In continuation from last week’s Business Talk on dictatorships in the workplace, so how does a workplace dictator finally get defeated and a company recover from the damage?
Most employees hold out hope that one heroic employee will end up confronting the boss and things will get better. However, that usually does not happen.
Research offers a much more interesting a nuanced answer in that numbers and alternative sources or power matter when confronting an organisational tyrant.
Famous philosopher Plato writing 2,400 years ago offers a useful starting point for how to fix a dictatorship. Although he did not write a management handbook, in Book VIII of The Republic, he argues politically that tyranny leaves both the ruler and particular communities trapped by fear.
The tyrant appears powerful, yet Plato describes them as increasingly suspicious, friendless, paranoid, and dependent upon flatterers who blow proverbial smoke. The longer a tyranny continues, then the worse the ruler becomes and the more and more miserable everyone around them becomes.
Now, translated into modern organisational life, the first lesson is simple. Do not try to repair a dictatorship by making the dictator kinder. Repair the system that allows one person to dominate everyone else.
A dictatorial manager usually accumulates several kinds of power all at once.
The manager may control work assignments, performance ratings, promotions, disciplinary decisions, access to senior executives, who goes to conferences and meetings, and even the upwards information that senior management receives about the department.
Employees, therefore, learn very quickly that challenging that dictator manager carries great personal professional risk.
The second employee who complains can be labelled disgruntled, the third can be called disloyal, but the fourth may begin wondering whether speaking up will destroy his or her career. But when employees raise ethical concerns collectively, the balance of power begins to change. The manager can no longer portray every challenge as one troublesome individual.
So, the solution requires breaking up that concentration of power and concentration of feedback away from that tyrant.
Mayowa Babalola, Patrick Raymund, James Garcia, Shuang Ren, Babatunde Ogunfowora, and Kubilay Gok studied 521 employees working in 98 groups to investigate the concept of dictatorship, often called in social science as ‘abusive supervision’.
They found that group ethical voice reduced abusive supervision. The effect was particularly strong when the group was larger, had greater power, and interacted frequently with the leader. As a result, organisations need to protect collective voice.
How to do this practically? Senior leaders should meet teams without the line manager present. Staff surveys should allow confidential comments. Human Resources should investigate repeated themes among employees. Boards and executives should treat retaliation against people who speak up as a leadership failure and make bold communications about whistleblower protection.
Further, sometimes the managerial dictator can change their behaviour. A firm that sets clear limits, provides independent oversight, and layers in consequences may actually force different behaviour. But, in reality, often times the manager cannot change. Sometimes a rock is always going to be a rock and sink to the bottom of the organisational pond.
In such situations, the organisation must clearly change the manager. But Plato’s deepest warning concerns what happens when people wait too long. Sadly, tyranny gradually destroys the very people most capable of correcting it. The strongest employees end up leaving, then the remaining employees learn silence is the safest option.
Flatterers and boot lickers gain influence. Senior leaders then receive less accurate information precisely when they need more of it communicated up the chain of command.
So, firms should not construct systems in which one manager controls a wide combination of an employee’s assignments, appraisal, promotion, salary, disciplinary process, and access to senior management. Such organisational conditions in which tyranny can survive. Employees need independent routes they can use to go around managerial power.
In summary, millennia ago, Plato understood the strange peculiar vulnerability of tyrants. Dictators appear enormously powerful because everyone around them has become afraid to speak.
But that silence is also their weakness. It prevents them from hearing reality, pushes away capable people, and gradually leaves them dependent upon weaker followers who tell them what they want to hear. The workplace dictator, therefore, rarely destroys only employees.
Eventually, the dictator starts destroying the organisation that gave him power in the first place.