De Lima: End criminal libel, protect speech

‘STOP treating speech as a crime.’ House of Representatives Senior Deputy Minority Leader Leila de Lima issued this call as she filed a bill seeking to decriminalize libel and oral defamation, replacing criminal prosecution with a civil action framework.

The measure, House Bill 11842 or the ‘Libel Decriminalization and Civil Defamation Act of 2026,’ follows the high-profile October 24 arrest of 73-year-old journalist Philip Lustre Jr. over a cyber libel warrant issued by a Davao City court-for a complaint he claimed he never received. It also comes on the heels of recent libel and cyber libel complaints filed against a television network and its journalists.

‘Veteran journalist Philip Lustre Jr.’s arrest is the latest reminder that criminal libel punishes long before any verdict is handed down,’ de Lima said, noting that detention, bail, and traveling to far-flung courts burden the accused regardless of the case’s outcome.

‘Instead of protecting reputations, criminal libel is now being weaponized to silence journalists and truth-seekers,’ the former Justice Secretary added.

If enacted, HB 11842 will repeal the provisions on libel and oral defamation under the Revised Penal Code, as well as cyber libel under the Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012 or Republic Act 10175.

Instead of jail time, the bill establishes a civil law framework anchored on the Civil Code to address harmful statements through proportioned monetary damages and civil remedies. Extortion through the threat of publication, however, will remain a criminal offense.

‘Let us be clear: This measure does not ask the State to stop caring about people’s reputations. Honor will still be protected in civil courts, enforcing effective and proportionate remedies,’ de Lima explained.

De Lima emphasized that the current framework creates a chilling effect that threatens press freedom and public participation.

‘The vigor of our democracy lies in our people’s ability to speak truth to power, hold public figures accountable, and participate in meaningful conversations,’ De Lima said. ‘Journalists and ordinary citizens alike have learned that one post, article, column, or broadcast can set off years of litigation in a court far from home. Complaints filed by those in power can silence truth-seekers… This has to end.’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *