Ketraco to pay Ecobank Sh549m as Spanish firm claim blocked

Ecobank Kenya has won a court order directing the Kenya Electricity Transmission Company (Ketraco) to pay it Sh549 million from proceeds of a Sh10 billion arbitral award involving a Spanish company against the State agency.

The High Court in Milimani Nairobi ruled that the bank’s claim takes priority over competing claims by Spanish contractor Instalaciones Inabensa SA and COX T and L SL, which says it acquired rights to the award.

The order now directs Ketraco to pay the bank pound 3.8 million (Sh547.9 million) and Sh1.5 million directly and protects the utility from paying the same sums twice.

The ruling resulted from a dispute over two contracts that Ketraco awarded in April 2013 to Spanish contractor Instalaciones Inabensa SA for construction of the 400-kilovolt Lessos-Tororo transmission line and extension of the Lessos substation.

The projects were intended to support electricity trade between Kenya and neighbouring countries.

However, disagreements over contract performance and payments led Ketraco to terminate both contracts on April 25, 2016. Inabensa challenged the decision through arbitration, accusing the State agency of breaching its contractual obligations. On July 30, 2019, the arbitral tribunal found Ketraco liable and awarded the Spanish firm pound 37.365 million (Sh5.3 billion), in addition to interest and costs.

The tribunal also awarded Sh102 million in legal fees, Sh83.5 million in arbitration costs and Sh2 million in administrative expenses.

The claim increased to pound 62.67 million (approximately Sh10 billion including accrued interest) and Sh195.3 million as at February 2024, excluding further interest.

The High Court recognised the award and Ketraco’s appeals failed.

Inabensa acknowledged owing Ecobank pound 5.39 million (Sh777.2 million) and Sh2.7 million, but agreed in a consent recorded on March 10, 2021, to settle the bank’s claim by paying pound 3.8 million (Sh547 million) and Sh1.5 million.

That settlement was secured against the arbitral award proceeds. Ecobank told the court that Inabensa had not honoured the agreement and was seeking to transfer its rights under the award to COX T and L SL following insolvency proceedings in Spain.

Ecobank said releasing the proceeds before settling its claim would expose it to loss, and sought direct payment from Ketraco.

The court allowed the application, finding that the 2021 consent decree remained valid and had not been set aside for fraud, collusion, mistake or misrepresentation. Ecobank’s secured claim predated the Spanish court order and deed of subrogation relied on by COX, both issued in 2023.

‘Even if the foreign recognition were valid, it could not, of itself defeat a pre-existing Kenyan security over the award proceeds,’ the judge said.

The court joined COX in the case because its claim could be affected, but said joinder did not establish ownership or give it priority over Ecobank.

‘Joinder is not a final adjudication of substantive rights,’ the court said. COX’s claim remained subject to proof, and its participation was limited to the issues raised by Ecobank’s application.

The judge found that Ecobank had established a strong case and that the proceeds should be preserved. The court said the bank risked losing its remedy if the proceeds were released first.

The court barred Ketraco, its officers and agents from releasing any part of the award proceeds to Inabensa, COX or their agents until Ecobank receives pound 3.8 million (Sh547 million) and Sh1.5 million, or the sums are otherwise secured to its satisfaction.

Ketraco is required to pay the euro amount into Ecobank’s euro account and the shilling amount into an account held by the bank for Nyaanga and Mugisha Advocates. Payment will discharge Ketraco from liability for those sums.

Any rights COX may have in the award rank below Ecobank’s secured claim, the court found adding that any surplus can be resolved between Inabensa and COX by agreement or further court order.

Ketraco supported the arrangement, provided it received a proper discharge.

The order comes as Ketraco faces a separate liquidation petition over the award. Last month the court dismissed the utility’s preliminary objection, allowing Spanish company C.A. Infraestructuras T and I SLU to pursue its petition.

Instalaciones Inabensa SA was the original contractor and award holder, while C.A. Infraestructuras T and I SLU acquired its rights to the Ketraco award and subsequently changed its name to COX T and I SL.

Inabensa was declared bankrupt and dissolved in Spain, while its insolvency administrator, Ernst and Young Abogados, could assert rights over the award on behalf of creditors.

The liquidation petition, filed in May 2024, rests on C.A. Infraestructuras’ claim that it acquired Inabensa’s rights through a deed of subrogation dated July 28, 2023.

Ketraco disputed the claimant’s standing and argued that liquidation required Cabinet approval. The court left those questions for the substantive hearing.

The Attorney-General has warned of a risk that Kenya could face competing claims to the same debt.

Earlier Inabensa had obtained orders affecting 17 Ketraco bank accounts, while C.A. Infraestructuras pursued liquidation separately. The competing proceedings raised questions over the legal authority of each claimant and the safeguards needed to prevent duplicate recovery.

In a separate ruling delivered in November 2025, the High Court dismissed Ketraco’s application for Sh185.3 million in security for legal costs, describing the decree as final, binding and enforceable.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *