Private capital or public funds: The costs of expanding Lagos rail

A proposal by a Lagos State governorship candidate to attract private investment into the state’s rail infrastructure has sparked a debate over its feasibility and the state’s funding for delivering large-scale urban rail projects.

Gbadebo Rhodes-Vivour, the African Democratic Congress (ADC) governorship candidate, during the Lagos State governorship candidates’ debate, proposed using infrastructure finance companies to fund rail expansion, with repayment spread over 30 years.

Rhodes-Vivour said he had met with corporations capable of financing and delivering the rail projects within two and a half years, adding that they were seeking an open, private-sector-driven procurement process to ensure competitive bidding and value for money.

‘The arrangement would free up government resources for transportation subsidies targeting vulnerable residents, including pensioners and elderly people,’ he said.

However, Obafemi Hamzat, the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate, questioned the feasibility of relying on private investors to finance real construction, arguing that the government must first invest in the infrastructure before considering concessions to private operators.

Hamzat recalled that the state government spent three years under former governor Babatunde Fashola seeking private investors to finance the Blue and Red rail lines without success. He also warned that relying on passenger fares alone to recover investment could make train services unaffordable.

The disagreement highlights a wider financing concern for Lagos as it seeks to expand its rail network, specifically how the state can attract long-term private capital without shifting financial risk to taxpayers and commuters.

Lagos’ rail investment requirements

Lagos currently operates sections of its Blue and Red rail lines, with further extensions planned to improve connectivity across the state.

The Blue Line operates between Marina and Mile 2, with a N750 fare, while the Red Line connects Agbado to Oyingbo across 27 kilometers and eight stations, with a full trip fare of N1,000.

Plans to extend the Blue Line towards Okokomaiko, with additional stations at FESTAC, Alakija and Trade Fair, are ongoing and expected to open in February 2027. Work is also underway on further phases of the Red Line.

The state also expanded its Strategic Transport Master Plan from six to 11 rail lines and one monorail, reflecting its ambition to develop a wider mass transit network.

Other proposed rail corridors under the master plan include the 68-kilometre Green Line, the 85.7-kilometre Purple Line, the 48-kilometre Orange Line and the Yellow Line.

Why private financing may not work

Ethiopia’s railway expansion offers an example of how governments can combine different financing instruments to fund large-scale transport infrastructure. The country relied on commercial syndicated loans, export-credit financing and concessional lending from foreign financial institutions to develop its railway network.

In one arrangement, Ethiopia secured an $865 million financing package for the Awash-Weldia/Hara Gebeya railway project, comprising a $450 million commercial loan and a $415 million export-credit-backed facility involving agencies from Sweden, Denmark and Switzerland.

Turkey’s Turk Eximbank also provided $300 million in parallel financing for Turkish goods and services under the project. Separately, China’s Export-Import Bank pledged $3 billion to support the Addis Ababa-Djibouti railway, while India’s Exim Bank approved a $300 million concessional loan for a proposed railway connection to Djibouti’s Tajourah port.

The financing arrangements illustrate how commercial lenders, export-credit agencies and bilateral development institutions can support railway construction.

Opeyemi Ajetunmobi, an infrastructure finance expert, said private sector participation in Lagos rail development is commercially achievable but requires a financing structure beyond recovering construction costs through passenger fares.

Ajetunmobi explained that although Lagos offers significant passenger demand potential because of its population density, urbanisation, and traffic congestion, high ridership does not automatically translate into sufficient revenue to repay billions of dollars in infrastructure investment.

A report by Samuel Taiwo Olabosinde and Samson Adelusi Oludele, titled ‘Innovative Financing Strategies for Urban Transport Infrastructure: Evidence from Lagos, Nigeria,’ showed how financing of urban infrastructure has evolved from sole reliance on government budgets and aid to more diversified arrangements globally.

‘Key mechanisms include Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs), infrastructure bonds, Land Value Capture (LVC), and multilateral or development bank financing. These tools harness private sector efficiency, risk-sharing, capital market access, and international expertise to improve infrastructure delivery.

‘Developed countries have institutionalised these strategies in large-scale transport projects. For example, London’s Crossrail and Seoul’s subway expansions have utilised PPPs and LVC, while multilateral support has backed mass transit systems in Nairobi and Dhaka,’ the report stated.

Ajetunmobi recommended a blended finance structure, combining public investment, private capital and development finance, supported by project-specific Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs).

‘Under this arrangement, the government could finance strategic enabling infrastructure while private investors participate in commercially viable components such as rolling stock, signalling systems, station facilities, maintenance and railway operations,’ he said.

Looking beyond passengers to recoup investment

Ajetunmobi said Lagos must avoid relying exclusively on passenger fares to recover private investment, recommending alternative revenue sources that could improve the commercial viability of railway projects.

He identified LVC and transit-oriented development as significant opportunities, explaining that improved rail accessibility can increase commercial residential property values around stations.

‘The state could generate revenue through long-term land leases, property development partnerships, commercial concessions, and agreed shares of development proceeds.

‘However, he warned that government guarantees and unconditional commitments to investor returns could transfer commercial risks back to taxpayers, creating long-term financial liabilities,’ Ajetunmobi said.

The ability of Lagos to attract private investment into rail infrastructure will depend on the financing structure, allocation of risks, and availability of revenue beyond passenger fares.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *