Mbadi backs law change to shield banks from billions in loan refunds

Treasury Cabinet Secretary John Mbadi has backed the removal of his office from approving interest rate changes in the review of the Banking Act, shielding lenders from refunding borrowers billions of shillings for illegal loan charges.

CS Mbadi reckons that the Central Bank of Kenya (CBK), and not the Treasury, should approve changes to commercial bank interest rates given its capacity for oversight and enforcement.

Section 44 of the Banking Act states that ‘no institution shall increase its rate of banking or other charges except with the prior approval of the Minister.’

CBK and banks recently held talks on the overhaul of the Banking Act and amending section 44 of the law.

The overhaul of Section 44 of the Banking Act is seen as a silver bullet to end litigation against banks over their failure to get approval from the National Treasury when amending interest rates to borrowers.

The High Courts rejected a petition from the bankers’ lobby- the Kenya Bankers Association (KBA)-to declare Section 44 of the Banking Act unconstitutional.

This followed judgments that Stanbic Bank and Spire Bank breached the law after changing their lending rates without approval from the Treasury.

Stanbic was ordered to refund a customer over Sh10 million, and Spire was compelled to reduce an outstanding loan balance in judgments that sent shockwaves through the banking sector, sparking fears of an avalanche of suits.

Mbadi has termed Section 44 of the Banking Act a ‘mistake’ while backing the move to remove the role of the National Treasury in approving changes to lending rates.

‘We have supported the case that it should be the role of the Central Bank. Only the CBK has the capacity for oversight and checking compliance,’ CS Mbadi told the Business Daily in an interview last week.

‘I think it was a mistake, in my view, to legislate the powers to the Cabinet Secretary. How would I oversee banks in terms of changes to interest rates?’ Mbadi posed.

Banks have been receiving approvals from the CBK before increasing lending rates on the back of a May 2006 legal notice, which then Minister for Finance Amos Kimunya officially delegated the consent powers to the Central Bank governor.

The Supreme Court of Kenya in the Stanbic suit and the High Court over Spire Bank separately ruled that the legal notice did not absolve the Treasury CS from legal responsibility.

The bankers’ lobby revealed in September that its members are engaging the CBK over an overhaul of the Banking Act.

KBA is currently seeking to squash Section 44 of the Banking Act at the Court of Appeal.

The courts ruled that the variation of loan interest terms without the involvement of the CS was illegal and unenforceable after scores of borrowers sued.

This risks opening the floodgates of suits against banks over loan terms after high lending rates have partly triggered defaults.

Banks see the overhaul of the Banking Act through Parliament to be a cure to the ensuing court disputes over loan pricing adjustments.

‘The CBK Governor has indicated that we have got to a point where we need to comprehensively review the Banking Act,’ said Raimond Molenje, KBA chief executive officer.

‘What we need to do is to embed the current risk-based credit pricing framework into the Banking Act to remove the requirement of getting approvals from the National Treasury Cabinet Secretary. That would cure the politics over who gets to approve changes in bank rates between the Treasury and CBK.’

Santowels, a sanitary towel manufacturer, was the first to test the interpretation of Section 44 of the Banking Act, falling out with Stanbic Bank Kenya over what it said was the varying of interest rates to levels it felt were unjustified.

The firm moved to court in 2003, arguing that the bank unilaterally varied interest rates without seeking the Treasury’s approval, and charged it Sh17.25 million in extra interest from several loans contracted between 1993 and 1997.

The suit escalated from the High Court to the Court of Appeal, and finally the Supreme Court, which determined, in June last year, that interest rates on loan facilities advanced by banks are subject to regulation under Section 44 of the Banking Act, requiring prior approval from the National Treasury Cabinet Secretary.

Spire Bank was previously found to have breached the law after varying interest rates on a customer loan without Treasury approval, after which it was compelled to reduce an outstanding loan balance.

Stanbic was also forced to refund a customer over Sh10 million.

In court, KBA said it was not asking for the re-interpretation of Section 44, but to determine whether the provision, as interpreted by the Supreme Court, is consistent with Article 231 of the Constitution, which guarantees the independence of the CBK as a key national institution.

CBK has largely stayed on the sidelines as commercial banks battle borrowers in court over the interpretation of section 44 of the Banking Act.

The apex bank, however, differed with the Supreme Court judgment, saying it expected lenders to vary loan rates immediately when it revises the Central Bank Rate (CBR).

CBK Governor Kamau Thugge recently told bankers that monetary policy decisions are independent and should be implemented directly by banks without going through the National Treasury.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *