Victoria Commercial Bank has lost its bid to revive criminal proceedings against the directors of the popular Nyama Mama Restaurant over an alleged Sh520 million loan fraud after the High Court dismissed its application.
The court rejected the lender’s application seeking to overturn the decision by Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Renson Ingonga to withdraw charges against Jayesh Shanghavi, his wife Nina Shanghavi and their company, Good Earth (Group) Ltd, saying the bank had failed to produce the decision it was challenging.
The judge said in a judgment on November 9 that references in pleadings and submissions to the alleged contents of the decision could not substitute for the actual document, whose substance and legal effect had not been established through clear and uncontested evidence.
‘Equally, judicial notice cannot be invoked to supply the contents of an unproduced document,’ the court said.
The court said that without the impugned decision or a satisfactory explanation for its non-production, it would be forced to infer its contents from secondary accounts, undermining the purpose of the law.
The dispute dates back to 2015 when the Shanghavis, directors of Good Earth, approached Victoria Commercial Bank for credit facilities to finance their business operations.
The bank says over the years, it extended working capital, overdraft, term loan and guarantee facilities running into hundreds of millions of shillings, secured through various properties, debentures, share pledges and personal guarantees.
Victoria Commercial Bank alleged that the couple had used deceptive means to secure the additional facilities while withholding the security document.
Following investigations, the DPP charged the couple and their company in 2021 with obtaining security by false pretences, contrary to Section 314 of the Penal Code.
The prosecution alleged that between December 10, 2018 and November 23, 2020, they induced the bank to execute a charge over an apartment to secure a loan of Sh520 million. The charges were dismissed as the DPP, following a review of the evidence, concluded that the dispute was commercial in nature and suited for determination through civil proceedings.
A Milimani court allowed the withdrawal on July 11, 2024, under Section 87(a) of the Criminal Procedure Code.
The bank, however, challenged the decision, arguing that the DPP had abruptly terminated the case without identifying new evidence, supervening circumstances or any material change to justify the move.
The DPP and the directors opposed the application, maintaining that the prosecution was discontinued lawfully after a review established that the evidence did not meet the threshold for sustaining the charges.
It maintained that the prosecution had previously investigated the matter, approved the charges and successfully defended its decision to prosecute after the Shanghavis unsuccessfully challenged the case through judicial review proceedings.
The bank further argued that the existence of civil proceedings and the alleged insufficiency of evidence did not justify terminating the criminal case.
They argued that the DPP was constitutionally empowered to review and discontinue prosecutions and that the bank remained free to pursue its commercial claims through civil proceedings.
The directors also maintained that the criminal proceedings had been initiated for extraneous purposes and that the lender had suffered no actionable injustice from their withdrawal.
They argued that the proper remedies available to a dissatisfied complainant included challenging the trial court’s order through an appeal or pursuing private prosecution.
The latest decision comes weeks after the High Court in Kiambu quashed a separate decision by the DPP, contained in an April 2026 letter, directing that criminal proceedings against the petitioners be registered afresh and that they be presented for plea-taking.