Bid to lift prosecutors’ immunity in Sh63bn Arror, Kimwarer dams case fails

The High Court has dismissed a petition by four lobbies seeking to lift the immunity of two prosecutors involved in the Sh63 billion Arror and Kimwarer dams scandal, ruling that there was no evidence they acted unlawfully, negligently or in bad faith.

Justice Chacha Mwita, now a Court of Appeal judge, said Transparency International, Katiba Institute, Kenya Human Rights Commission (KHRC) and Africa Centre for Open Governance (Africog) had failed to demonstrate that Geoffrey Obiri and Oliver Mureithi deliberately derailed the prosecution or abused their powers.

The organisations wanted the court to hold the two prosecutors personally liable should former Treasury Cabinet Secretary Henry Rotich and other acquitted suspects sue the State for malicious prosecution.

They argued that the prosecutors had violated the Constitution through what they termed reckless dereliction of duty, exposing taxpayers to possible compensation claims arising from the collapse of the high-profile case.

But Justice Mwita said the prosecutors had explained the circumstances that forced them to seek adjournments, including the withdrawal of key witnesses and the absence of a substantive Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP).

‘The court is satisfied that the 2nd and 3rd respondents were forced by circumstances to act as they did. There was nothing to demonstrate that… their action was influenced by nepotism, favouritism, corrupt practices or improper motives,’ the judge said.

The petition followed the acquittal of Mr Rotich and eight others on December 14, 2023, after the prosecution failed to present 41 witnesses in the trial.

In acquitting the accused, trial magistrate Eunice Nyutu raised concerns about the conduct of the prosecution and called for accountability over the handling of the case.

The four lobbies subsequently moved to the High Court, arguing that the two prosecutors should not enjoy immunity under Section 15 of the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions Act because their actions were allegedly not undertaken in good faith.

They also cited Article 73 of the Constitution, which requires public officers to exercise their responsibilities objectively and impartially, without favouritism, corruption or improper motives.

Justice Mwita, however, said the petitioners had failed to establish that the prosecutors deliberately withheld witnesses, ignored available evidence or made decisions that amounted to dereliction of duty.

He said the organisations were required to demonstrate that the alleged challenges cited by the prosecutors were not genuine, including claims that witnesses had recanted their statements or declined to testify.

The two prosecutors told the court that on August 10, 2023, the Directorate of Criminal Investigations informed the DPP that four witnesses had recanted their statements and were no longer willing to testify. Another key witness, the former Director of the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority, had died.

They said further communication from some witnesses on August 30, 2023, confirmed their withdrawal, prompting Mr Obiri to seek directions from the DPP on how to proceed.

The prosecutors also argued that the absence of a substantive DPP affected the trial, with the Acting DPP directing them to await the appointment of a substantive office holder to review the case and give directions.

They maintained that their requests for adjournments were intended to allow an independent review of the prosecution file and ensure the case proceeded on the basis of properly evaluated evidence.

Justice Mwita said the petitioners had not demonstrated that the prosecutors acted in bad faith or that their decisions were influenced by external interests.

He further explained that Section 15 of the ODPP Act protects officers from personal liability for actions undertaken in good faith while performing their official duties.

Quoting a Supreme Court decision, the judge said the immunity was intended to safeguard independent decision-making by protecting prosecutors from the fear of personal liability over decisions made in the course of their work.

The apex court had observed that it would be repugnant to the cause of justice if public officers were forced to discharge their mandates while constantly fearing legal action over their decisions.

The judge said the protection also shields institutions from interference and helps preserve public confidence in their independence, accountability and integrity.

The groups had argued that lifting the immunity would ensure prosecutors were not above the law and would prevent taxpayers from shouldering compensation claims arising from alleged misconduct.

‘Instead, limiting the prosecutorial immunity would at least serve a symbolic function, however, it would show that prosecutors are not entirely above the law that holds other mortals financially accountable for their intentional misdeeds in public office,’ they argued.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *