GOVERNMENT money put into joint research with companies and universities can draw in more private investment and generate spillovers worth 2.6 times the original spending, according to Swedish officials who promoted the country’s Triple Helix innovation model to the Philippines.
Jakob Rehme, a professor of industrial economics and management at Linköping University, said the model contributes to economic output through three channels over different time frames.
‘When you have this type of spending, it actually creates high wages… that trickles down into the entire economy, so that’s like GDP impetus for that,’ Rehme said in a roundtable interview at the Embassy of Sweden.
In the medium term, he said, public innovation spending pulls in private money through what economists call a crowding-in effect.
‘If you add 10 percent from that type of investment, so like a government investment, then you get an additional 5 to 6 percent coming in from the private sector,’ he said, citing studies on the subject.
The largest gains come over the longterm through the spread of knowledge and skills, which Rehme called spillover effects.
‘We had studies, but that was in the defense sector, and then you had an additional 2.6 times the money that you put in,’ he said. ‘If you invest 1 billion, you get an additional 2.6, because of knowledge and competence that spreads throughout the society, and you develop technology that could be used in completely different applications.’
Asked how much the model could add to Philippine GDP if adopted, Rehme declined to give a figure.
‘That really depends. It’s so different,’ he said.
Swedish Ambassador to the Philippines Anna Ferry pointed to the development of the Gripen E fighter jet as an example of such spillovers.
‘It’s not just having a better multi-role fighter. You develop new composite material, new technology sensors, things that can be used also by other industries,’ Ferry said. ‘These spillover effects are a variety of things, both in the short run and in the long run. For us, it’s been critical to create our society.’
Mission first
The Triple Helix model brings together government, academia and industry to solve a specific problem.
‘It’s really about identifying a societal challenge or need, and then crowd in minds and money to find solutions,’ Ferry said.
She cited Sweden’s response to the oil price shocks of the 1970s, when the government classified dependence on imported oil and gas as a national security issue. Over the decades that followed, researchers, government and industry invested in energy-efficient technologies and alternative power sources.
Ferry said the process has to leave room for failure.
‘In innovation, you have to allow for mistakes, and then lessons learned, and then you build a new project and you try out. That’s how you evolve,’ she said.
The Swedish officials said the model is different from a public-private partnership (PPP), which Rehme described as closer to procurement.
‘Public-private is maybe more at the operational level. This is really to develop new working processes, but it can also be new technologies,’ Ferry said, citing a project to build a mine that is safer, more efficient and less polluting.
‘Just start’
On how the Philippines could institutionalize the model, Ferry said each country has to design its own structure.
‘In the Swedish governance model, we have very small ministries, and then we have bigger national authorities, agencies. That’s how we do it, but you have to find your governance model,’ she said.
She said Sweden’s innovation agency has handled about 22,000 projects since it was created in 2001. To qualify, projects must involve at least one university and one private company.
Researchers in Sweden also own the intellectual property (IP) from their own work rather than their universities.
‘If you have personal interest in it, then you also tend to start companies,’ Ferry said.
Rehme said the model started as an informal handshake between government and the private sector and was never codified into law. Ferry credited Sweden’s high level of public trust.
‘Trust is very high in Sweden, trusting in government institutions, between people,’ she said.
She urged the Philippines not to wait for ideal conditions.
‘The key message was also just to start, to start creating projects, and then you learn from that, and then you create also the capability of collaborating between different parties,’ Ferry said.
Private sector carries the load
Emil Akander, VP and head of region for Asia-Pacific at Business Sweden, said about 70 percent of research funding in Sweden comes from the private sector in some form.
‘We have a very small market in Sweden. So our companies needed to become international early on, and to become international you need to be competitive,’ Akander said.
He noted that exports still account for half of Sweden’s GDP.
Ferry cited the Wallenberg AI, Autonomous Systems and Software Program (WASP), a privately funded initiative that will finance well over 700 PhDs.
‘Private sector can actually fund PhDs at the university. That solves also the problem of funding,’ she said.
Investments continue
Ferry said around 60 Swedish companies or brands are present in the Philippines. She noted that pharmaceutical firm AstraZeneca announced last year that it will invest P7 billion in an innovation hub in the country from 2026 to 2028.
The hub will be located at the Knowledge, Innovation, Science and Technology (KIST) Park at the De La Salle University Laguna campus.
‘That is really also the embryo, I think, of creating a kind of Triple Helix site in the Philippines,’ Ferry said.
She said Swedish companies remain bullish on the Philippine market despite slower growth and the oil price shock.
She cited the country’s macroeconomic fundamentals, talent pool and work culture, as well as the expected conclusion of the European Union (EU)-Philippines Free Trade Agreement (FTA).
‘When you work with Sweden and Swedish companies, it’s not like a quick win in and out,’ she said. ‘It doesn’t really matter if one quarter it’s a bit lower, slower growth, because the potential is enormous in this country in the long run.’
Akander acknowledged that the Middle East oil crisis will weigh on short-term perceptions.
‘We haven’t seen the full effects yet, but they will come,’ he said.
He added that there are ‘not that many growth prospects in the world’ and that the Philippines is one of the few.