says.

Azerbaijan, France discuss regional peace and EU cooperation at UNGA

Azerbaijan and France discussed bilateral and multilateral relations, the Azerbaijan-EU cooperation agenda and the regional situation during a meeting on the sidelines of the 81st session of the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA).

The meeting was held between Azerbaijan’s representative and Jean-Noël Barrot, France’s Minister for Europe and Foreign Affairs.

The Azerbaijani side stressed the importance of constructive engagement, referring to guidance provided during high-level exchanges between the two countries’ Heads of State over the past year.

The discussions also covered Azerbaijan’s efforts to consolidate peace and stability in the region.

The Azerbaijani side said the meeting addressed issues related to bilateral and multilateral relations, Azerbaijan-EU cooperation and regional developments.

Umahi: Why south-east should support Tinubu in 2027

The Minister of Works, Mr Dave Umahi, has said leaders from the south-east should be bold and vocal in educating their people on what he described as the benefits of supporting the President Bola Ahmed Tinubu administration.

Umahi made the appeal in Abuja on Tuesday while receiving the report of the northwest leg of the Nationwide Federal Roads Project Tour conducted by the National Association of Nigerian Students (NANS)

Speaking during the event, Umahi repeated his argument that the people of south-east to support Tinubu’s second term bid because of the Federal Government’s infrastructure interventions in the zone.

‘It is a strategic decision that we Igbos must make. And I commend the south-east governors and the governor of Anambra State for his bold decision.

‘He is not afraid of telling our people the truth; the truth is that we must support President Bola Ahmed Tinubu,’ he said.

The minister said the South-East should compare what the region benefited from successive administrations with the infrastructure and other interventions being undertaken by the

Tinubu administration.

He argued that marginalisation should be considered from the point of the appointments, adding that infrastructure should also be considered.

According to him, the Tinubu administration has broken the jinx in areas where the south-east had previously complained of marginalisation.

‘I call for debate. If you are insulting me, insult me constructively. Do not just empty talk.

‘When I was governor of Ebonyi State for eight years, and now as Minister of Works, what have I done through the support of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu?’ he asked.

The minister also urged south-east stakeholders to support the Tinubu so that other regions would reciprocate when it became the zone’s turn to produce the president of the country.

Umahi commended students who requested access to Federal Ministry of Works project sites across the six geopolitical zones to independently inspect ongoing projects.

He said the students rejected logistics assistance offered by the ministry, insisting on unhindered access to the projects.

Umahi described the initiative as responsible leadership, saying the students had chosen to acquaint themselves with the projects rather than dwell on issues that would not add value to their future.

He also welcomed civil society organisations that had indicated interest in monitoring the projects.

Umahi said the federal government had expanded its four legacy road projects from about 700 kilometres to approximately 1,150 kilometres following a directive by the President.

He cited the Sokoto-Badagry corridor, which he put at 1,068 kilometres, and the Akwanga-Jos road, which he said was 135 kilometres and currently under construction as case studies.

‘Only about 30 per cent of it is constructed as new projects, mostly the Lagos-Calabar Coastal Highway.

‘In most cases, the Lagos-Calabar Coastal Highway is also passing through an existing road, and we expanded it,’ he said.

Umahi listed other projects, including the 156km Gombe-Bauchi road, the 149km Bauchi-Jos road, the new Ogoja-Calabar connection of about 400 kilometres and the Biu-Maiduguri corridor.

He said the Bauchi-Gombe road had been fully rehabilitated, while sections of roads in Bauchi and Jigawa states that had been cut off were being reconstructed using box culverts, rigid concrete pavement and asphalt surfacing.

The minister disclosed that the federal government was contributing 30 per cent of the funding for the legacy projects, while the remaining 70 per cent was being financed through foreign loans.

He explained that the loans were predicated on tolling the roads on completion and using proceeds from the corridors to recover and repay the funds.

On the Lagos-Calabar Coastal Highway, Umahi defended the project against criticisms, saying a substantial portion of the corridor was located within the Niger Delta.

He said the highway would pass through Ondo, Edo, Delta, Bayelsa, Rivers, Akwa Ibom and Cross River states, describing the project as important to the region and the national economy.

PPA taps EU port giant for terminal upgrades

The operator of Europe’s second largest port has agreed to work with the Philippines in building up the capacity, design and standards of local terminals.

With a looming free trade agreement (FTA) with the European Union, the Philippine Ports Authority (PPA) is turning to the bloc for best practices in developing future-ready infrastructure.

The PPA has entered into a memorandum of understanding with the Port of Antwerp-Bruges International (PoABI), operator of Belgium’s Port of Antwerp-Bruges.

The Port of Antwerp-Bruges is Europe’s second largest, next to Rotterdam. It plays a crucial role of linking Belgium to more than 800 destinations globally through its roughly 300 shippers.

PPA general manager Jay Santiago said the memorandum opens up potential cooperation on port planning, development and operations. It also covers digitalization and smart port applications to speed up turnaround times and reduce trading backlogs.

Further, PoABi is expected to help the PPA develop public-private partnership (PPP) frameworks to persuade more private players to build ports.

‘This (partnership) will provide opportunities for capacity-building on operational readiness for PPP port projects, port crisis and emergency response management, cruise port development and port strategy,’ Santiago said.

PoABI head of business development Maartje Driessens said the operator is keen on helping the PPA take the next step in digitalizing its port operations.

Driessens sees possible tie-ups on digitalizing cargo flow and upgrading safety standards. She is also confident that PoABI can share best practices on sustainability efforts, especially as the PPA would soon be hosting shore-based power.

Santiago said the partnership also aligns with the Philippine push to expand bilateral ties with the EU.

The Philippines yesterday announced the conclusion of FTA talks with the EU, making it the third country in Southeast Asia to strike a trade deal with the region.

In signing the partnership with PoABI, the PPA gains access to the best practices of an operator that handles the most important infrastructure to the Belgian economy.

The Port of Antwerp-Bruges employs around 164,000 workers and generates 21 billion euros, or $24 billion, in added value.

CARIBBEAN-HEALTH-Guyana and Burundi join initiative to advance cooperation in pandemic prevention

Guyana and Burundi have joined the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) and the Africa Centres for Disease Control and Prevention (Africa CDC) to advance country-led cooperation and financing for pandemic prevention, preparedness and response.

The PAHO and Africa CDC, together with other countries in the Americas, have since called for sustained investment in pandemic prevention, preparedness and response (PPPR), alongside stronger cooperation between the two regions to protect lives, economies and societies from future pandemics and public health emergencies. The call came at ‘Two Regions, One Future: Financing Pandemic Prevention, Preparedness and Response to Build Global Health Security,’ a high-level side event during the 81st United Nations General Assembly (UNGA), organiised by the Guyana and the Republic of Burundi governments in collaboration with PAHO and Africa CDC with support from the United Nations Foundation.

The event brought together leaders and partners from Africa and the Americas to examine how country-led priorities, stronger regional capacities and sustained financing can reinforce preparedness and build more resilient health systems.

The meeting took place ahead of the Second United Nations High-Level Meeting on Pandemic Prevention, Preparedness and Response, scheduled for September 25, where world leaders will review progress since the first meeting in 2023, and discuss how to sustain political commitment and financing for pandemic preparedness in an increasingly constrained global funding environment.

‘The pandemic showed what happens when countries depend too heavily on distant sources for essential medicines, vaccines, diagnostics and protective equipment,’ said Guyana’s President Dr. Irfaan Ali.

‘Science should know north or south but access to its fruits must never depend on geography. We must build a world in which the global south has the scientific capacity, not simply to receive life-saving innovation but help create it,’ he added.

PAHO’s Director, Dr. Jarbas Barbosa said that preparedness is not a cost to be paid during an emergency.

‘It is an investment we make before one strikes – an investment in public health, certainly, but equally in our economic resilience, our social stability and our collective security. We already have the diagnostic tools, the risk assessments, and the action plans.

‘The real challenged is sustained financing. We must translate priorities into predictable, long-term investments – nationally, regionally, and globally – and maintain those investments during the quiet periods between crises,’ Dr. Barbosa added.’

Discussions drew on lessons from COVID-19 and recent infectious disease outbreaks, highlighting priorities including disease surveillance and epidemic intelligence, laboratory and genomic surveillance, early warning and rapid response, emergency coordination, and other core preparedness capacities.

Sustained investment in these areas can help countries prevent, detect and contain pathogens with epidemic and pandemic potential while protecting essential health services and limiting wider social and economic disruption.

The Director-General of Africa CDC, Dr. Jean Kaseya, said that the next pandemic will not wait for the world to mobilize after a crisis begins.

‘We must invest before emergencies strike, with countries setting the priorities and strong regional institutions able to act quickly. Africa and the Americas carry immense experience, scientific expertise and response capacity.

‘By connecting these strengths, sharing knowledge and building predictable financing around country priorities, we can strengthen health security across both regions and contribute to a safer world,’ said Dr. Kaseya.

During the meeting, participants emphasised the importance of keeping countries at the centre of pandemic preparedness, with governments defining priorities and directing investments according to their national risks, needs and capacities.

Regional organizations such as PAHO and Africa CDC can reinforce these nationally led efforts through technical cooperation, cross-border coordination, knowledge exchange and regional public goods.

‘The current Ebola epidemic in the DRC reminds us forcefully in the urgency of investing in preparation and pandemic response,’ added Ambassador Zephyrine Manirataganda, Permanent Representative of Burundi to the United Nations.

‘Our nation, and the nations of south America and the Caribbean face similar structural threats and we welcome south-south cooperation between our regions in terms of health preparation.’

The meeting also called for a shift from crisis-driven funding towards sustained and strategic investment in preparedness. Such investment protects health, strengthens economic resilience and national security, and supports sustainable development.

The discussion advanced a shared agenda for stronger Africa-Americas cooperation, connecting national priorities with regional capacities and more coordinated domestic, regional and global financing for health security and preparedness.

‘No country can build alone: The regional infrastructure that makes national preparedness coherent; surveillance networks that cross borders; laboratory systems that share capacity; emergency workers that can move where they are needed – these are collective goods, and they require collective investment,’ concluded Dr. Anne-Claire Amprou, French Ambassador for Global Health and moderator of the event.

LTFRB programs exempted from Comelec spending ban

The Commission on Elections (Comelec) has granted the request of the Land Transportation Franchising and Regulatory Board to exempt LTFRB programs intended to cushion the effects of soaring fuel prices.

Acting LTFRB Chairman Greg Pua Jr. said exempted from the Comelec spending ban are the service contracting, Love Bus, free rides and fuel subsidy programs as well as the P12-per-liter fuel discount for public utility vehicle (PUV) drivers.

Also covered by the exemption from the Nov. 2 barangay and Sangguniang Kabataan elections is the public transport modernization program (PTMP), including the three-month aid for the monthly amortization and operational expenses of PUV operators.

The service contracting program provides support based on actual and validated transport services rendered while the fuel subsidy aids qualified PUV operators and drivers to mitigate higher fuel costs and sustain operations.

The PTMP aims to modernize and improve public transportation.

Comelec Chairman George Garcia approved the recommendation of the poll body’s law department to exempt the LTFRB subsidy programs from the spending ban.

A certificate of exemption is needed to implement social welfare projects and services during the ban, according to a Comelec resolution.

‘On behalf of the PUV operators and commuters, the LTFRB expresses its gratitude to the Comelec chairman for understanding the concerns we raised,’ Pua said. ‘This only proved the same direction that we want to pursue: to maximize all the necessary assistance to the Filipino people at a time when they needed the government the most.’

Pua committed to strictly observe all the conditions set by the Comelec for granting the poll exemption ban on the major programs of the LTFRB.

Among the conditions is that no election candidate should be directly involved in the implementation of the LTFRB programs.

The agency was also ordered to submit a periodic written report of the disbursements made in relation to the programs exempted.

‘The exemption is a big relief for the beneficiaries of the subsidy programs, especially at this time that they are really in need of government assistance,’ Pua said. ‘We assure the Comelec of the LTFRB’s compliance with the conditions set.’

CARIBBEAN-SECURITY-Caribbean countries to impose sanctions on Haitian gangs

Guyana and Trinidad and Tobago have agreed to impose a range of sanctions on the notorious Haitian gang, Viv Ansamn, and 23 other similar narco-terrorist groups operating in several countries of the Americas.

The two Caribbean Community (CARICOM) countries are members of the United States- led Shield of the Americas and announced their position following a meeting President Donald Trump on the sidelines of the ongoing United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) in New York.

‘We declare our intention to impose, as applicable and in accordance with our respective international and domestic legal obligations, asset freezes; immigration and visa restrictions for members, associates, and supporters of the organizations; and criminal liability for individuals knowingly providing material support, including logistical support, to the organizations, among other measures,’ the participating states said in a ‘Joint Statement on Defending Hemispheric Sovereignty’ .

The Haitian criminal group Viv Ansamn is a coalition of gangs, led by former police officer Jimmy ‘Barbecue’ Chérizier, and has been blamed for the widespread political instability in the French-speaking CARICOM country, ahead of the first presidential and legislative elections on December 13 this year.

The Shield of Americas member countries have also announced a collective action to confront the scourge of narco-terrorism targeting the Venezuelan gangs- Tren de Aragua and Cartel de Los Soles.

Guyana has in the past expressed concern that Tren de Aragua members had been crossing from Venezuela into Guyana’s Essequibo Region.

Trinidad and Tobago Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar in an address to the UNGA on Tuesday evening said transnational organised crime continues to pose a serious threat to the security and development of small island states.

‘Small states face serious challenges from sophisticated criminal networks that move people, that move weapons, that move narcotics, and illicit finance across national borders.

‘For Trinidad and Tobago, this is not an abstract threat. These networks directly endanger our citizens, they endanger our institutions, and they endanger our development,’ she added.

Brazil’s largest criminal organisation, Primeiro Comando da Capital (PCC), regarded as that Brazil’s largest criminal organization, and the decades-old major drug group, Comando Vermelho (CV), are also on the list of 24 blacklisted groups.

In their statement, the Shield of the Americas members said they intend to defend their economies by enhancing economic cooperation; exploring investment screening mechanisms; safeguarding critical minerals supply chains through diversified and reliable sourcing; and promoting trusted supplier regulations for digital infrastructure, applied on a non-discriminatory basis.

‘We recognize that durable security requires economic development, stable jobs, and tangible opportunities for the people, and that economic sovereignty is successfully defended when capital entering our nations is transparent and verifiable.’

They said they will also defend democratic governance against armed narco-terrorist networks including coordinating on sanctions, designations, and financial actions against terrorists and criminals; expansion of civilian law enforcement; and supplying humanitarian and messaging assistance to defend popular will.

In addition they said they will ‘defend and promote mutual respect for national sovereignty and each nation’s self-determination through multilateral fora to coordinate and advance shared objectives and proposals, such as catalyzing international enforcement actions against transnational organized criminal groups or pursuing needed reforms to multilateral organizations.

‘In furtherance of these three pillars, participating states intend to strengthen cooperation through enhanced intelligence sharing; facilitate access, where appropriate, to security technologies and capabilities; promote training and professional development of human resources; and expand the exchange of best practices.

‘Participating states also intend to deepen cooperation on investment and economic matters and to strengthen consultation on and coordination of common positions on issues of shared interest in regional and multilateral for a,’ according to the joint statement.

They said to facilitate these aims, they intend to co-sign a formal request to the President of the Organization of American States (OAS) Permanent Council requesting a meeting of consultation to decide on the establishment of an Organ of Consultation under Articles 6 and 13 of the Inter-American Treaty on Reciprocal Assistance (Rio Treaty).

‘Once the formal meeting of the Organ of Consultation is convoked, we intend to participate at the ministerial level to consider adopting a resolution promoting and facilitating collective action against narco-terrorist organizations under the Rio Treaty.

‘States that participate in the Shield that are not currently parties to the Rio Treaty declare their support for this initiative and express their determination to contribute to it in accordance with and to the extent possible under their respective international and domestic legal obligations, including by participating in the Organ of Consultation to the extent permitted under its Rules of Procedure.’

Is the Philippines really the world’s No. 1 source of ocean plastic pollution?

A 2021 study published in Science Advances estimated that the Philippines contributes 356,371 metric tons of plastic to the ocean each year, equivalent to 36% of global riverine plastic emissions from 4,820 rivers.

The estimate has since been widely cited in claims that the Philippines is the world’s No. 1 source of ocean plastic pollution. But the figure was generated by a model, not by direct nationwide measurements of plastic entering the sea.

The model used a 2015 baseline and national averages, including waste generation of 0.5 kilogram per person per day and an 81% waste-mismanagement rate. It did not stratify waste generation by income or locality, directly sample household waste segregation, or account for cleanup and waste-management initiatives carried out in later years.

This report examines the assumptions behind that estimate and argues that any updated assessment should incorporate more recent barangay waste audits, direct river-flux measurements and Extended Producer Responsibility compliance data.

It also draws on field observations from Virac, Catanduanes; Bay, Laguna; and the Pasig River, where cleanup efforts and changes in waste management have altered conditions since the baseline data used in the model were collected.

The analysis also considers corporate accountability. Break Free From Plastic brand audits cited in the report have identified Coca-Cola, Nestlé and Unilever among major sources of branded plastic waste in the Philippines, while World Bank reports have emphasized circular-economy infrastructure, policy reforms and improved waste-management systems.

How a modeling paper became a national label

The estimate that the Philippines contributes 36% of global riverine plastic emissions came from a 2021 Science Advances study by Meijer and co-authors on plastic emissions from more than 1,000 rivers.

The study, associated with The Ocean Cleanup, was intended to help prioritize river interventions globally. Its modeling framework, however, was often reduced in subsequent coverage to a ranking of countries by their contribution to ocean plastic pollution.

The Philippines, with 7,641 islands, 421 principal rivers and high rainfall, ranked at the top of the model. The result did not mean Filipinos were necessarily the world’s most wasteful consumers. The model assigns higher probabilities of plastic reaching the ocean to short, steep and densely populated tropical catchments.

Geography, therefore, plays a major role in the result.

The author, a farmer and practitioner in Bay, Laguna, who has also observed conditions in Virac, Catanduanes, questions whether a single national waste-generation average can accurately represent a country with wide income disparities and an active informal recycling sector.

The equation that created the ranking

Meijer and co-authors described their modeling framework in the Science Advances study.

Plastic emissions at a river mouth, or ME, were calculated as the accumulation of mismanaged plastic waste, or MPW, multiplied by the probability that the waste would reach the ocean, or P(E), within a river basin:

ME = S [MPW_ij × P(E)_ij]

MPW_ij represents the mass of mismanaged plastic waste produced in a grid cell, while P(E)_ij represents the probability that the waste will be emitted into the ocean.

The probability of emission was further divided into three components:

P(E) = P(M) × P(R) × P(O)

P(M) is the probability that plastic waste will be mobilized, based on factors such as wind and precipitation.

P(R) is the probability that mobilized waste will reach a river, based on factors including distance from a river, slope and land use.

P(O) is the probability that waste already in a river will reach the ocean, based on distance from the river mouth and river discharge.

One key input, MPW, was calculated as:

MPW = Population × Waste generation per capita × Fraction plastic × Fraction mismanaged

For the Philippines, the model used a 2015 baseline. Population figures came from WorldPop, while the waste-generation figure of 0.5 kilogram per person per day came from the World Bank’s 2018 ‘What a Waste 2.0’ report. The model also used a plastic fraction of 12% to 15% from national waste-composition studies and an 81% mismanaged-waste rate from a 2015 Science study by Jambeck and co-authors.

Under those assumptions, each Filipino was modeled as generating 182.5 kilograms of waste a year, including 23.7 kilograms of plastic, of which 19.2 kilograms was considered mismanaged.

With P(E) estimated at about 17% for Philippine catchments because of factors such as short distances to the sea and heavy rainfall, the model produced an estimate of 3.26 kilograms of plastic per person per year entering the ocean, or 356,371 metric tons nationwide.

The report contrasts this with India, where the model used waste generation of 0.43 kilogram per person per day and an 87% mismanagement rate. Because much of the Ganges basin is more than 1,000 kilometers from the ocean, the model assigned a P(O) of less than 1%, resulting in an estimated 0.09 kilogram per person reaching the ocean.

The comparison shows how sensitive the model is to geography in addition to assumptions about waste generation and management.

Meijer and co-authors also acknowledged substantial uncertainty in the model. Their predictions could vary by a factor of four within a 68% confidence interval and by a factor of 10 within a 95% confidence interval.

Applied to the Philippine estimate, that uncertainty would produce a wide possible range around the central estimate of 356,371 metric tons.

RELATED STORY: From bin to ocean: How plastic waste escapes Philippine systems

The 0.5-kilogram per capita figure is based on older averages

The waste-generation figure of 0.5 kilogram per person per day came from the World Bank’s 2018 ‘What a Waste 2.0′ report, which relied on data from 2012 to 2016.

The report argues that applying a single figure nationwide does not reflect differences in waste generation among communities and income groups in the Philippines.

Waste Analysis and Characterization Studies by the National Solid Waste Management Commission and DENR cited in the report show such differences. Metro Manila generates about 0.69 kilogram of waste per person per day, compared with 0.51 kilogram in highly urbanized cities and 0.30 kilogram in rural municipalities. The figure for some rural barangays is cited at 0.15 to 0.20 kilogram.

Those differences matter because applying a uniform national average can assign the same waste-generation rate to households with very different consumption patterns and waste-management practices.

The data used to estimate mismanaged waste have also changed since the model’s baseline year.

Under the Ecological Solid Waste Management Act of 2000, or Republic Act No. 9003, waste collection and disposal systems have expanded. According to DENR figures cited in the report, collection coverage increased from 40% in 2010 to 70% in 2022.

The report also notes that subdivisions and organized barangays in Laguna, Cavite and Virac have adopted segregated collection systems in which biodegradable waste is composted, recyclables are sent to junk shops and residual waste is taken to disposal facilities.

The model classifies waste as mismanaged when its final disposal site is an open dumpsite.

DENR reported 353 open dumpsites operating in 2019. By 2023, the agency had reported the closure of 335 open dumpsites as disposal systems shifted toward controlled facilities and sanitary landfills.

The report argues that the 81% mismanaged-waste assumption reflected conditions closer to the model’s 2015 baseline than to conditions from 2023 onward.

The model also does not separately account for the informal waste sector. The Philippines has an estimated 500,000 informal waste pickers, including magbobote and mangangalakal, who recover recyclable material before it reaches disposal sites.

The report estimates that informal recovery accounts for 20% to 30% of recyclable plastics. Because such activity may not appear in official collection data, the report argues that it can reduce the amount of plastic available to enter rivers without being fully reflected in the model.

The Meijer model identified the Pasig River as the world’s single highest-emitting river, with an estimated 63,000 metric tons of plastic a year, or 17.6% of the Philippine total.

The report says the estimate reflected conditions around 2017 and 2018, when the Pasig River was heavily polluted.

Conditions have changed since then.

The Pasig River Rehabilitation program under the PRRC and DENR, with private-sector participation, reported removing 1.2 million metric tons of waste from Pasig tributaries from 2019 to 2024.

Trash traps have also been deployed in the San Juan River, while The Ocean Cleanup’s Interceptor 001 and 002 have operated in the Tullahan River since 2021. Metropolitan Manila Development Authority River Rangers also conduct regular cleanup operations.

The report argues that these interventions have substantially reduced visible floating macrolitter. Based on the author’s observations, the floating masses of plastic associated with the Pasig River in 2018 were no longer a daily sight by 2025, although the river had not returned to the condition remembered from the 1950s, when people swam in it.

The report notes that the national model has not been recalibrated using post-2021 data from these interventions.

Similar differences can be seen in smaller waterways.

In Virac, Catanduanes, the author observed that the river passing through the poblacion was generally clear of floating plastic. The municipality has an ordinance restricting single-use plastics, along with community cleanup activities and relatively low industrial activity.

In Bay, Laguna, rivers flowing toward Laguna de Bay, including the Calo and Sapang rivers, are not pristine. But after heavy rains, the author observed that the more visible load was often eroded brown soil rather than floating plastic.

The author also observed bottle-return practices at sari-sari stores and barangay material recovery facilities that, while imperfect, capture some plastic before it reaches waterways.

Soil erosion remains another environmental concern.

The Food and Agriculture Organization’s Global Forest Resources Assessment for the Philippines cited a deforestation rate of 157,000 hectares a year from 1990 to 2010. After heavy rains, soil from degraded watersheds can enter waterways and turn rivers brown.

In the author’s observations in Laguna, sediment was often more visually prominent than plastic bottles and was a concern for aquatic ecosystems and fisheries in Laguna de Bay.

What a fair methodology should be

A more current assessment of Philippine plastic pollution would rely more heavily on direct measurement and locally differentiated data rather than a single national average.

The report proposes:

income-stratified waste-generation audits at the barangay level, consistent with the Waste Analysis and Characterization Studies required under Republic Act No. 9003, rather than a uniform 0.5-kilogram-per-person daily estimate;

recognition of plastic recovered by the informal waste sector before it reaches disposal sites or waterways;

direct and seasonal measurements of river plastic flows using collection methods such as nets, rather than relying solely on probabilities derived from rainfall and geography;

consideration of watershed deforestation and soil erosion alongside plastic pollution, particularly in rural rivers; and

regular recalibration of models after major cleanup and waste-management interventions.

The report does not dispute that plastic pollution remains a serious problem in the Philippines, particularly because of the widespread use of sachets.

World Bank figures cited in the report put sachet consumption in the country at 163 million pieces a day, many of which have low recyclability.

The report argues, however, that applying a single waste-generation figure nationwide can obscure significant differences among households and communities. A household that composts organic waste or sells recyclables to informal collectors does not necessarily have the same leakage profile as waste sent to an unmanaged dumpsite.

Direct river-flux studies and field sampling, the report argues, would provide a clearer picture of how much plastic actually reaches waterways and how those flows change across seasons.

The report also points to corporate responsibility.

The Plastic Tort Administrative Complaint cited in the report argues that the production of nonrecyclable sachets and packaging by multinational companies, including Coca-Cola, Nestlé and Unilever, exceeds the capacity of local material recovery systems.

Break Free From Plastic brand audits similarly place greater attention on the producers and brands associated with discarded packaging, rather than assigning responsibility solely on the basis of where waste is found.

Conclusion

The widely cited estimate that the Philippines contributes 36% of global riverine plastic emissions is not a direct measurement of individual behavior or of all plastic physically entering the ocean.

It is the result of a model based on mismanaged plastic waste and probabilities of mobilization, river transport and ocean transport:

MPW × P(M) × P(R) × P(O).

The report argues that the estimate remains useful as a call to address plastic pollution but should be understood within the limitations of the model and the age of its underlying data.

The 0.5-kilogram-per-person daily waste input is an average rather than a measurement of every Philippine household. It does not account for differences in income, locality, recovery practices or waste-management systems.

A more current assessment would incorporate barangay-level waste audits, informal recovery rates and direct river-flux measurements. It would also take into account changes brought by cleanup programs, expanded waste-management infrastructure and the implementation of the Extended Producer Responsibility Act of 2022.

Field observations in Virac and Bay cited in this report suggest that some waterways now contain less visible floating plastic than they did in previous years, even as soil erosion and sediment remain serious concerns.

The author argues that these conditions also connect environmental security with food security: protecting watersheds can reduce soil loss while improved waste management can reduce plastic leakage.

Any updated national assessment would also need to account for changes since the original model’s baseline, including river cleanups, EPR implementation and the expansion of material recovery and sanitary disposal facilities.

The report concludes that empirical sampling and locally stratified waste audits would provide a stronger basis for assessing the Philippines’ contribution to ocean plastic pollution. It also argues that such assessments should consider corporate production and packaging practices, government waste-management systems, informal recovery and community cleanup efforts alongside national estimates of mismanaged waste.

Baku, Sofia review strategic partnership agenda in New York

Azerbaijan’s Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov met with Bulgarian Foreign Minister Velislava Petrova on the sidelines of the 81st session of the UN General Assembly.

According to Azerbaijan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the meeting focused on the strategic partnership between the two countries and opportunities to expand cooperation.

The two ministers discussed the strategic partnership agenda between Azerbaijan and Bulgaria, including political dialogue, energy cooperation, expanding supplies of Azerbaijani gas to Bulgaria, renewable energy projects, as well as transport and connectivity issues through the Middle Corridor.

The sides also exchanged views on Azerbaijan-European Union cooperation and regional developments.

President Ilham Aliyev received newly appointed ambassador of Estonia to Azerbaijan

On September 23, President of the Republic of Azerbaijan Ilham Aliyev received Tiina Nirk, the newly appointed Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Ambassador of the Republic of Estonia to Azerbaijan.

The ambassador presented her credentials to the head of state.

President Ilham Aliyev then held a conversation with the ambassador.

The head of state stressed the importance of reciprocal visits and contacts at various levels in expanding cooperation between Azerbaijan and Estonia.

Welcoming the development of Azerbaijan-European Union relations, President Ilham Aliyev highlighted this year’s visits to Azerbaijan by President of the European Council António Costa, President of the European Commission Ursula von der Leyen, and Kaja Kallas, EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy and Vice-President of the European Commission.

Tiina Nirk, who said she was honored to have been appointed Estonia’s first ambassador to Azerbaijan, emphasized that she would spare no effort to further develop relations between the two countries, as well as between Azerbaijan and the European Union.

Noting Azerbaijan’s important position along the Middle Corridor, the ambassador pointed to the strong potential for expanding partnership in many areas, including political dialogue, business, information technology, logistics, and other fields.

Tiina Nirk also highlighted broad opportunities for cooperation in education, noting that around 200 Azerbaijani students are currently studying in Estonia.

The ambassador also commended Azerbaijan’s humanitarian assistance to Ukraine.

During the meeting, it was underlined that the opening of the Embassy of Estonia in Azerbaijan would make an important contribution to further developing bilateral relations. The sides also addressed the activities of the Intergovernmental Commission on Economic and Trade Cooperation and discussed issues of mutual interest.